1

Wow. What a misogynist post.

Earrings thrown at you?

I'll see anything with Kristen Stewart in it, even though the make-up looks lame and has that whole vague homoerotic vibe of an Ambercrombie and Fitch store.

Andrew Wickliffe on May 2, 2008

2

that's of course meant in jest Andrew but I think it's safe to say the majority of the material's followers is female

Kevin Powers on May 2, 2008

3

How disgusting, Kevin.
Grow up a little.

E on May 2, 2008

4

Thanks for keepin' it real, Kev! The only way I'd go see this bullshit is if my little neice had my balls in a vise grip and dragged me. Looks like they took 6 of the whitest, blandest actors they could find and made them up to be even paler and homo-goth. A&F store indeed!

kevjohn on May 2, 2008

5

Haha "How disgustin, Kevin." NERD.

I haven't heard about the book or the author til' right now. I also refrain from watching MTV since they no longer show MUSIC on the MUSIC TELEVISION CHANNEL.

Les on May 2, 2008

6

Is that what this Twilight crap is about? I was looking silent vampire films up on IMDB and there was all these postings about Twilight on there! Don't believe me. Go to IMDB, look up Alice Guy's Vampire (1920), first post. Enough for me to boycott Twilight.

Christopher Goudos on May 2, 2008

7

Well, it just goes to show that if you haven't educated yourself, you don't know what you're talking about. I know some college guys that are eating up these books (having to go to the store and buy the next one after they've read the first). Seems like you're being put into the category of 'Harry Potter is evil because my minister says so, and I know it's so, even though I haven't read the books'. Go educate yourself, man, so you don't sound so ignorant. The book ain't half-bad.

first_time_user on May 2, 2008

8

umm…if you're talking about educating myself on the demographics of the story, I have. even the book's publisher states as much: "Stephenie has tapped into a new level of yearning in teenage girls." this is why I'm curious what the guy fans have to say. where are they in this conversation? and what's a minister?

kevin powers on May 2, 2008

9

I've read and enjoyed all the books. While the story is accessible to and marketed towards teenage girls (and their mothers), it does not exclude anyone from enjoying it. My problem with your post is that you cast aspersions on the books and movie without any foreknowledge of the contents. The book actually does sound silly when you read the basic premise, but there is definitely something compelling in the telling. It's just really hard to take your article seriously when you start as a basic premise with, "I haven't read this series, but here is why it sucks." Your credibility is completely non-existent at that point.

David on May 2, 2008

10

we all have our own oppinions

amanda on May 2, 2008

11

I think you should read the book before you say anything bad about it.. How can you say bad things when you havn't even read the book?!? O.o

Charlotte on May 2, 2008

12

This photo makes me mucho happy.

But how DARE you critique Twilight, when I doubt you have even read it? I don't see how you het "A&F store" out of this.


I love Twilight.


I hate A&F.

End of story.


Thank you for reading.

Sylvia. on May 2, 2008

13

to clarify, I'm not casting some widespread judgment on the written material, per se. I've simply seen a lot of what the movie seemingly has to offer, considering the videos & vignettes & news out, and feel pretty comfortable in deciding this isn't my cup to tea (for the stated reasons). if you want to extend that to some opinion of the source material, well…there's nothing I can do about that. keep in mind, this is a movie site, as well, so my opinion rests within that realm.

kevin powers on May 2, 2008

14

Last I read, Robert Pattinson was considering writing a song for the movie and if that happens, then the powers that be will consider using it. Yikes, your article is a perfect example of the telephone game. This book series definitely falls into the category of "need to read it to understand it." Many fans admit that they were skeptical at first. Don't know if the movie will be decent or not.

Sheri on May 2, 2008

15

Yeah sure, the story plot sounds redundant and corny when you sum it up, but how can one sum up a story that is so large? (remember people its a freakin adaptation)
If one condensed it into a few paragraphs it would surely sound like some lame ass movie.

**You haven't read the DAMN books so why write a blog about why you WOULD NOT watch it? It just doesn't make sense to me (and prob. to other people as well).**

Sure the twilight fan base is VERY VERY large, but what does that matter? isn't that a good thing?
and… so what if MTV is providing us with great behind-scene-footage. I personally think its awesome that Twilight is getting attention.

you should see the movie on December 12 before you write something so grotesque and idiotic as this.

Esther on May 2, 2008

16

If you really want to know what guys think of this, please go to twilightguy.com. He has an open mind about this and is actually trying to understand. Go see if it convinces you. And really–you should try to read this book. Edward is the new standard from which all the girls will be measuring their boyfriends with. It pays to know what makes Edward tick with the chicks.

Tisha on May 2, 2008

17

Seriously i know its been mentioned, but you can't talk trash about something you haven't even read. Given, the book is more of a love story pointed toward chicks but its not a bad read. I made fun of the story line a bit and then Tiff gave it to me to read and i made fun no more. It's not harry potter good but its pretty damn close. That and Alice is just ridiculously hot. so read the book and then write an article. i read it over night so it shouldn't take a professional that long.

MIchael on May 2, 2008

18

The whole discussion going on in the comments remind me of that woman speaking ill of that video game (mass effect?) without having played it first. This movie, however, looks like emo-girly Harry Potter. It could of course turn out to be something outstanding, but there are some things you can judge from the cover of a book, and that is the target audience.

Korinthian on May 2, 2008

19

Okay, listen up.

I know you wanted a guys opinion but oh well.

Twilight is an amazing book. The storyline is great and the descriptions of the characters, setting and such are fantastic. I know everyone is entitled to their own opinion, but it annoys me SO much when people say negative things about the book without having already READ the book. Once you've read the book then you can say you absolutely hate it or whatever.

What bothers me most is that many guys don't want to read the book and say the book sucks when they haven't read it, simply because there's romance in the story. My own boyfriend won't read it because of that. Just because there's some romance doesn't mean that Twilight is a bad book.

All in all, Twilight is a great book, so please, read the book before you make judgements about it.

Tiffanie on May 2, 2008

20

even as a girl i thought the premise of the books was stupid when i first heard it..i read and i really enjoyed…BUT i totally see where you're coming from..the movie does kind of look like and A&F commercial for the pastey haha ..i respect your opinion..and i too wonder where ARE all the guys ..we know they're here somewhere

El on May 2, 2008

21

When I first read your little article, I was an angry Twilight fan. But then I paused for a second and realized that I had my doubts about it being that popular with the guys. It's a love story but from what I heard, they are making it more into an action flick so that it'll be marketed towards men too. An actress who plays in the movie said something along the lines that it can't all be about a love story (where's the enjoyment in that?), and that they need to have more action in there too. So maybe instead of boycotting it, you can go see it and if you don't like it then you express your opinions on this website. (Sorry, I'm a girl but I just couldn't hold my opinion back)

Karen on May 2, 2008

22

Haha. I love the attention this movie is getting.
I love the series, but I guess I don't understand why the guys are already in an uproar about how dumb and girly it's going to be.
Typical male.
Everyone may have their own opinion, but I promise you I will value it more so if you decide to read the books and then post how odd the fandom is for being obsessed.

The book sat on my night stand for two months before I would read it. I was thinking how weird it was that a human would fall in love with a vampire. No thank you. But I really loved it.

AND the books were not written focused on being YA novels.
Since there was no sex in them, and the characters are teenagers it became YA.

I encourage you to read it and write again.
Perhaps you're opinion will not have chnaged at all, but at least then you can say "told ya so!"
Right?

Heather on May 2, 2008

23

I do agree with you on some level that I wouldn't see a movie IF the summary and whatnot was horribly written… or too simple to catch my interest. However, I think you should give this one a chance.

Twilight (and Stephenie's other books) does centralize around romance, but there are a broad range of subjects that also make up Meyer's central message, such as morality, religion, friendship, etc. The characters in the story aren't the shallow vampires one would usually see or hear. Stephenie has that charm that pulls her readers into the character's life and thoughts and shows them that these vampires are so much deeper and real; they can be so relatable to anyone. Yes, the summary of this book can repulse you. It did for me. I thought: "Ugh… vampires!" Being such a huge fan of the book now, I can assure you that I have been proven wrong.

As for the movie, seeing that Twilight adaption is "extremely loyal" to the book, without a doubt, if you decide to read the series, most likely, the movie will interest you.

Jessica on May 2, 2008

24

It's really funny how it changed from guy posts to mainly girl posts by the middle.

I personally like all three of the books a lot and I'm looking forward to the 4th book and the Twilight movie as much as anyone else who loves them. You should give it a chance though because the movie's not supposed to be as gushy as the books; more fast-paced. And I know a lot of girls that don't like it, and a lot of girls that refuse to give it a chance, but really, it's your call.

Radhika on May 2, 2008

25

OH MY GOD!!! I love the picture it totally perfect!! Robert and Kristen are the perfect Edward and Bella. I can't wait for the movie!!!!!!

Imaan on May 2, 2008

26

I have to agree. We (the readers) are aware that this is, in fact, a movie site. But since most movies ARE judged by how closely they relate to the corresponding book (ex: HP, Lord of the Rings, Eragon, The Golden Compass, etc.), wouldn't you find it a bit more helpful to actually read the book before writing it off altogether? Makes you look just a tad less judgmental if you have every piece of the puzzle together.

In your defense, I agree that the target audience is teenage girls. But the target audience for Harry Potter was probably (at the beginning) children, however, we've seen that many generations, genders, races, and whatnot have got something out of it in the long run, myself included. Keep in mind that it's no Harry Potter, but it's certainly not bad and there's something addictive about it.

Just a little FAQ: I loaned my copy of it to my History Professor and he enjoyed it quite a bit. He went in with a certain mind-frame about the book and after he read it, he was asking me what the title of the sequel was and told me that it was different than he expected.

Carissa on May 2, 2008

27

Why don't you fucking read the book before you write such a ridiculous and non-credible article!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?!?

C on May 2, 2008

28

OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
OMG!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

This is like my FREAKING BIRTHDAY! It's AWESOME!

Ummmm..... Alice Cullen! on May 2, 2008

29

OK, the problem I have with this article is that it blends the books with the movie. They'll be pretty different, so I think that they should be judged separately Sure, you don't have to like the books–but don't discount them because you don't like the looks of the movie.

Maddy on May 2, 2008

30

Also, isn't this a Anitha Blake rip-off?

Korinthian on May 2, 2008

31

You don't have a clue as to what this movie is about, or all of the hype surrounding it. Let me fill you in. You already know what it's about in general, but you don't know how big Twilight is going to be. I, being a hardcore obsessed fan, know that we've been following the making of this movie from the very beginning. We pounce on every single bit of news and updates. The release of this promo picture made people all over the world shriek with happiness. There's much more to Twilight than just a girl falling in love with the vampire. There's an intense struggle between life, death, and ultimately love. Okay, I know that sounds cheesy, and if you're a guy you probably won't feel the same way. But you also get to watch some vampire fight scenes that I'm sure will be freaking sweet. Yes, the majority of the fanbase is female. But we have a fair share of guy fans too. Twilight isn't your average teenage love/vampire romance novel. There's originality. Stephenie's (or our) vampires don't have fangs. They don't burn in the sun, they glitter (read the book before you start laughing), and they are all breathtakingly beautiful. We don't just love the books, were in love with the characters. They all seem so real and they all have their own histories and everything. So when we found out about the making of the Twilight movie, we (the millions of fans), freaked. We've reacted reasonably well to the casting choices for the "perfect" vampires. Oh and they're SUPPOSED TO BE PALE. Read the books. Anyway… fans have been visiting the sets from day one, getting pictures with the cast, and reporting on every little detail. We're passionate about this book, and the director Catherine Hardwike knows that. She's worked very hard to make it just as amazing, if not more, than words on a page. If you want to know more (which you should), check out these sites:
http://www.twilightlexicon.com
http://www.hisgoldeneyes.com
http://www.twilightmoms.com
http://www.thetwilightteens.freeforums.org
http://www.twilightviniculum.com
http://www.bellaandedward.com,
and most importantly http://www.stepheniemeyer.com.

I hope that covers what you need to know. :]

Priscilla on May 2, 2008

32

dude, maybe I'm not girly enough, maybe I expect MORE from children's books, but I HATED Twilight.

Yes, I read it. Oh I enjoyed it, for the same reason I enjoy Glitter. IT WAS AWFUL. I tried to count how many times Edward was alluded to as DANGEROUS and MYSTERIOUS. I lost track. and Bella? How stupid is this girl? "Ooooh look at that sexy really pale dead guy! Let me walk right into his fangs!" Not to mention the part where she wanders aimlessly in a large city, stumbles into the 'ghetto' and HAPPENS to find thugs who want to rape her? WTF? I had to laugh. Not to mention the fact that the girl can't take care of herself, and constantly needs to be rescued. Um, excuse me? What happened to girls WITH a clue. This is like Regency romances written for young girls, giving them unrealistic expectations. You want REAL YA books? You want girls who actually have COMMON SENSE and the ability to WALK without falling into the arms of their undead lover? Try a Tamora Pierce novel, or the vastly underrated Patricia C. Wrede.

Lauren on May 2, 2008

33

ummm…

ever heard of "don't judge a book by its cover"???

whatever on May 2, 2008

34

So was there a hot rape scene or not? Or was there the standard knight in glittering armor moment we'd all expect?

Korinthian on May 2, 2008

35

No rape scene, but the 'knight' PHYSICALLY GLITTERS IN THE SUN. NO ARMOR NECESSARY.

Lauren on May 2, 2008

36

Sounds like some kind of Care Bear vampires wrapped in a story of a helpless princess pining for the tall dark and handsome man her mother tells her she isn't allowed to be with. I can't wait to see/read this.

Korinthian on May 2, 2008

37

21 year guy here, and to be honest, they're as bad as they look. The books are horribly written, the "plot" is laughable, and the comparisons to Harry Potter are completely and utterly insulting to J.K. Rowling. My dislike for it has nothing to do with the presence of the romance itself; it's the fact that it's badly written, unconvincing romance unsuccessfully disguised as "edgy" teen fantasy that really gets me.

Patrick on May 2, 2008

38

perdona tio pero soy un chico de diecinueva años de madrid, españa y a mi me encantan los libros

translation: sorry dude but im actually a 19 years old guy from madrid, spain and i like the books and i want to watch the film

i think you should read the books first

carlos_cruz on May 2, 2008

39

ummm….EXCUSE ME….!
What do you think you're talking about…?!!
you have no right to critique the twilight books or the movie when you haven't even read/watched it…..
i have read twilight and the rest of the series and thing they are the best things i have read and think that the movie will be great aswell….
alot of people including GUYS have read these books and know what they are saying "the books are the best"…..but you wouldn't because you haven't read them
how about you make yourself useful and go read the books an then come back here and write something that isn't so pathetic
the picture is awesome by the way…it just gets me more excited…..the "TWILIGHT" movie will be awesome!
and as for you i think you're going to get more than just earrings thrown at you….

sarah jones on May 2, 2008

40

OMG you're pathetic….
the books are awesome!
and guess what?!
ROBERT PATTINSON is hotter than you….moron!

emily_rox on May 2, 2008

41

okay
look i am a GUY
and kind of think this book is quite cool
so yeh!
and man can't wait for the kickass movie
it's gunna be cool as

chris on May 2, 2008

42

I can see where this kind of opinion comes from. I may not be a guy but it's not like all girls get giddy when they hear there's a book about vampires. I was definitely skeptical about this book. I thought it'd be a waste of time reading about vampires. I abhor science fiction. My friends got me to read this book and it definitely was compelling. I think I would respect your judgment better, if you at least tried to read Twilight. Who knows, maybe you won't like it even after you read it. But at least there's some support to your opinions. Or maybe you'll at least think that it's better than the movie, whether or not the movie IS BAD. I feel as though the movie may ruin or make the books better. Hopefully, better because seeing the cast has already ruined my image of the beloved characters. Try and experience reading this book, and THEN you will be able to state your opinions.
Thanks.

Cindy on May 2, 2008

43

Go here: twilightguy.com

Also check out the Twilight lexicon and look at the 'newbie' boards for all the guys… there are more than you'd think.. They say why they like it…

BUT… I will give you that I think this story is more appealing for women… It is a love story. BUT if you have go see a movie with a woman, i.e. a date, why not take her to an amazing love story that also has the action scenes, suspense, and blood lust that Twilight will offer? Won't both of you be happy?? Have you NEVER gone to see a movie with a woman before just because she wanted to see it? I guarentee we do it (yes I've seen my share of 'guy-flicks'), so I hope you offer it up to your significant other once in awhile…

Oh and why not see what all the fuss is about and actually READ the book…pick it up and read it…or give it a try, the first 100 pages or so and see if you are even interested…

Then write an article on what you thought. I guarentee we'd all be interested to hear it…

Melissa on May 2, 2008

44

i'll have to agree with Patrick on the fact that the book is poorly written and that it is no way as good as Harry Potter. i'm a teenage girl and i do think the plot is pretty silly, however there's something about it that i like. Even tough it sounds like just a love story, it's really not. I like the general story but the way it's written stinks. I love the characters though. It's very difficult not to like the story. I personaly enjoyed it a lot. As for the movie, i really hope there's a bit more action in it because it would be really boring other wise.
As for the writter of this article, you shoulod definately familiarise yourself with the story. I'm not saying read the book, because this is about the movie. But you should definately do some further research. Robert said he MIGHT write the song, they're going to have several of them written, and they'll choose the best. It's good to give Robert a chance just like you should give the movie a chance. Please INFORM YOURSELF!!!

Ellah on May 2, 2008

45

Wow, honestly, I feel sorry that some many people are inclined to quickly insult you on this article. What you said is very much the truth of things, by the way. Twilight's an extremely self-indulgent series, no one can deny that, it's like Fan-Fiction that had no typos and managed to get published. I do read the books and I am a fan, but barely, and only because this is admittedly my guilty pleasure. If it weren't for the Sci-Fi in it, I wouldn't have given it a second thought. The hype around it being "The Next Harry Potter" is also a load of bull, because if it was really good enough to knock JKR's work to one side, people wouldn't be constantly in the need to compare it. Rowling's is art that took years to complete into what it is, Meyer's looks like it was a day dream outcome of spending the night watching Bram Stoker's Dracula. It's totally understandable that the majority of fans are women as well, because hardly any men would want to know about how much Bella thinks her boyfriend Edward is oh-so cute. In fact, I had my fiance read the first book only so that when I get into these kind of rants, he can understand what on earth I'm talking about. I never expected him to honestly enjoy it, and I was right in thinking so. These books are good, but they're not that good.

Roxana on May 2, 2008

46

what the fuck is Twilight?…

Garrett.king on May 2, 2008

47

Ok so Im not gonna load down your wall with a bunch of…OMG….or…..WTF?..cause Im 23 and well your ears are probably already bleeding from the high pitched squeals you can hear when you read these comments. I however have read the series and enjoyed the books greatly for the reasons why so many people disliked it…it is a unrealistic love affair, a romeo and juliet of the underworld love story. On that note my boyfriend also read the series and while it has not replaced his Maxim mag. on the nightstand he did like the books as well and is eager to see the movie. From what i have seen and read about the movie it seems as thought they are trying to have it appeal some to guys with stunt work, fast cars, and pretty girls (not to bad looking at Kristen Stewart, Nikki Reed, and Ashley Greene for 2 hours). Anyways, all i have to say is give the book and the movie a shot, if you go in thinking "this is gonna suck" whats the worst that could happen..you actually like it?

Allie on May 2, 2008

48

Oh you messed with the wrong fandom dude.
Seriously nearly EVERY guy in my school has read this book!
It's amazing I was not quite sure of it but I was BLOWN away by the amazing action scenes.
Seriously GROW UP and READ THE DAMN BOOK!

Kendra Dumbledore on May 2, 2008

49

I understand the nausea that you must be experiencing due to all the sickly sweetness that's been appearing about the movie. But seriously, give it a shot you may find that you actually enjoy the books if not the movies (we all know how "well" often times books will be adapted into movies). And those Nomads you fear would disappear quickly might be around longer than you actually think, give it a try….maybe just not with your lunch, just in case.

Carolina on May 2, 2008

50

Oh I'd like to agree with someone else who said that not everyone is excited/intrigued by the Vampire aspect…

That is actually the thing that makes most people NOT want to read it… I just have to insist that its not as stupid as it SOUNDS…just try it…

And not a single person I've had read it didn't like it

So it's hard to explain why Twilight is so appealing… If you read it you might understand what we mean

Melissa on May 2, 2008

51

Okay, I am not going to blast you for this post, it's your opinion! Yay freedom of speech. I'm just replying to the twentysomething guy comment…

Check out http://www.twilightguy.com

It's pretty good!

Personally I can't wait for the movie release.

I still love this site!

Stephanie on May 2, 2008

52

Okay I know you want guy's POV but like I care.

I actually passed up Twilight many times. I hate fantasy type books, don't really care for love stories either. But after one my friend, A GUY I might add, told me that he was reading it I actually called him a prissy. He ended up punching me in a nose and forced me to read the books.

And really the entire series isn't about love. There is plenty of action in it, life lessons. Yes Bella does need to be saved all the time and is always in danager but reality check alot of children are constantly in danger.

And really want's wrong with reading a book that has been called a "teen flick"? If a guy reads pink, does that make him less of a man? I find that if a guy goes OUT of his comfort zone that it makes him more of a guy, not some ignorate jerk.

Ginger on May 2, 2008

53

I'm a guy. I read the books and liked them. I am pumped for the movie b/c I think it's going to be better than the book( for a guy)… it's going to actually have some action. I don't want to judge the movie fully until I see the trailer but I like Catherine Hardwick as a director and think she is going to do a good job. I also like the fact that summit is doing it instead of some big name that would cheese it up more than it already is.

Zeke on May 2, 2008

54

Well you do have your constitutional right to say what you want, but I am using the same right to say that you are a jackass. You are very unprofessional writing this article and not really doing your back up work. If you are to lazy to read a couple of books then how can anyone really ever take your work for serous?

Mary on May 2, 2008

55

Congrats on the discovery on how to find girls on the Internet. You should be able to make lots of money doing just that. And I think the comments have once and for all proved what the target audience is.

Korinthian on May 2, 2008

56

Kevin, I'm curious if you plan on reading the books now after reading all of the comments? I hope you read it and give us an update on what you think of it. Also, I'm really impressed by all of the early guy comments. There is no way any of my male friends would consider giving the book a try. I've enjoyed the series and I'm looking forward to the movie and the 4th book, which comes out in August.

Janet on May 2, 2008

57

Hi. I'm a girl and I have read the books.

They are fun to read and the whole thing is just a giant romance story (with action once in a while). But it is NOT very original and it does NOT have a lot of point. I've seen at least three anime series with all of the same aspects; humans who love vampires. The whole premise is "Everyone wants a piece of Bella, oh noes! What is she to do?"

It's like comparing Maggie Furey to Robin Hobb; Furey writes fantastically intricate and engaging stories, but they're just fluff and fun, Hobb writes intensely character motivated and humanly insightful novels.

Kevin, I think you're right. Guys (mostly) won't be interested in this movie. It's like something that Disney would produce. The poster is serious eye candy.

And does anyone else think that almost all of the fans of the books are rabidly defending their bible. A little too hysterical for me, thanks.

Nettle on May 2, 2008

58

yo! thanks for promoting this movie. you may talk shit about it, but atleast it's on your mind, and also every other ignorant person out there that can't read romances. after re-reading your opinioned article, you sounds like you're "afraid" to like Twilight, therefore, you smack-talk away like a shallow guy. it's okay, everyone's a bit ignorant sometimes, you just happened to openly expressed yours to people that will, and already have, openly bash(ed) you right back. don't be so quick-to-judge next time.

Alex on May 2, 2008

59

Dude you just brought a knife to a gun fight…Im a guy that read the books and actually enjoyed them. yea I got into it by yes a female telling me how good the books are. Also was warned that it is mainly directed towards female genre cause it is infact…from a females point of view. I took my chances and read the first book and i liked it…alot. Now im not as psyched up about the movie like my friend is but Im sure as hell goin to watch it. It looks like its gonna be pretty damn good. The books are very well written, and her helping with the movie is only gonnna make the movie that much better. My only concern about the movie getting this much publicity is that its being blown up to these great great expectations…which if you enjoy the books your gonna love the movie and it will be that good. But to the people that are just goin to see it they may not understand the concept and might not be as impressed as the rest of us going to watch it. Im gonna leave one more comment because im getting tired of typing about your ghey ass comments…Read the book before you decide to comment on something you know absolutely nothing about…and well you fail at life. My only hope is that they infact make it a 3 movie series like the books instead of trying to fit it all into one movie…gives the fans something to look forward to as being able to get into more detail and make it as close to the book as can be. Yet no movie has ever been as good as the book and thats mainly cause of the imagination factor. Im leaving now…go say hi to your gerbal for me…
XD

Basa on May 2, 2008

60

"I can just hear the clank of earrings being taken off as the throngs gear up for a fight."

Seriously.. what is the point of writing unfounded, insulting, pointless, whiney crap like this?

Kate on May 2, 2008

61

I agree with this basa guy, read the books before YOU think you can actually make any type valid opinon about Twilight. You set yourself up for such a bashing >_<

Lola on May 2, 2008

62

it's funny how combustible this topic is…let's go back to what I originally wrote: "I'm certainly not saying Meyers work is bad." so I'm not bashing the material, actually. I'm simply stating it's not for me. if folks construe that as me hating on the author's work…well, then, that speaks to something else. I wouldn't outright say Twilight sucks, b/c, of course, I haven't read the material, nor, more importantly, seen the movie yet. but I think I have enough of an idea of how the film will play out, that I can say its not my bag. it's as simple as that. (and again, this is a movie site, so I apologize for not being able to read the source material for EVERYTHING that hits the screen.)

but the mere fact that some folks are outright volatile on anything negative on the topic definitely makes me think twice about "joining" such a base. #54 gets at that type of discussion that's needed.

and #58 — relax. it was a joke. but the statement has definitely proven correct given some of the discourse here.

Kevin Powers on May 2, 2008

63

Okay I've already commented but here I go again in response to your latest post..

for the movie: Don't need to join our fan club, but I still don't see what would turn you off to seeing a 'chick flick with action in it.' Doesn't that equal perfect date movie?? Then both you and your date are happy people!

A lof of Twilight fanbase (and oh yes I am a rabid fan as well…just a rabid fan that is a bit older than a lot of the more vocal fans) is young and is very rash when they write comments back… you are entitled to your opinion.

As for the book, we REALLY would like to see you give it a try and tell us what you think. I guarentee you we'd all come back and read your articles…

Melissa on May 2, 2008

64

If you haven't read the book, to be honest, I dun really see why you are giving yourself the open right to just rant away and complain mate. lD These sods will flame you to a crisp.

hrm As far as why a sod would like or read the book…I read it for school, to be totally blunt. I don't like romance, and I do begrudge Meyer's for even comparing her book to Wuthering Heights or Romeo and Juliet, because come on, Mercutio doesn't exist in such a world. And WH was about Heathcliff, it wasn't in all trueness a love story. Anyway, the books actual "action" or "fight" sequences are rather vague, it's in female perspective, but whatever. Read Midnight Sun if you want the gory details.

Julian on May 2, 2008

65

Kevin: "relax. it was a joke. but the statement has definitely proven correct given some of the discourse here."

That's why you call a self-fulfilling prophecy, ain't it? Don't throw bait in the water if you don't expect fish to bite.

Korinthian on May 2, 2008

66

That's why = That's what*.

Korinthian on May 2, 2008

67

Wow…sorry you walked into this one, Kevin. For the record I'm with you. This looks like a CW drama that I'm going to avoid just to keep from having to bash it. I simply don't think I'm the target demographic.

As for reading the source material, I have a VERY limited amount of free time between working two jobs, doing a weekly podcast, playing games, catching up on comics and reading the series that I actually enjoy (Dresden Files, in this case) on top of spending time with my wife. I simply don't have the time to start another series that I seriously doubt I'll finish the first chapter of, let alone like. If Twilight gets a bunch of good buzz from people I respect, I may take the time to watch it on DVD.

I really think that Kevin would probably give it that same chance. Since this is a movie site that primarily caters to the film geek community, you really shouldn't be suprised that we'd rather read "Conversations with the Great Moviemakers of Hollywood's Golden Age: At the American Film Institue" than this series. I MAY give the movie a chance, like I did with Harry Potter. I still haven't read the books, but I've enjoyed the movies. It's a longshot (again, for me personally), but it's certainly possible that Twilight may end up the same way.

Like Kevin said, though, if this is the way fans of this series act, I'm much more inclined to steer clear completely. Seriously, you'd think that Kevin had taken a wizz all over a Bible or something.

SG Dave on May 2, 2008

68

@SG Dave #65: Lol, way too true, man.

Nettle on May 2, 2008

69

OK so here's MY question!


If you haven't read the Book, and dont plan to read or see the movie… why do you even waste your time writing about how badly it will or does suck!?
Seriously why waste your and MY time by writing negative stuff about it?

If u dont want to see teh movie, DONT!
dont waste your time telling people NOT to see or read the book series!

REaD IT FIRTS and then JUDge it… OR DONT EVEN!

Just dont waste a moment of your life tlking about something tht MILLIONS or more people are completely excited about.

Was your purpose to have an angry MOB behind you?! cuz u've done an AMAZING JOB!!!!

Gees what a waste of time uve made.

Laura on May 3, 2008

70

@ 67: And well-informed posts like this are going to make us change our minds. Really, spell check is your friend.

If there's one thing that every geek I've ever known has in common, it's that we're willing to give something a chance if we're given a reason to. The negative reaction is that this photo looks bad. I'm more than open to having a discussion, as long as it isn't, "OMG ur the sux0rs becuz you havnt red teh buk!"

Maybe this is a topic that should've been left alone, but 40 people essentially saying the same thing over and over and over isn't going to change anyone's mind. You want to know why I posted in this thread? It's because I got more annoyed with every single post I read. I decided to try to be as rational and explain how we work as a community so you can try to get your point across. If everyone wants to keep screaming how awesome this is, go for it. You're just going to galvanize a movement against it. For crying out loud, if someone even said, "Yeah, that picture is pretty bad, but the cast looks to be a great match for the books and it'll be worth checking out", that would be a start.

I look forward to a more civilized conversation, and I'll happily join in. Otherwise, I'll just stop by for a good laugh.

SG Dave on May 3, 2008

71

I'm not going to bite your head off because I can understand where you're coming from, but I agree with everyone else, you should read the books. I can't tell you if the movie is going to be worth it because I haven't seen it, but I'm personally excited about it. See the thing is, although I am a girl, I had no desire to read Twilight, or see the movie either. I thought they were only for young teenagers, and the fact that it was a vampire romance turned me off completely. Finally, a few weeks ago I picked up the first book and ended up reading all three in as many days. No, that doesn't mean you would like them or the movie. It is perfectly reasonable to say "That doesn't look like something I'd like" and you may even be right about that. But I do have to say the way you said that came off in a slightly offensive manner and that's coming from someone who hasn't been worshiping at the Twilight shrine for years. I do get that you were trying to be funny. And like I said, I get it. The premise sounds cheesy, the picture looks cheesy, and the fans seem way over the top not to mention everywhere. But there really are a lot of positives about the books (even some guys think so) and from everything I've read/seen the movie seems like it will be more than worth seeing. If you disagree, I 100% respect that but just like fans need to not respond to this article with "You don't like Twilight? Well, you suck!", not liking anything to do with Twilight (without having read the books, or obviously seen the movie) mostly because of how much OTHER people like it rubs people the wrong way. Hope this makes a little sense and doesn't annoy anyone further…

Taryn Lentes on May 3, 2008

72

I have a couple things I want to comment on. Alot of people are really angry that Kevin hasn't read the book but it's important to remember that he is only commenting on the movie because this is a movie website. Personally, I have seen plenty of movies without reading the source material. A great example of this is oh say every movie based on a comic book. All he wanted to know was what the readers of this site thought of it. On the other hand Kevin, I must admit that some of your comments did seem like you may have been intentionally trying to provoke fans. I only say that because there have been plenty of sites doing the same thing over the last few weeks. You have to admit that this all ready has a lot more comments then some of your older posts and I am curious if that was something you were trying to achieve with this.

I would hope that you and others would not let fan reactions dictate whether you try reading the first book or not. What attracted me so much to the series is that Meyer does something with vampires that I have never seen before. Her vampires don't have fangs, they don't turn to dust in the sun - they sparkle, and they don't sleep in coffins because they don't sleep at all! I was so fascinated by such a different take on something that has been done for years. It is really interesting if only for the creative value of it. I mean have you ever seen vampires without fangs? That's just clever. You don't have two neat holes in the neck because her vampires (the bad ones anyway) rip apart flesh and it's not neat or clean. Also, I want to let you know that a popular twilight fansite linked to this article and I think that's why there are a lot of intense fan comments coming in.

One last thing in response to the photo - you guys should check out the unofficial ones that are floating around because those are a lot worse.

Just my two cents. Now I'm done. Thanks!

Janet on May 3, 2008

73

Its not the point that hes trying to bash a fanbase or movie or anything like that #65. He hasnt read the books so he has no leg to stand on for what type of movie its goin to be and how crappy he thinks its going to be. People are passionate about this set of books. Im sure someone pisses on your comics or your wife (hopefully your passionate about and or with her at the same time) your gonna get upset and defend what you care about. People care about the book and the movie. some one attacks it they are going to go in defense mode. same way someone does about a loved one in trouble. #68 you already took the time to comment to bitch about everyone's well bitching or w/e. your a idiot wrapped in a moron… oh and im pretty sure no one cares that you are reading everyone's posts for fucking spelling errors.

Basa on May 3, 2008

74

Kevin, you sure seem opinionated about books you haven't read, this series is not your typical bloodsucker blather, the vampires headlining are resisting their baser urgers. The heroin is intelligent and homely there is no sex, less profanity and the theme seems to be that love grows when differences are embraced and obstacles overcome thru sacrifice. This is a refreshing change from the "me" generation's usual spew. God forbid our teenagers emmulate these characters. If the movie is as good as the book we may have a few possitive influences for our children.
P.S. chicks dig guys who will read what they'll read. It's not like they're asking you to recite the vagina monologues. Not every movie has to include guns, blowing stuff up, Keanu Reeves, and frontal female nudity. Plus this one will have more women in the audience than the Harold and Kumar crap most guys frequent.
P.P.S Don't you want to be the lone guy walking out of a theater full of horny 19 year old women at 10 o'clock at night? You do the math.

Jared on May 3, 2008

75

Im a HUGE Twilight Fan!!! This probably doesnt surprise you because im a 21 year old female. However, when my friend told me to read the books i looked at her in disgust. I read the first chapter and i was like youve got to be kidding me. i dont want to finish this book its so corny.
But I forcd myself to keep reading, and i found that Its not bad. Im not one for Romance or chick flicks. I dont waste my money on going to see a movie with a happy ever after movie. I would rather see blood and guts and lots of fight scenes. I dont read happy, love story books either. I think they are tacky and stupid. Im a down to earth person and live in reality not fantasy. I dont believe in 'and they lived happily ever after THE END'

But this book caught me by surprise. The thing is, even though its a romance story, its way more realistic… take out the vampires, and its just about dealing with loving someone and all the obstacles that you face. Its more about living life at 17, and going through puberty. It relates to girls because the main character is a girl and its her thoughts and feelings that your reading about. As for me i can read it and say, hey ive felt that, hey ive done that. Most 17 year old boys arnt going to care about that.

I personally think the movie could go both ways. Dont get me wrong, im really excited but look at reality. Kristen Stewart, she is an awesome actress, yet alot of the movies she has done arnt that great. Can she act this part without coming across corny? Robert Pattinson is a hearthrob, but so was Josh Hartnett, and please name a recent movie that hes done which was good?
And Catherine Hardwick… well ive seen a couple of her movies and they are ok, but nothing to scream over. Yet, she seems to have a really good handle on keeping the story line.

And again, its a book turned to movie. That rarely ends well. Lord of the Rings was a great movie, and kept to the story line, but yet so different. And lets not forget the Harry Potter phenomenon. I would say that about 90% of the people that I have talked to say that the movies arnt as good as the books. But i have never read the books and I do like the movies.
My POINT IS… I dont think saying at this early stage 'Its not my cup of Tea' without seeing anything substantial about he movie (the trailer isnt even out yet), and not reading the books, is Wise. My advise is take a look at the books, if you dont like them fair enough. there is nothing wrong with that. We all know what we do and dont like.My guy friends look at me like im nuts. But trust me, its not as corny as it looks.
And the movie, well we will just have to wait and see. but I have a feeling it will be worth seeing. Its a rare thing when the Author is involved in every step along the way. Im interested to see the difference it makes. but again, everyone is entitled to their own opinions, but I would advise to look deeper into the subject before making a judgment.
-J

J on May 3, 2008

76

umm….look i just want to say you are free to express you're opinion
but you cannot judge something without actually knowing what it's about
i personally think the book is great and think that the movie is going to be amazing aswell
so i think you should read the books before you can criticise it

kate on May 3, 2008

77

i totally agree with #73!

anonymous on May 3, 2008

78

This just goes to show that you need to read the book before you read it.
I know plenty of guys that love the Twilight series, and I think that before you judge something, you should find out what you're talking about and READ THE BOOK.
Please get over your own ignorance and read the book.
Twilight IS amazing, and, though the movie could never surpass the book (what movie ever does?), the movie will also be amazing.

Rin. on May 3, 2008

79

Meant to say "You need to read the book before you judge it" as the first line.

Rin. on May 3, 2008

80

ok so what is your point here really?
"i don't im not gonna watch this movie… is not my cup if tea bla bla bla …"
therefore what?
why criticize and bash about Twilight in such a negative way??????
yes is a movie website, but thats not what movie websites do… sooo not profeccionsal. =/

Maria on May 3, 2008

81

I read just a few comments alongside with the article.
I understand the author isn't' criticizing the books, though he does impale that the reason for that is because he thinks they're underneath his age (we're round the same age btw) and sex (where we differ).
Never mind that, we're talking about the movie right? Which he also haven't seen because it's not done yet.

Anyhow… why don't you wait for the movie to come out? There'll be quite a few wanna-be-different critiques who'll flame it then.

You don't have to like the book, you don't have to like the movie, you don't have to like the number of fans they both have. (You don't have to underestimate fans and judge them either when we're at it)

(By the way…good move! Your post already has round ten times more comments then your other posts and I guess the number will only grow. Actually, you made a pretty smart move with this critique… I must admit that.)

Rhin on May 3, 2008

82

hey everyone….just to respond to a couple of points:

a) thanks for those who have offered constructive commentary (you know who you are)

b) despite my lack of interest in seeing the movie, I'm still interested in Twilight as a topic in general; I think Meyer's background and the product she's created (not to mention the following generated) is pretty damn fascinating. considering that, and that there's folks that read this site that would be interested in this news, I posted the photo and my opinion, just like I did with the last article on the subject

c) also, I felt it worthwhile to "fess up" as it were, that I'm not really into the story at this point; that seemed a decent decision considering the swarm of support and Twilight mania going on; as #49 said, things have been a bit too "sickly sweet"

d) as for judging the movie prematurely, we do that all time, and usually with a lot less fodder to examine (e.g. just a poster or casting announcement); so forming an opinion right now is not at all unusual, especially since we've already seen a number of behind-the-scenes clips, interviews, etc.

and e) a couple of folks have mentioned since my time here at FS.net some nefarious scheme to incite controversy to get comments; that, of course, is not the case and this is genuinely my opinion (and I'm bringing this news forward for the reason states); but if we were being shady, do you think we'd want most of the comments here? I've, in fact, already deleted a few b/c they're outright vulgar

but in any event, thanks again to those folks who are positively contributing to the conversation. I might even take #63 up on her offer…of course between the many screenings every week, my day job and my two dogs…we all have priorities

kevin powers on May 3, 2008

83

I think Twilight rocks, I must admit when I first heard about it I blew it off, because I heard it was a love story. But I eventually read it anyway and just couldn't stop reading it. Now I'm counting down the days until Breaking Dawn, and am pretty hyped about the movie. Granted there are some parts of the books that get a little too lovey dovey (sp) but it's manageable. So yeah I'm not ashamed to say that I think Twilight is one of the best books I've ever read.

Chris S on May 3, 2008

84

I really didn't hate this so much.

I thought it was kind of funny. (The earing bit at least, haha)
Any publicity is good, no? Why can't everyone just share the l.o.v.e? Even though I'm a RABID twilight fan, I don't think anyone should take offence at this article. Atleast it posts that fab new pic, and who can be angry looking at the Cullens? I mean, REALLY? So why doesn't everyone just back away from their crowbar and take a breather?


And remember, atleast there IS a movie being made now for this guy to 'pass on'!!!!

Anne on May 3, 2008

85

I'm not a guy, but I'm married to one

My husband is a man's man; 6'4", 200s, won't "dress up" for anything, "don't cry, or you're a sissy lala" kinda guy. He has just finished listening to "Twilight," "New Moon," and "Eclipse" for the second time on audiobook. (Maybe you should try listening to it. Seems that's what a lot of guys are doing)

Now, he doesn't like that the action doesn't start until later in the book, he thinks Bella is dramatic, and that Edward is kind of gay. BUT he likes the story over all, and I think that is in part by the way Stephenie writes. She just writes a good damned story!! At first, my husband didn't understand the fandom either, but he just sorta says 'whatever' and goes about his life, LOL.

Now, since this is about the movie, I think he will like the movie much better because there is obviously a lot more action in it that the book has. I won't repeat what is totally obvious (because everyone else seems to have done that already), but I will say that if you are the movie connoisseur that you say you are, you will see this movie. Only then, will I believe that you truly are into movies for the sake of what they are, not just whether you think you'll like them or not. I will watch a movie no matter what it is, if only to say that I at least give everything it's fair shake. If then i don't like it, at least I can say I tried to. As my father said to me a LONG time ago, "As long as you're not risking your life, try everything at least once." Now, you writing this article, that is risking your life more than a visit to the theater, huh? Of course, that's only until you shout how bad the movie sucked (if AFTER seeing it, that's what you still think) while walking out the theater door….

BTW, #74, I laughed my ass of reading that. GREAT ending to your comment

Jcking78 on May 3, 2008

86

Would everyone please just calm down?

The article clearly wasn't written to talk trash about the book. However, some of the comments do talk trash about it. Yes, everyone has their own opinions and no, not everyone enjoys the book. I think we've all firgured that out. And yes, the target audience IS teen girls, however, it's not just the teen girls who enjoy it. It all depends on what kind of stories you like and, quite frankly, not everyone likes vampire romance/action stories.

Personally, I don't think Twilight should be compared to Harry Potter. I love Twilight and used to be a huge fan of Harry Potter, but as tthe Harry Potter books progressed I found myself not wanting to read them anymore. I just wait for the movies. In my opinion I believe Twilight is much better than Harry Potter, though many people will disagree.

I respect everyones opinions, but please… Keep your negative opinions to yourself, especially if you haven't read the book or don't really know what it's about.

Tiffanie on May 3, 2008

87

Okay, Twilight fans… I am one of you but some of you need to calm down. Seriously we can have discussions about this without swearing, insulting, and…yes spelling things very poorly. It makes us look bad. Please try and read some other comments before you jump down to the end and just start insulting and swearing and saying the same things over and over

Not everyone is going to like the movie we are all so excited to see. We are angry because he hasn't read the books…I agree he should give it a chance so he'll know why there are so many rabid fans… but this is a movie site and he's expressing why he thinks this movie isn't for him.

So instead of insulting maybe we should try and say why we think he should give it a chance…

I have said it before, its a great date movie for him… action for him, romance for her…

He doesn't have to LOVE it the way we do…

Melissa on May 3, 2008

88

Man Kevin. Be careful dude. This and your Jared Padalecki thing…

Ryan on May 3, 2008

89

I like how he went to bashing and talking trash about the movie and all this to now he is gradually giving all of it "interest" and its props. kinda back peddling if you ask me now kevin… And everyone saying to calm down and talk this out civilized just reminds me of the puss, dick, and asshole conversation off of Team America… Im laughing right now lolz its funny to me XD

Basa on May 3, 2008

90

Well, I can see why some guys would not like the book series. I am of the female persuasion and also a teenager so sue me for that, but yeah. I believe that guys will like this movie because a) Hot Girls b) Pretty good action and c) The actual movie itself seems like it is going to be amazing. Now, I am attempting to see this from somewhat of a positive dudes point of view. I mean, I can also say that when guys are dragged into the theatres they will be grumbling which will only ruin the movie for them because hell, my uncle did that with all the Pirates of the Carribean Movies. It may be somewhat hard to ask this of guys but just go into the movie theatres as if you were about to watch "Iron Man" or whatever the hell it is that you want to watch.

I am just going to make this clear real quick ; Be careful what you post about "Twilight."

Had we not learned our lesson from the flame-war over at /Film?

If anyone attempts to post bad stuff about "Twilight" I guarantee a war and it really is not that pleasant. The one over at /Film was 100 times worse than the one over here.

Check out "Kaleb Nation" he's a college dude who reads the books. But if you would rather not, oh well. I actually don't care what you think now that I got all that stuff off my back XD

VIVA LA MAFIA =D!

Rawr on May 3, 2008

91

Im not from the US so I don’t watch MTV, so MTV has not affected the book or movie for me. Twilights not really talked about hear in Canada so people haven’t ruined it for me ether. I hate it when people talk about a movie so much that it totally destroys it when it comes out. But I like the books I’ve read them all. I don’t really like Bella but I like the vampires and werewolves. Emmett has to be my favoured character, same with Jake. The books are intense and funny I don’t see why people should dislike the books much. My girl friend actually got me reading the book. She loved it so much that she demanded I read it. I wasn’t all for it in the beginning but then the book became really interesting. So ya hope that helped.

dan on May 3, 2008

92

I actually have to be a little 'catty', so to speak, about one thing in particular.

What is wrong with Robert writting the lullaby? I mean, dude come on. Immature much for a what? Twenty year old guy? I'll just let you on a little secret; girls don't find that whole 'macho' facade, mainly when it is used inappropriately. =/

I'll be attacked/debated over with this with all of the nega-guys but hell…Do I care? I try and debate intelligently (try is the key word), but when I read an article like this it really does push some buttons. It would be like me saying that "Iron Man" was the worst movie in the history of films before it even came out and honestly, "Twilight" has a much better chance of becoming a franchise than any other film that "Hollywood" or any other big named companies are working on. Let's have a wager, shall we?

Starting with statistics; over two million copies of "Twilight" were sold and translated intoo 20/30 languages.

Next, the FAN BASE is VERY similar to Harry Potter because majority of us WERE/Still are Harry Potter fanatics.

A reminder: Not everyone knew what Harry Potter was UNTIL it became a movie/franchise. I never even touched the books until after the Fourth Harry Potter film. Give it a chance and don't poke at the Twilight Fan base, the books, the movie, or the actors. As you can see messing with this kind of magnitude of fandom does not come without a major reaction.

Rant over for now…And now time to be optimistic. Have a great day.

Rawr on May 3, 2008

93

Wow, amazing, a guy that read Twilight and actually liked it. Now here I can say I am actually shocked. Because most men wouldn't admit to something like that, due to fear of being shunned by their friends and such. Anyway, I read through quite a bit of the previous posts and such, and I can say this much. Twilight is a wonderful book series, I have read every book that is out so far, and I am looking forward very much to the release of Breaking Dawn and Midnight Sun. For those of you that don't know, Midnight Sun is Twilight, but from Edward's point of view. As for the movie, no movie is as good as the book, that's just how it is, because they always have to leave things out. But if the movie is at least somewhat close, and they at least put the important things in the movie, then the movie will be a success and a big hit. And yes, I have watched every behind the scenes clip that is out and it has been said that they are leaning toward a bit more of an action/romance/horror genre with this movie to attract both men and women. The clip I saw involving the fight scene in the ballet studio looked great, which you can see here, http://www.etonline.com/news/2008/04/60435/index.html and here is also another behind the scenes clip from MTV http://www.mtv.com/overdrive/?id=1585900&vid=226476

Kayla on May 3, 2008

94

Ok I haven't read it and I'm probably not gonna see it but I'm gonna throw my $.02 in…

Pardon the pun I think vampires have been done to death. I kinda stopped being into them after Anne Rice turned them into misunderstood anti-heroes. The whole mystery and danger part has been taken out of the myths, they've been defanged if you will.

I guess I just prefer my vampires as monsters, rather than teenage outcast love interests. (sigh)

Time to throw 30 Days of Night into the DVD player…

jason_md2020 on May 3, 2008

95

go to twilightguy.com
it's a guy's blog about reading twilight with stories from other guy readers

Emily on May 3, 2008

96

Kevin…. David…..

Just have to apologize for all the crap comments on here.

And David, I'll say it. I'm a Twilight fan, and really enjoyed the series (as did my husband), but I have to agree that the shot posted on this page doesn't exactly make me want to see the movie. I hope that the trailer is a lot better. Although I DO believe the movie was cast well based on my idea from the novels, the makeup looks kinda freaky and goth. And although the vampires are supposed to look VERY pale, their not supposed to look goth. In the novels, the vampires always dress in light clothing so they don't look as pale as they would otherwise, kinda trying to avoid the goth look and blend in.

As far as enticing you to see the movie, there's not much to say. Either you are interested in the story or not. I do have to say you may be surprised if you give it a chance. I started reading the novels almost a year after my sister-in-law (the most tom-boy girl I know) recommended them to me. I read them because I got them for a gift on Christmas and I liked the cover-art. After the first book, I read the second and then bought the third.

As far as chick-flicks go, my husband and I both love the 6 hour version of Pride and Prejudice. Neither of us likes it for the love story. If it was just the love story I liked, I'd stick with the two hour version with Kjiera Knightley because although the love story is great from a female perspective, it's the sarcastic humor of Mr. Bennet that I love, and you just don't really get that in the 2 hour version.

I see Twilight as being similar (I am NOT saying that it is on par with Pride and Prejudice in terms of literary esteem) in the sense that what is REALLY enjoyable for my husband is not the love story, and there are other things in the story that make it enjoyable which will hopefully be apparent in the movie.

I agree, however, that the photo doesn't do anything good to promote the movie to those who are not rabid fans of the book series. That being said, I think it is cast well and that Catherine Hardwick will do a good job of directing the movie. I'm excited to see how it turns out.

Married to a man on May 3, 2008

97

The first time I heard about this movie was from FS and that is when I also heard that Kristen Stewart was going to be the lead. I'm a fan of hers so I had to find out what exactly all the hype was over, so I read all the books. They were pretty awesome. I'm looking forward to this movie 1) for Kristen Stewart, 2) i enjoy Vampire movies and 3) I also enjoy the occasional love story movie.
I just hope I'll get to see it in Japan.

robert_b on May 3, 2008

98

Twilight is terribly overrated. I read most of the first book and couldn't finish it. I find Edward Cullen TERRIBLY UNATTRACTIVE (Please girls, my idea of perfection is the late great Robert Palmer). I also find Bella Swan to be a complete idiot easily swayed into being obsessed over a shallow vampire loser who happens to look good and sparkle like in the sunlight. There are better men out there aside from this overrated fictional Cullen fella. This book series is giving girls a false sense of what they want in a man. If you want a shallow, conceited asshole who will just abuse you, go ahead, girls!

ClubScum on May 3, 2008

99

This movie looks to me like a sequel to "The Covenant" which was an awful teen vampires movie.

Hector on May 3, 2008

100

hmm.. well..can I just clear something up?… THE TWILIGHT SERIES IS THE GREATEST BOOKS I HAVE EVER READ..and they will continue to be the greatest books I have ever read for the rest of my life.
Harry Potter sucks actually…whats better, Wizards or Vampires?–VAMPIRES..they actually sparkle in the sun..=D.. Stephenie Meyer is a better writer than the chick who writes the Harry Potter books.. (see,I can't even remember her name…)
but,anyway..this is not about Twilight Vs Harry Potter.
Kevin..I think you should read The Twilight books first,or look up Twilight sites…you are a guy..and Twilight is from a Girl's perspective,so it probably would be a little weird for you..but .try reading Edward Cullen's perspective on 'twilight' -'Midnight Sun' -you can get it from here- http://www.stepheniemeyer.com
and by the way,I love that picture of bella,edward,rosalie,emmett,alice and jasper.
they are PERFECT. I think the movie will be really good,from what I have heard,and seen.
I actually,have a few guy friends who ADORE the books..and, he has actually been screaming over it,and the movie!!! so take that Kevin.
I first got 'twilight' in 2005…and I have re-read the books.so many times,that its crazy.
thats how much I love the story.
Yes,we all have our doubts about the movie..but,just be thankful that they are actually making a movie of it….we get to see the story,in front of our eyes,instead of in our head.
Twilight the movie,is going to be AWESOME.


the end.

Lauren on May 3, 2008

101

To the guy who said this>> "This movie looks to me like a sequel to "The Covenant" which was an awful teen vampires movie."

HAHAHAHA,the convenant wasn't even a VAMPIRE MOVIE.
idiot!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Lauren on May 3, 2008

102

I don't get why people judge everything when you haven't WATCHED or READ it. Seriously, that's stupid.

And yes, I know everyone has their opinions, but at least read it, or attempt too before you write a stupid, idiotic report about it.

Which, by the why, why did you even post this? It served no purpose whatsoever. All it did was bash something you know little about and get thousands of fans angry. Good job.

Ashley on May 3, 2008

103

Idiot indeed for watching that movie. I want my 10 dlls back!

Hector_n on May 3, 2008

104

I came across this series quite by accident, and though at times the writing is repetative I must admit I became I fan. I cant wait for the movie and have no expectations. I think what I most enjoyed from it was the lack of sex and swearing (and believe me I like a good amount of cursing) because lets face it thats all thats out there now. I found the story at its core to be a pure love story and at times sticky sweet but whats wrong with that. Its basically about the rush of first love (throw in some vampires and werwolves) which appeals to young and older audiences. My question is what did you expect the movie to be like? Honestly I'm curious.

GLD on May 3, 2008

105

@#102: This is a movie site about past, current and prospective movies. It is their JOB to anticipate how a movie might turn out.

You say it's a waste to post something that he's never seen or read. The Love Guru won't come out until summer. No one I know has seen the movie or read the script, but it's pretty safe to say that it will turn out horrible. There aren't any Mike Myers fans on a crusade against any bad comments, so why the hell is everyone making such a stink out of this.

You people make me embarrassed to be a Twilight fan!!

Nettle on May 3, 2008

106

GLD, I've pretty much seen the movie! I have seen so many pictures, and videos…… A lot is different, but it is all aproved by Meyer.


SPOILER:

(Im mostly excited for the new field trip scene with Jasper,Alice,Edward, and Bella. As well as the waterfall…. and Victoria is at the prom!!!! )



(/end spoiler)

Anne on May 3, 2008

107

I love twilight but man some of you fans go all out. People are entitled to their opinions. I myself can’t wait for the movie I have read all the books and liked all of them; I thought new moon wasa little sad though. The books are mainly about Edward and Bella’s love for one another but there is a lot of intense drama/ action. And some of my guy friends actually like the books. Im dragging them along to go see the movie with me when it comes out.

jen on May 3, 2008

108

I like your honesty but I believe your not giving the book a proper chance.
Atleast try to read the books and give it a go.

You may be surprised!

Thalia on May 3, 2008

109

Wait Victoria’s not at the prom in twilight. Unless they added that in. And what waterfall?

jen on May 3, 2008

110

Kevin's To Do list:

1) Read Twilight
2) Read New Moon
3) Read Eclipse
4) Print retraction
5) Beg for forgiveness

Feel sorry for you on May 3, 2008

111

Ok, Twilight is DEFINITELY not the next Harry Potter; Harry Potter is a masterpiece while Twilight is a…typical teenage romance book with werewolves and vampires thrown in…quiet enjoyable, but that's it!

1. The writer of this article shoud get a little more informed, it seems that you're talking with nothing to support you.
2. Twilight's plot IS really silly, and almost no one outside the US knows what Twilight is, while I personally don't know a single person who doesn't know what Harry Potter is.
3. Twilight has a lot of potential, with better writing and a BETTER PLOT, it'd be awesome. I'm sorry but the plot is very "ok, I'm going to make a plot just because it'll be boring to read about Bella thinking how hot Edward is…voila!"
4. I enjoyed Twilight, I thought it was a bit forced at some points, but hey, I enjoyed it!
5. I'm actually quiet excited for the movie, it'll be a HIT in the US, but only there, believe me, I know what I'm talking about.

Cristina on May 3, 2008

112

You disgust me. These are acually good, well written books which im proud to say ive read. [and NO my girlfriend didn't make me] dont look and "love story" category and think it's crap. Be a real man and give it a try.

Ben on May 3, 2008

113

Okay, this really has gone too far. I do not think that Kevin should be forced to read the books or have any affiliation with the novels. He's giving his opinion on what he thinks about the movie which everyone has the right to do. He shouldn't have to read the books or even watch the movie! This is just one person's opinions and people can't go around trying to change everyone's opinions. This is a movie site and as a fan of Twilight, I will definitely go see it, no matter what. Jen #109: They did add extra scenes in the movie (hence Victoria at prom) & the waterfall is at the part where they go hiking to the meadow. #111: Twilight has been translated in over twenty languages & there is large following in Spain & Germany. Even Canada is already doing news coverage on Twilight (and the movie is still filming!). I think that it might not be big money makers like Harry Potter (and although I am a bigger Twilight than HP fan, I can admit that HP has a big following for it & is a far complex novel) but there is a pretty large following for Twilight outside the USA too. But Twilight is going to be a great movie & I bet you that once it hits the theaters, it will spread the word & become an even bigger international sensation. Just watch.

Jessica on May 3, 2008

114

I totally understand where Kevin is coming from when looking at all the videos and crazy fanpires, twiligters and twi-hards. Honestly, the only way all the vids and pictures are good is if you have fallen in love with the story and the characters, otherwise, it all looks silly. I love the books and even I find myself being repulsed by the over exuberant fans.

How wonder you feel this way, it's only to be expected. But I encourage you to the read the book anyways, you may be surprised.

Annie on May 4, 2008

115

"Angelic Robert Pattinson even wrote the tune, "Bella's Lullaby," himself. I'm sorry, but there goes my lunch."

Oh the lulz, they cannot be contained. I completely understand why this would be unappealing to guys. It's even funnier knowing how many fangirls wanted to shag him after learning that news.

We'll just have to see how it turns out. Frankly, I'd be horrified if every guy liked Twilight. That's kind of messed up.

Anon on May 4, 2008

116

I would just like to say to all the commentors that are either saying "the book is FANTASTIC, can't you seeeee!!!!!!!!1" or "it really SUCKED" that this is part of the nature of the human race. We aren't all going to enjoy the same things, we all have different tastes and just because one person believes one thing, you dont have to convert them to your views. I don't think it is appropriate, however to complete trash another person's views, simply present your arguments for others to consider.

As for my own opinion on the books, I enjoyed them and I'm really looking forward to this movie in the same way I hopefully waited for The Golden Compass and Eragon, two books that could have made fantastic movies but in my opinion, fell way short.

Also, for the people who want a male opinion, my 17 year old brother is in love with these books so it can be enjoyed by some of the males of our species, as long as they don't mind some really cheesy romance

Annabelle on May 4, 2008

117

seriously dude. u havent even read this book so how can u freaking be against it?
sure u probably heard really cheesy things about it but u shouldnt be slamming it before u even read it.
& earring thrown at u? my girlfriend would probably do that…
im not saying i like the book because i havent even read it yet. do i plan to? i dont know yet. but im going to see the movie just to watch people [vampires] kill eachother.

victor on May 4, 2008

118

wtf go read the books before you judge them asshole. talk about uneducated masses

Rees on May 4, 2008

119

Well I'm a girl, I read the books, and quite frankly, enjoyed them very much. I don't think it's a kind of book that's the ultimate-best-writting-ever-masterpiece-for-eternity thingy, like Harry Potter or Lord of the Rings, but the plot it's quite interesting, and, I must add, very addictive. It's basically your average triangle love story, but with a couple of mystical beings thrown in.

I know everyone already said this, but really it isn't nice to make a review of a book without reading it. It's exactly the sort of things that kids do. (- I don't like lasagna! - How do you know if you've never tried it? - It doesn't smell good!)

It actually raises a bunch of deep moral issues, without falling in vulgarity. And it is not your average teenager book. I can assure you that.

I can understand why this type of literature appeals for women better than men. But if you're going to bash it, at least make sure you do it AFTER you've read it.

And yes, the lullaby situation. I myself found it quite adorable and think it adds a speacial touch to the movie, as well as feeling when the actor actually gets to play his own composition. But that's just me, apparently.

Yes, I'm going to see the movie. And yes it was a GUY who first introduced me to Twilight.

Greetings from Portugal. (and HURRAY for freedom of speech)

Carla on May 4, 2008

120

Question: Why haven't we had this many female posters on any other movie discussion?

Just curious…

jason_md2020 on May 4, 2008

121

The book primarily caters to an audience of teenage girls, and while that's not necessarily a bad thing (not everything written for a teenage audience sucks horribly, you know), it does tend to predilect the novels to a certain amount of campy romance.

It would be wise for people to stop comparing the novels to J.K. Rowling's "Harry Potter" series, and the recently popularized J.R.R. Tolkien's "Lord of the Rings" trilogy. They might be of the same genre (fantasy), but, that is the ONLY similarity that can be drawn between the three series. They didn't even cater to the same audiences.

I've read the books- my little sister is enamored with them and I hear no end of praises on her end about them. However I do not care for them. Stilted prose and over-worked descriptive euphemisms tend to turn me off to a book rather quickly, and a needy protagonist that needs saving every five minutes is better left to the Harlequin Romances I pick up for my mom at the swap meet.

But that's just my two cents.

Michelle on May 4, 2008

122

The immaturity of some of the comments amazes me. This is a movie review site, there is no need to read the original material to formulate an opinion on the movie (opinions are formed on much less than kevin has formed his opinion). I have read all the books and I am not excited for the movie, I am also not amazed by Meyer's writing which I find very formulaic. I respect what she is trying to do with the genre but find it to be just another Romeo and Juliet-esque love story transported to vampirism and modernism, not exactly a fresh take.

I agree with Kevin about the poster as well, at least to me a 20 year old male it reminds me of the abercrombie and fitch models i see as i walk the mall, albeit a bit more pale. This movie could be good, it could be the worst piece of tripe standing next to Meet Dave and The Love Guru, I won't know it until I see it and finish formulating my opinion. But right now my excitement is a Giant 0 and my hype for the movie is the same.

Furthermore, due to the rabidness of the fan base exhibited by much of the comments I have read. I am almost ashamed to admit I have read the books. I enjoy a good fluff read and that is all I see these books as. I hope Mrs. Meyers continues to write and that her writing becomes more original as time goes on. As I hope with all current writers I enjoy to a certain extent. But as of right now, I still do not support this movie or the hype behind it.

I welcome december.

Memento Mori

Sojourner on May 5, 2008

123

I loved all the books that i have read so far. I cant wait till the next book, i'm in love with them

Amanda on May 5, 2008

124

I found your take on this whole thing pretty typical for someone who hasn't read the book yet. I would give you more credit had you read them. I am a girl who read the books and absolutely loved them. When I first heard what they were about I was a little hesitant to read them. They didn't exactly seem to appeal to my likes. But after everyone in my extended family gave them a try, I decided to as well. They were wonderful. They sucked you in (pardon the pun) and really made you feel for the characters. I was amazed at how well Ms. Meyers developed her characters. Her writing style is amazing and easy to follow.

I will admit the movie hype has gone a little crazy given there are still 7 more months until December, however I am still excited for this to play out on the big screen.

I suggest that you give the books a try and then formulate an opinion. It seems there have been a slew of articles lately about Twilight and half of the authors have not read the book and that bothers me. I don't care if you don't like the books, doesn't bother me at all. I would just give you more credit if you studied your subject material a little more.

sam on May 5, 2008

125

Kevin, a teaser trailer is out. I hope you watch it and do an update. Even if you still don't like it. It's interesting to hear what people think of it who are unfamiliar with the books. I hope the movie is good and does well but it's still really early and I can't get a feel on what non-readers will think of it. Thanks!

Janet on May 5, 2008

126

LOOK guys a teaser trailer (as Janet has already said)

But here's a link: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=I7oeLpx8lDg

Melissa on May 5, 2008

127

Wow.
Kevin has gotten hell from just posting his opinion of THE MOVIE.
Whether or not he aggravated you fans, whe wasn't trying to say that he didn't like it. He was just trying to express his opinion of the movie, NOT THE BOOK. I'm a guy and I came across the first book a while back. Did I finish reading it? No, I stopped after the first chapter. Didn't intrigue me one bit, and as some posters have said, the storyline itself is old, unoriginal, and just plain idiotic. The vampires being good (or in this case and some others, a love interest) storyline has been done to hell. I'd like to relive the good old days of vampires being the monstrous villains once again.

Just my 2 cents, and this probably isn't going to be read.

ADN on May 5, 2008

128

I was reading many of the comments others posted, and what one girl said hit me…

Why are you writing an article on a book you haven't read? I mean, I wouldn't write an article on something like Star Wars or Lord of the Rings or something if I didn't like it, or at least have some interest in it… You either have serious issues about whether or not the movie really does interest you but being the kind of guy who must think he has to be so "manly" he won't addmit his interest, or you just wasted your time on a topic you shouldn't concern yourself with because, you don't even care about it. If I have nothing good to say about something like SpeedRacer or Rambo, I have the decency to not go rant about how awful it is, and how its only for guys and racer fanatics… Sure the sterotype of Twilight is over all related to romance, but there is so much more to it than just "o la la"… "smooch smooch"… If you had read it, you would know. Unfortunately you are one of those people who judge a book by its cover, or by what you hear in the media… The characters of Twilight are exceptionally deep (in the book at least), alot of thought went into them, they arn't just characters in a book, like most other material you find on the shelves nowadays. Its actually like they exist. But you wouldn't know that, now would you? Plus Twilight isn't just about romance it portrays to alot of deep things, like the meaning of life, and the existance of heaven, or hell, or even the possibity of being "damned", or a higher being. But I doubt your a religious person because hell yo