1

last time i checked, Captain America wears a shirt, personally i hate the idea, i rather have a no name than put McConaughey in it.

or at least someone who'd appreciate the role, why not give it to Ryan Phillippe.

The Delightful Deviant on May 6, 2008

2

Oh, that's not fair. You gave no replacement for McConaughey. While he might not be the best to take the role, I'll take him over the no one you suggested. The Delightful Deviant offers Ryan Phillippe which might be good, but his acting is wooden, which could workout I guess. I say why not Matthew Fox or Josh Hartnett. Maybe not the best suggestions but it's still early.

With marvel announcing the line up for their next few movies, the casting will have to be perfect for all this to work out and making it all the way through to the Avengers movie.

Cecil on May 6, 2008

3

I would think Matthew would be great! He's got the physique and the action appearance. I'm up for him playing the role… or someone totally new.

nha on May 6, 2008

4

While I agree that Matthew McConaughey isn't the perfect choice for Captain American, to dismiss him as a "piss-poor actor" is a little harsh. He's not that bad. Wooderson, anyone? Unfortunately, he tends to choice romantic comedy roles that do little to improve his reputation.

Thats what I love about these old-school superheroes, man. I keep getting older…they stay the same age.

Kelly B. on May 6, 2008

5

I've got only a few problems with McConaughey.

Phillippe sounds much better, while Matthew Fox or Josh Hartnett introduces the dye-job.

My favorite has always been Matthew Lillard.

I know, when Marvel first started bandying the property about, Brad Pitt was frequently mentioned, but that was ten years ago…

back in the early 1990s, it was Dennis Quaid.

Given the Downey Jr. success, they'll get someone well-known. No unknowns in Marvel movies.

Andrew Wickliffe on May 6, 2008

6

What about Ryan Gosling?

Kelly B. on May 6, 2008

7

If we wanted Steve Rogers to be a pothead who can't act, we could hire one of my friends. Please, for the love of god, pick someone that, oh i don't know, makes sense for the role.

Derek on May 6, 2008

8

Scott Speedman

Discateia on May 6, 2008

9

yeah matthew would totally kill it. I dont think he could last long in the costume with having to take off his shirt. And he always looks homeless.

therblig on May 6, 2008

10

The minute you put Mathew Mcconaughey in to play captin america this movie is destine to fail,when holly wood makes these movies they must be wise on who they choose to as lead superhero for example Christian bale,Toby Mcguire and now recently Robert Downey jr. please choose someone else.

APOCALYPSE1 on May 6, 2008

11

Personally, I think you might have to go with an unknown for Captain America.

While Iron Man proved that unconventional casting can work, a lot of Robert Downey Jr.'s personal history lined up with the character and that made the transition easier.

Captain America - as much as any super hero since Superman - represent an ideal. To slap some celebritity into the role would overshadow that.

Tom Brazelton on May 6, 2008

12

#8 - I like the idea of Scott Speedman. He's not a household name yet, but familiar with most sci-fi geeks for his role int he Underworld flicks. He's actually a pretty cood actor too.

I think with a character like Captain America, Marvel is going to be forced to use a lesser known actor. Cap is way to iconic to be play by a well known actor. If would be hard to forget you're watching (insert overpaid, well known actor here) and enjoy the movie.

Downey Jr. nailed it, but it's been a long time since he was considered a bankable actor, if he ever really was.

When casting they have to remember that Cap is a bigger than life boyscout. Putting smaller guys like Phillippe, or Gosling won't work, unless they use 2 different actors for a "before and after" Steve Rogers.

Matthew Fox is too lanky, and McConaughey is too much of a pothead to take serious as an actor. I don't dislike him, I just don't think he's a good fit.

With Marvel big announcement about Thor appearing in Iron Man II, I'm curious who everyone would like to see cast. My pick for Thor would be Vin Diesel, or maybe even a WWE wrestler like HHH, who has done some acting before (Blade: Trinity).

TCox on May 6, 2008

13

ooo….Matthew Fox could be really cool. He did a nice job as Racer X in Speed Racer. He's already warmed up to wearing a mask and costume!

kevin powers on May 6, 2008

14

I hate hate HATE Matthew McConaughey. It is extremely painful watching him on the screen. He IS a piss poor actor. Why? Because he's always preening. I've never seen an "actor" more in love with himself. And I can't remember the critic, but in one review for one of his films, the reviewer said "McConaughey is not nearly as precious as he thinks he is". And that nailed it. I wish he would work with a director who would knock him down several pegs. In short, if McConaughey plays Captain America, count me out.

Rob on May 6, 2008

15

How about Paul Walker from The Fast and the Furious???

I never really liked him in any movies till i saw Running Scared!!!

REAL6 on May 6, 2008

16

I agree that McConaughey would be a poor choice. I vote for Matthew Fox. Speed Racer this weekend will show his ability to be pull off a costume.

Napier's News on May 6, 2008

17

It's gotta be Aaron Eckhart.

Ian Kazimer on May 6, 2008

18

Thomas Jane is perfect for any comic book hero role.

woogie on May 6, 2008

19

Vin Diesel as Thor? Come on ………….If Thor is made, you almost have to cast Sean Bean in the role. As far as Captain America, I don't think McConaughey wouldn't be terrible, he'd have to lose the "aww shucks, I'm from Texas" thing he usually brings to his roles. Aaron Eckhart might not be bad, I think Brad Pitt would probably be pretty good. He's a tough role to cast, you need someone big who can act, they have to have presence, and they can't over-shadow the role.

Shane on May 6, 2008

20

Nick Cage could actually be great to inject a little character into the role.

But he was already Ghost Rider…

McConnohey's only good line ever was in Dazed & Confused:
"I love high school girls, I keep getting older & they stay the same age."

Typical smarmy dick talk. Hardly Cap material.

Each Marvel characters' strength on-screen and on paper comes from their inner conflicts, Cap's being his "Survivor Guilt", from the post-war Kirby books. Cheery boyscout that he is, he's still wimpy Steve Rogers inside that serum-grown soldier hide, so the actor would have to be able to portray that depth somehow. M.M. is not capable.

Haven't read Brubaker's stuff but I hear it's top rate material. Maybe I'll come up w/ a name after picking that up.

I like Vincent D'onnofrio as Thor. Ever seen 'The Cell'? He is so awesome in that.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

21

I agree with woogie, Thomas Jane did an awesome job as the punisher.

Nelson on May 6, 2008

22

Trying to wrap my head around how you guys think the same actor could star as two Marvel characters.

Either you guys are nuts, or you've been hittin' the sauce.

And btw- top notch acting involves a little more than looks, i.e. Triple H's "acting" experience doesn't qualify him to do a starring lead role, and portray an actual character (aside from himself, or another version of his on-stage persona).

Brad Pitt can actually act, but I can't really see him as Cap either.

We need someone who can make me a bigger Cap fan than I ever was, the way Downey's doing for Iron Man.

Someone who's had actual military experience might be good. Or something close. Spielberg put his actors through serious boot camp to prepare them for Private Ryan.

Maybe Tom Sizemore could be an interesting choice.
He's believable as both the "Football Quarterback/Captain" aspect of the character, as well as having the inner game to actually inject Cap w/ a sense of life.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

23

It has to be an unknown because of the fact that when you re casting Captain AMerica you re not casting a character you re casting a presence, he has to command respect without saying much. If there is an actor in it that has been in other movies, ANY other movies, than all we ll be seeing will be the roles that they have done previously.

Captain America is a big, strong leader, while being an imposing presence, the first thing you notice about him is that when he walks into a room and speaks, EVERYONE shuts up and listens. Any movie where he is a character, even the Avengers Movie, will be 40% him and 60% divided by the other characters.

Someone almost like Brandon Routh (Superman Returns) which as Superman could have presence without saying much. However Captain America is more serious then even a Superman.

Anyways, just my 2 cents

Logan on May 6, 2008

24

I agree–Aaron Eckhart. he's got the jawline for sure… Im good with Thomas Jane too.

Ew. NO to bongos McConaughey! Will this be a comedy? Please give Cap some respect Hollywood.

cyn on May 6, 2008

25

Aaron Eckhart and Scott Speedman are two outstanding suggestions. Or a complete newcomer. Like they did for "Superman Returns" with Brandon Routh. Who I thought captured Christopher Reeves essence beautifully.

Rob on May 6, 2008

26

I think a no name is the best bet. As far as chaning him to fit the times that is the opposite of what they need to do. He needs to be Cap with his 1940's values. Just bring into focus the best parts of that maybe with some sort of terriost action (maybe eco terroirst or something so we stay away from other controversies). That will bring a feeling to be patriotic for the country. That doesn't mean he needs to endorse any actions or revile any actions of the country, just be patriotic. Support the ideals that America was meant to stand on.

Stirling on May 6, 2008

27

Actually, Logan, I think what you actually need is a seasoned actor who's never had their time in the Limelight.

Brandon Routh did Soap Operas before he did Superman Returns. He sounded like Chris Reeve, but he didn't REALLY add much depth to the character (discounting the fact that Superman is now a naval-gazing pouty face).

If Sizemore's come through rehab nearly as well as Downey has (they've worked together, in Nat. Born Killers. Maybe Downey can give him some tips…) then he'll be just the kind of hungry, under-recognized talent that this role needs.

(my two cents. I should be a freaking casting agent. Oh, that's right. I am my own casting agent, for a play I wrote this summer… ah, the joys of creative labour…)

Djo. on May 6, 2008

28

Personally I'm not a fan of the man, but I wasn't a fan of Robert Downy and thought that him as Iron man was idiotic just cause I honestly didn't like the guy. But what happened it was an awesome movie and he did a great job. So I'll hold off all my opinions about casting after I watch the movies.

Eric on May 6, 2008

29

Thomas Jane would be great since he is no longer the Punisher, is really physically fit, and is a great actor. I also agree with #6 in that the very first person I thought of was Ryan Gosling…he's a great actor (see Lars and the real girl)…he just needs to get huge ala Christian Bale going from 110 lbs after "The Machinest" to jacked a huge at over 200 lbs for Batman Begins like 1 month later. Furthermore I think Gosling would have made a MUCH better Anakin…but that is a different argument for a different day…

Cmurder on May 6, 2008

30

Plus, if we're going to be picturing an actor's previous roles when we see him on-screen, we've already seen Sizemore in the trenches, during WWII.

Any of these other actors you're mentioning are too 'good-looking' and/or young to really fill the iconic presense of this character - to make him believable. Besides, even if Cap's a super soldier, he still has to have been "thawed out" in the fifties.

Anyone under thirty wouldn't work.

Anybody w/out some degree of experience won't fill the role.

'Pretty good' acting simply won't cut it.
(This guy has to lead the Avengers, folks)

And Aaron Eckhart is already Two Face.

Get over it.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

31

mcconaughey isnt a bad actor, he just doesnt fit the role, i dont think speedman would be a good fit either, matthew fox on the other hand would be great, good actor and commanding presence, just needs to grow the hair out and dye it

harrison on May 6, 2008

32

Matthew McConaughey cannot be seen without his southern drawl accent coming from the one side of his mouth. Even when he becomes commanding in We Are Marshall it rings so loud and clear I cannot possibly expect that an acting coach could fix it. Not that there's anything wrong with a southern accent, I think as a guy who was born and raised in New York City and represents America a southern accent would be out of the question. No accent is preferable, or as little of one as possible.

He could be a nice Hawkeye, with his full-of-himself attitude and you could say he learned how to shoot when he was a young boy hunting with his dad in the south. I'd be pretty okay with that.

Everyone is hitting excellent points. Captain America is the quarterback for the Avengers. When he talks, everybody listens. He is the boy scout that always does his duty to God and country, etc.

We could have a young actor for this, since Cap joined the service in 1941 around the age of 18. By the time he was frozen in 1945 he'd be in his early 20's. Of course it doesn't have to be an exact age, but we would then need a relatively younger actor… relative to Robert Downey Jr. who is 43 years old.

Not only must the actor look good, but he must have the voice and the ability to verbally take command.

Chris H. on May 6, 2008

33

Ni… Ni…. Ni….. Nicholas Cage.

TAXI!

Dr.Duvel on May 6, 2008

34

Dr. Duvel:

Nic Cage was already Ghost Rider. Thought about that, too.

… if they pretend Ghost Rider never happened, just like they did w/ Ang Lee's Hulk, it might work.
But that's too recent to be serious possibility.

Such a shame- I could easily picture him doing a fine job in the role.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

35

How can anyone with a straight face even consider someone like Tom Sizemore!? First, he's bat shit crazy. And I'm talking near Gary Busey level. Then you've got all of his baggage. Way too much to ever be considered for another Hollywood high profile film. Being with Heidi Fleiss, filming himself having sex with hookers, going to jail. Not to mention he's too old, ugly and a schlub.

Rob on May 6, 2008

36

One name: Andre 3000.

The Captain America this country NEEDS.

Aswipe' Melendez Johnson on May 6, 2008

37

"…where patriotism isn't the biggest focus anymore.". I'm sorry, that line was almost drowned out by reporters pestering candidates about their piffling flag lapel pins.

But yeah, McConaughey is such a backwards choice. I hope it just turns out to be some fanboy trying to start a wishlist rumour.

Mark on May 6, 2008

38

I also have to agree with both Logan and Djo. Logan hit the nail on the head when he described that Captain America is a presence more than anything. When he walks in it's as if the Pope just came in. The guy embodies power, courage, righteousness, honor, etc.

When you look at Nicholas Cage there is no way in hell that you would see that. He's a goofy looking guy. A great actor with strong verbal skills, but you don't fit a square shaped piece into a star shaped hole. It will never fit. Tom Sizemore is big, and not the muscular kind of big. He is also too old and his voice sounds like he's a chronic smoker. It's the kind of voice I hear at my local diner all the time.

I agree with Logan and Djo that the actor must be of unknown or little known identity. Someone else hit it just right as well, that Captain America is as iconic of a character as Superman… maybe even moreso. This means the casting must be perfect in look, attitude, and in verbal ability.

In other words, don't FORCE a good actor to fit the role. It just won't look right. If there isn't a perfect fit among the hollywood lineup, go for an unknown. Whatever it takes to get the right guy for such a prestigious role.

Chris H. on May 6, 2008

39

You'd be surprised what the prospect of a killer, career-making role will do to an actor/actresses workout regimen.

These guys have handlers, agents, and trainers that can focus them on becoming a character like a goddamned Laser.

I'm not saying Tom Sizemore's perfect. But to make Cap BELIEVABLE (grew up in NY, survived WWII, etc. not to mention ANYONE who's survived the front lines of a war & went head to head w/ Hitler would HAVE to be Batshit-crazy- yet likably commanding), we don't really WANT "perfect" abs, jawbone, hair, etc.

Pick a talented actor w/ a checkered past, who lifts weights in their free time, and can pull a genuine NY accent w/out being forced or unnervingly obnoxious, and I'll show you the Captain America that can fill theatre seats.

Give us something we've never seen before. Give us an actor who can actually portray redemption onscreen, and embody America's checkered past - and undying Will, all in one performance.

(But please, someone w/a degree of experience)

Aswipe' Melendez Johnson on May 6, 2008

40

Oops. Gave away my Secret Identity there for a minute!

Looks like I don't have what it takes to be a Costumed Avenger.

Yes, America. I am Aswipe' Melendez Johnson.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

41

Why not Neal McDonough?

I think he's a great character actor who really needs a chance for the spotlight.

Just check him out in Ravenous and tell me he wouldnt be a good choice.

If he bulked up a little more, it could really work.

-Jd

Josh on May 6, 2008

42

What about this guy, from Band of Brothers?

http://movies.aol.com/celebrity/damian-lewis/301677/biography

Djo. on May 6, 2008

43

Good call, Jd.

Since I'm stepping out to lunch, I'll toss this out for laughs:

Kelsey Grammar.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

44

If they were really considering Matthew McConaughey it would make me wonder the direction that they would be going with the movie. I don't think I have ever seen him in anything other than romantic comedies so I have a really hard time picturing him in this role. Some commenters mentioned Ryan Phillipe but I don't see that either but yeah I could really get behind Kelsey Grammar.

Janet on May 6, 2008

45

OK, since you guys are going in a different direction for Captain America nominees, here are some of my choices:

Ray Romano
Danny Bonaduce
Hulk Hogan
Kenny G
Larry Hagman
Fabio

Rob on May 6, 2008

46

What about Daniel Craig? hes got the size and could have the screen presence. He also looks like the type thats been in some fights, hes not a real pretty boy. I think anybody who plays him has to be a decently sized man who has great screen presence.

Goose on May 6, 2008

47

Stephen Colbert should play Captain America.

M. on May 6, 2008

48

I'll actually go out on a big limb here and DEFEND Matt as a choice. Does anyone remember "A Time To Kill"? The guy can act…. he just hasn't done it recently.

Jeff on May 6, 2008

49

I think Ryan Reynolds would be great!

Daniel on May 6, 2008

50

Ryan Reynolds is already playing Deadpool, in Wolverine.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

51

Cap America (and Thor!) are REALLY tough choices.

Captain America - Josh Brolin?

As for Thor, i've only seen his character in those Avengers cartoons, but make The Rock grow long blond hair and he IS Thor…cocky, arrogant, funny and ass kicking! :op

chrisUK on May 6, 2008

52

Why not Brad Pitt? I think he can still fit the part with a little bulking up. I'm pretty sure cap's always been portrayed as a really good looking guy in his mid 30s. I thinkhe can still pull off being a little younger

Nate on May 6, 2008

53

what about will ferrell, he would fit the role well

zach on May 6, 2008

54

If you've seen the old, late 80's Cap movie, they guy in the suit talks like Will Ferrell, when he's portraying that creepy nudist who's always in the Hot Tub.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

55

Since you're saying Cap should be adapted to modern times (a statement I fully agree with), why not go with a modern decision? I say why not enlist Will Smith for the roll? He's a bigger star, can out-act, and is a much bigger B.O. draw than anyone all these other people are suggesting.

(unless they're saving him for a Green Lantern role, that is)

kevjohn on May 6, 2008

56

Just see Southland Tales, for flagrant proof that the Rock simply CANNOT act.

Djo. on May 6, 2008

57

Yeah, Will Smith IS a bigger B.O. draw.

His ass stanks!

(and he's already playing a superhero in Hand-cock)

Djo. on May 6, 2008

58

i could see brolin playin the part maybe, as for sizemore hes just too old and doesnt have the build to pull of the captain
and in further defense of mcconaugheys acting abilities, i changed my mind and i think he could pull it off, remember U-571? great movie and he had a commanding performance the whole time

how about brendan fraser, david duchovny, mark wahlberg, josh hartnet, id say dennis quaid but hes in GI Joe, jason london the other guy from dazed and confused, jason segel, val kilmer, or viggo mortenson?

harrison on May 6, 2008

59

Brolin would be one mean, kick-ass choice.

I could see it. Then Javier Bardem as the Red Skull.

(or Daniel Day Lewis… !)

Smedley Munchkin Lazslow on May 6, 2008

60

I don't know why anyone hasn't mentioned Hayden Christensen for this role yet. He did bring Darth Vader back to the big screen, talk about screen presence!

Seriously on May 6, 2008

61

This guy is an amazing actor - after a few pushups I think he's the man for the First Avenger.
http://www.imdb.com/media/rm2554567168/tt0381849

CoJo2 on May 6, 2008

62

Sorry Alex but I have to disagree with you on this one. Frailty, Two for the Money????

He usually makes bad choices but he has some decent acting in him and I think he wouldn't be the BEST choice but I wouldn't think he would be a bad one either.

Ryan on May 6, 2008

63

This expanding list of great actors makes me sorely wish Steve Rogers wasn't blonde haired & blue eyed.

Just picture Matt Damon, in that ridiculously whiny "Team America" voice, as Cap.
"But I'm Matt Damon! Wheh, wheh, wheh!"

Brad Pitt could do it - but fact is he probably wouldn't. Same goes for Clooney.

I say Eddie Furlong as pre-serum Steve, and Brett Favre as post-serum Steve.

Djo. Sizemore. on May 6, 2008

64

For Captain American, what about Mr Bourne Identity himself, Matt Damon?

iDavid on May 6, 2008

65

Actually I like the idea of Damon. Especially after showing his action chops in the Bourne series.

Oh yeah…screw the hair color. They made the Kingpin black in Daredevil. Hair color should not be an issue.

And now a curve ball pick…Nathan Fillion (No, really I'm serious)

jason_md2020 on May 6, 2008

66

What about … Bruce Campbell?

Seriously on May 6, 2008

67

The "reliable" source that Cinema Blend is claiming is none other than Marvel themselves…sorta. If you read the Marvel Ultimates comic line you can see a new age of most of the Mavel heroes. The Avengers are called the Ultimates and they are headed by Nick Furk. In this line of comic Fury is black and he favors Samuel Jackson…on purpose. In one of the issues they all sit around joking about who would play them in the movies. Sam Jackson for Nick Fury, Lucy Liu for the Wasp, Johnny Depp for Tony Stark (go figure- that didnt wash), Steve Buscemi for the Hulk aka Bruce Banner( another no-go), Matthew McConaughey for Cap't America and a few others I dont remember. Cinema Blend is just being GHEY claiming they got a "source"

Gfunk on May 6, 2008

68

Ryan Phillippe as Bucky, just so we can watch him die.

Djo on May 6, 2008

69

I personaly think Ben Affleck would make a great Cap. America anyone agree?

DAC on May 6, 2008

70

The Ultimate line actually suggested McConaughey for Giant-Man and Brad Pitt for Cap.

One of my dark horse picks for the role is Ed Burns. He grew up in Queens and kind of looks the part. He might not be perfect, but I'm kind of liking the idea.

Plus he did the whole boot camp thing with the Private Ryan cast.

Mongo on May 6, 2008

71

no.

and no to matt damon as well, he will ruin it with his whiny lil bitchy voice, ive hated him since he sat crying in the fetal position throughout saving private ryan while everyone around him was killing germans. besides hes tied up with about 4 movies including bourne 4 til 2010

as steve buscemi couldnt be bruce banner, how about as cap america? buscemis the man

harrison on May 6, 2008

72

Like I said, Burns isn't perfect but I like him better than a lot of the other choices being tossed about.

Most are too old, too fat or just plain wrong for the role.

One knock against him is that he tends to whine in most of his roles. I think thta might be the characters though.

Mongo on May 6, 2008

73

Harrison,

Don't mean to shatter your illusions, but Matt Damon did not sit "crying in the fetal position throughout SAVING PRIVATE RYAN while everyone around him was killing Germans."

That was just a character. Matt Damon was playing pretend. Acting a script written by someone else.

Movies in general are a game of 'pretend.'

Remember? Like your parents taught you.

M. on May 6, 2008

74

I'm sorry #59, but if Hayden Christensen never acts again, it will be too soon. He butchered the character of Darth Vader, and I will never, ever forgive him. What a little bitch.

Josh Brolin is an interesting choice, as is Nathan Fillion. I can see them both in the role. But I still think Gosling could probably do a good job. If he bulked up, which he would (he got fired from a movie he was gonna do because he deliberately gained weight for his character and the director didn't approve). He's a very talented actor, he's committed, and hes got the look.

Kelly B. on May 6, 2008

75

"I personaly think Ben Affleck would make a great Cap. America anyone agree?"

Ben Affleck was already Daredevil, if he was the Cap then it would destroy the universe.

Kail on May 6, 2008

76

yea his character did, and to me it seems he plays that same role in all of his movies just on different levels of whiny bitch

harrison on May 6, 2008

77

If they could get Steve Buscemi as pre-Serum Steve, it would not matter who they cast b/c that would simply be THE ULTIMATE.

Alot of people despise Ed Burns - myself pretty much included.

He's like the Hilary Clinton of acting. Plenty of potential & cred, but he just polarizes people.
(Difference is, I can't name one person who really fanatical about him, either…)

I accept the Sizemore thumbs down. But as long as we've moved past all those hot young actors that could NEVER fill this guy's boots, I am cool.

I think the funniest would be Steve Buscemi as weak Steve, and Stone Cold Steve Austin as post-serum Steve - but in a way that he keeps reverting back to weak Steve, a 'la the HULK.

(And Ben Affleck DID destroy the Universe. The second he took up his friend, Matt's advice, and thought he'd make a good actor.)

Djo. Sizemore. on May 6, 2008

78

what about Ryan Reynolds although I see him as more of the Flash type of guy. Eric Bana anyone?
Wadda about Bruce Willis, or Kiefer Sutherland, hell maybe even Mark Wahlberg. Gerard Butler without the accent. Sean Bean maybe.

Xerxex on May 6, 2008

79

Oey vey..please not Matthew. I like him in other stuff..but not this. Geesh…please find a no-name and give them a chance. Somebody..help the captain!

Bry from Chi on May 6, 2008

80

First person who comes to mind is Scott Speedman; I think he'd be excellent. Matthew Fox is an interesting thought… he could be OK. Casting Matthew McConaughey, Ben Affleck, Matt Damon, or Ryan Reynolds would be catastrophic for this role.

Lorelai on May 6, 2008

81

When's the next writer's strike?

wm on May 6, 2008

82

Captain America playing bongos…naked

wm on May 6, 2008

83

Cheyenne Jackson

Dmillerium on May 6, 2008

84

I like Ben Affleck but he is such a hit or miss actor. Everytime you go to see a movie of his you're wondering "am I going to get good Ben or bad Ben." Also, like someone said before he played Daredevil and I don't think you would ever see them pick another actor who has been a major character in a different franchise. I just don't see how that would work at all and for that reason Damon and Craig couldn't be serious contenders either imo.

The people who brought up Craig it made me wonder would you not have a problem with capt. america being played by a foreigner? I never really care about that stuff personally but if they did go with someone who wasn't american I feel like some fans would just go ballistic.

Janet on May 6, 2008

85

What about Karl Urban…could work out well…

teagan73 on May 6, 2008

86

What's wrong with McConaughey? He was in one bad movie, and a couple of kinda 'meh' movies, and people write him off? I think he'd make a pretty good cap, considering the possible alternatives out there.

Squiggly_P on May 6, 2008

87

I was joking when i said ben affleck, lol I can't belive its gone this far. Just for the record I do hate Ben affleck. Oh and dont forgett he was superman to, to bad it was a different universe. If it had been the same perhapse he would have died.

DAC on May 6, 2008

88

The best choices for Cap.
Mark Valley (Boston Legal)
George Eads (CSI)
Josh Holloway (LOST)
Josh Duhamel (Transformers)
Kevin Mckidd (ROME)
Jason Lewis (Sex and the City)

Best for Red Skull.
Bill Nighy (Pirates - Davey Jones)
Stellan Scarsgard (Pirates - Bootstrap)
Timothy Dalton (007)
Richard Roxbury (Van Helsing)
Daniel Craig (BOND)

shawn on May 6, 2008

89

You idiot - explain why he wouldn't be a good Captain America, or go down as just another Hollywood hack.

batfreak on May 6, 2008

90

If they cast McConaughey I will be VERY VERY angry. How can they even consider him for the role after the great choises of Robert Downey Jr. for Iron Man and Edward Norton as the Hulk. #14 is absolutely right. I like Aaron Eckhart or what about Christian Bale.

Iron Man Fan on May 6, 2008

91

Don't screw this up Marvel. NO McCwhateverhisnameis.The best choices I've heard are (in no order)
Josh Brolin
Brad Pitt
Scott Speedman
Matthew Fox

Eyes and hair are no problem to fix, bulk is changable. The problem is Cap will probably be in more than his solo movie and Avengers so it has to be a younger guy (early thirties). And I really think Captain America should be AMERICAN so no Craig (sorry). The main criteria are:

look good with blonde hair and blue eyes
can get Cap'n buff
not too old (for future installments)
American (actually a strong preference not a qualification)
most importantly be able to hold his own against the likes of Robert Downy Jr. and Ed Norton (who might eventually join the avengers…Hollywood)

so this will be a reallly tough role to fill and i think the best choice is an unknown or relatively unknown with strong acting chops. Because come on RDJ will defer to him or hold the same amount of authority and yeah screw Superman, Captain needs to have a daunting presence. Thanks for reading

If Kiefer Sutherland was 10 years younger…:(

silver on May 6, 2008

92

oh yeah i think Aaron Eckhary might be the best idea I've heard i dont give a shit if he's Two-Face entirely different universes or Thomas Jane he is the Punisher no longer. Those are my two favorite "well known" actors. Ben Affleck already ruined Daredevil for me and I got this weird feeling about Matt Damon…even though i think he's cool

silver on May 6, 2008

93

Matthew McConaughey as Cap?

Hellz no, how he gonna sling the shield with those 'T-Rex' arms of his? Plus he has yet to prove he can shed his southern accent, I'd take him as John Walker USAgent but not for Captain America.

PimpSlapStick on May 6, 2008

94

@ #83 Karl Urban shouldn't play Cap. HE SHOULD PLAY THOR!!! Go back to LOTR and take a good look.

jason_md2020 on May 6, 2008

95

I kinda like the Josh Duhamel idea for Cap, I can see him in the role.

PimpSlapStick on May 6, 2008

96

#5 you want Shaggy as Cap? WTF

PimpSlapStick on May 6, 2008

97

^Shaggy…lol…

silver on May 6, 2008

98

The best suggestions so far (not ranked) are

Josh Brolin
Nathan Fillion
Scott Speedman

Bucky: Chris Pine, maybe, opposite Fillion or Brolin.
Not enough age contrast to cast Pine opposite Speedman.


if we each get to suggest one actor who would be amazingly bad,
how about Justin Long? Hi, I'm a Mac, and I'm non-threatening.
I like Justin Long, by the way. Just sayin'.

emilio on May 6, 2008

99

Squiggly_P wrote: What's wrong with McConaughey? He was in one bad movie, and a couple of kinda 'meh' movies, and people write him off? I think he'd make a pretty good cap, considering the possible alternatives out there.


One bad movie!?? I count six. "Fool's Gold", "Failure to Launch", "Sahara", "How to Lose a Guy in 10 Days", "Reign of Fire" and "The Wedding Planner". I'm sure the upcoming "Surfer Dude" (puke) will be added to this list. Let's face it, McConaughey has only starred in one or two good movies. The rest (and not the bad films I listed above) were not really a Matthew McConaughey film. But more of a ensemble movie.

Rob on May 6, 2008

100

Why not cast Lito Lapid!

Doodle on May 6, 2008

101

or Ace Vergel

Doodle on May 6, 2008

102

Mark Wahlberg.

Who's with me?

Glodokboy on May 6, 2008

103

JOSH HOLLOWAY! thats the guy! not well known, and he can kick some ass! just watch LOST!

Lou on May 6, 2008

104

I love how the comic controversies on FirstShowing always get 100+ comments lol

silver on May 6, 2008

105

JOSH LUCAS should play Captain America

michaelsdca on May 6, 2008

106

Holy crap I didnt even think of Josh Holloway!! Wow go lost fans I actually think that would be a pretty good choice

Nate on May 7, 2008

107

How about John Cena from the marine? i know he's a wrestler but with some acting lessons he could be alright, plus he's pretty much unknown… And he's big enough and built enough for the role, but he probably lacks the depth that is needed too… He's got another movie coming out in 2009, lets see how he fairs as a lead detective?

Matoojo on May 7, 2008

108

McConaughey as Cap?? Just the thought sends chills down my spine. Cap can't be played by an "actor" that has sold his soul to the romantic comedy genre.

My choice is JASON LEWIS. He's a relative unknown, a pretty good actor, and looks exactly like Cap. Just see for yourself: http://www.exposay.com/celebrity-photos/jason-lewis-2005-vanity-fair-oscar-party-5wVDIA.jpg

http://www.exposay.com/celebrity-photos/jason-lewis-2004-vanity-fair-oscar-party-00Oqcv.jpg

Daas on May 7, 2008

109

I think Speedman is the best choice named so far.

John Cena has the look and could have the additude, but this really dosent need to be another crappy WWF movie. Plus i doubt he can act in a serious blockbuster type movie.

On a different topic someone mentioned Karl Urban for Thor, thats perfect and that would free up Jacon McKidd (who i think looks the part of Cap) to play Steve.

Goose on May 7, 2008

110

Well just my two cents but…..

NO mathew M., Im sayin no to thoimas jane…he is already the punisher. NO to ANY wrestler, they definately would have the physique to pull off the look but definately not the experience and depth you want CAp.'s character to be portrayed…

Definately is okay with Josh H. i actually saw in a WIZARD mag., Spiderman 3 on front cover, and they were talkin about makin more marvel movies, they threw around some names and he actually was thought to be a good hero character( not sure who they had him cast as).

I dont think you wanna go with a huge name on this one for one reason…that person is gonna forever be know as that character and you dont want to get stuck in that mind frame i.e. When you say toby Mcguire —spiderman–no one will know him as anything else….that would cause alot of negative and mixed reactions from movie fans.

The Best person for thor is definately DOlPH LUNDREN….the russian badass who has done alot of action movies…jus might work!

but unless you have someone made for the part like Angie Jolie as tomb raider, then your takin a chance on any actor……american cinema now a days is a tough crowd to please!

I think marvel should be very careful too, if the wrong person plays the role a messes it up, it will be hard gettin the comic book fans back on board….like the first HULK that flopped and the second and third X-MEN but that was more of the story directors that screwed that up but…..thats all im sayin…

I welcome comments……..

ScorpionKing on May 7, 2008

111

Well just my two cents but…..

NO mathew M., Im sayin no to thoimas jane…he is already the punisher. NO to ANY wrestler, they definately would have the physique to pull off the look but definately not the experience and depth you want CAp.'s character to be portrayed…

Definately is okay with Josh H. i actually saw in a WIZARD mag., Spiderman 3 on front cover, and they were talkin about makin more marvel movies, they threw around some names and he actually was thought to be a good hero character( not sure who they had him cast as).

I dont think you wanna go with a huge name on this one for one reason…that person is gonna forever be know as that character and you dont want to get stuck in that mind frame i.e. When you say toby Mcguire —spiderman–no one will know him as anything else….that would cause alot of negative and mixed reactions from movie fans.

The Best person for thor is definately DOlPH LUNDREN….the russian badass who has done alot of action moviesand would be perfect for the Viking GOD…jus might work! but unless you have someone made for the part like Angie Jolie as tomb raider, then your takin a chance on any actor……american cinema now a days is a tough crowd to please!

I think marvel should be very careful too, if the wrong person plays the role a messes it up, it will be hard gettin the comic book fans back on board….like the first HULK that flopped and the second and third X-MEN but that was more of the story directors that screwed that up but…..thats all im sayin…

I welcome comments……..

ScorpionKing on May 7, 2008

112

i know this is hard for everyone to deal with….. but matthew mcconaughey has shown me on a couple occasions that he is a total badass….

1.) just watch the movie frailty and you will see that he is actually a legit actor who stole the show in an awesome film

2.) he got arrested for playing the bongos high in his house in austin, apparently he was causing enough of a ruckus for someone to call the cops!

i know that comic book movies are really touchy when it comes to big name actors but give the man a break, its not his fault the ladies love him

big stone on May 7, 2008

113

There's a missing piece to Iron Man's success that many of you are missing:

-Robert Downey was not the first choice for Tony Stark, it could easily be argued that
he does not resemble him AT ALL.

-For every Blonde, Blue-Eyed dollface on this list- REALIZE that you're essentially saying
David Hasselhoff should have played Tony Stark.

Yeah, he looks just like Tony did in the comics, and yes, he's a well known actor.

BUT DOES HE HAVE T.A.L.E.N.T. ???

The Public, who are not comic fans, who have little clue who Iron Man is, who simply love to see great actors in entertaining movies - are eating this up NOT b/c Robert Downey looks like the guy you see in the comics, but b/c he's an artist at what he does, and Favreau's been investing several years into this project as well.

There's a rare breed of skilled character actors out there, who- IN THE RIGHT SITUATION (Downey's being, this is his career-making role, and he's HUNGRY FOR IT)- can carry almost an entire film, w/ the help of an equally talented director (Favreau's also got kids to feed, and needed a hit).

My point being - slice all guys who can get by on looks alone OFF THIS LIST. They don't NEED to play Cap, so why would they invest ANYthing extra into a role that - particularly if they've never read comics in the first place - have little to no understanding of.

Mccaunahey (I refuse to EVER spell this name right) could be that guy. He needs a career change. BADLY.

But what extra can we expect from him? We'll end up with a smarmy Icon of Liberty, broadcasting to the whole world that, in fact, THIS is what America's all about.

So the real question here is not who looks like the 2-Dimensional character, STeve Rogers (forget physique, forget the eyes, the hair- Downey had next none of these): But who can FILL this role, and defy ALL of our expectations, to flesh this pulp-symbol cum-propaganda hero, into something not only believable, but worth spreading the word about.

My new 2 cents: Marvel should NOT slate movies on their schedule, nor announce actors, until Directors are attached who will bring equal skill to realizing their characters to the screen.

PLUS: (as I'm beginning to detect w/ the Hulk) Marvel films will each require enough CGI-rendering time and money to invest in a quality product. Otherwise, we've seen time & again they're perfectly capable of making movies not worth seeing.

The New Marvel studios may be onto something with Iron Man, but we and they are kidding themselves to think it was as simple as- throw a million at a good looking actor and you've got a hit.

Iron Man's Success is a bit more Alchemical: timing, talent, hunger, word-of-mouth combined w/ aggressive promotion, stretched out over a year or so…
It's not formulaic, and I'm not convinced simply "casting a star" (a'hem, Matthew Mccaunahey) is going to make the Public "Believe" in Captain America.

(Okay, that's about 5 cents)

Djo. on May 7, 2008

114

I can't believe they are seriously thinking of McConaughey. He is a total beach bum and smokes waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaayyyyyyyyyy too much of whatever he's on. To hire him is to kill Capt. and the Avengers.

However, I do like Mathew Fox or Matt Damon. They both are fine actors, a bit gritty for our post-9/11 world, and they aren't big household names yet (well not Damon, thank you Sarah "I fucked Matt Damon" Silverman).

But do not hire Daniel Craig. Why? BECAUSE HE'S BRITISH! IT'S NOT CAPITAN ENGLAND!

And #12, HHH would be a good choice for Thor. They're both kickass, they both wield a hammer, and they look exactly the same. Maybe if he gets a few acting lessons, it could work.

Ajax on May 7, 2008

115

Anyone who needs acting lessons to play this role is OUT.

This guys is supposed to LEAD the Avengers. They're not supposed to lead him.

LEAD ACTOR=An actor who can lead an ensemble.

Plus, Trimple H is too mean to play America's Biggest Boy Scout.
Wrestlers as film actors: Nope (see Southland Tales for proof).

Niles from Frasier: Pre-Serum Steve Rogers.
Kelsey Grammar: Captain America.
Malcolm in the Middle: Bucky (just to watch him die)
Leonard Nimoy: Aged Prince Namor, telling Cap's story as flashback.

Daniel Craig as: Captain Britain.

Djo. on May 7, 2008

116

I would have to say the one person that would nail the part visually that is. would have to be The Natural Randy Couture. Now I know What your thinking. Can he act? And the short answer would have to be probably not. But I was just going by who whould truely look just like Captain America. And lets face it the guy is damn near being a super hero anyway.

Cluffy101 on May 7, 2008

117

Vin Diesel!

ni.Je on May 7, 2008

118

Let's get back to the root of this article. Would Matthew McConaughey be a good fit for the part. Well, let's think like a marvel exec for a second. This would be at least a 3 picture deal. With The Avengers being on the ticket too, you would need someone who is as recognizable as Robert Downey Jr. to fill that part.

Also, let's face it, Matthew's acting skills aside (and I do think back in the day he put alittle more effort into it, A Time to Kill, Reign of Fire), the Marvel guys need a guy to play the part that will draw in the Female audience also. As guys, we are going to see this movie, even if Paul Reubens is cast.

I can think of others that I would prefer to be in the part, like Matthew Fox or Ryan Reynolds, but I can see where McConaughey would be on the top of a very short list.

mjs on May 7, 2008

119

See, that's what I like a Comic Book characters.

I keep getting older, and they stay (roughly) the SAME age.

Djo. on May 7, 2008

120

I think McConaughey is a terrible chose for cap. He just doesnt fit and that is the bottom line. first off his personality is all wrong. Lets fast it hes a f'n retard. And second he jst isnt big enough.

Cluffy101 on May 7, 2008

121

Ryan Reynolds is an awsome idea. He's an awsome actor and he can play a serious role a very well. (amityville horror, smokin aces). Plus he is a big f'n guy. He was hugh in Blade. He seems to be the perfect choice .
Then again I heard e was supposed to be The Flash in he JLA movie.

Cluffy101 on May 7, 2008

122

justin hartley would be an awesome captain america. young, blonde… not THAT well established name.

jacob1112 on May 7, 2008

123

this discussion is terribly prescient — starting at 4:47
http://www.hulu.com/watch/18246/family-guy-former-life-of-brian

"[matthew mcconaughey] sucks donkey ass"

kevin powers on May 7, 2008

124

Justin Chambers… I just saw him in Zodiac on Showtime and he looks like he could definitely pull off the roll.

cap on May 7, 2008

125

I just keep thinking people are missing the point. Forget the marketing, forget Marvel for a second, this is being brandied about by us, the public on the web who follows these movies that we find near and dear to us, extremely intently.

Cap is an ideology. Forget how other countries see him, hell forget how our modern angst ridden society sees him as "Too Goody Two Shoes", try and think like him for a second. He could care less if people think he is too Boyscout-ish. He does what he does, simply because the ideals are virtueous and honerable and right. Not right for America, or in a self interested way, but right because the ideas of freedom, and justice, and fairplay, and hope, and with hardwork advancement , and independence, and a society where the convergence and melding and acceptance of all people, only strengthens it, not divides it.

He represents what is best in all of us, and not all of us being soley Americans, but truly all of us, which is what America was (perhaps someday will be again), was suppose to stand for.

Now take those ideals, wrap them in a body of physical perfection, and most importantly, the undying will of a man who truly believes in these ideals and is willing to fight for them completely unselfishly, just because they're the right thing to believe in, and you have Steve Rogers.

Picture also a man who is close to 300 lbs of physical perfection,between the age of 23-27 yrs old, and combat skills, and war time experience fighting the evil that was the very antithesis of his beliefs, and ther you have Captain America.

Now try and picture any known actor being able to fill that role. I'm not unwilling, but I just can't seem to do it. It is very important that the actor is physically believable, and that he commands the presence that is Cap. Mathew Mc doesn't do that for me, nor does anyone I can think of. I'm not against a known actor, but I have to believe him, and no one comes to mind.

Iron man worked because Tony Stark was damaged, and jaded, and spoiled rich boy who self indulged and lived to excesses, but had a re-awakening, just as RDJ did, which made his connection to the character, believeable and gave him good source material to pull from to do this role. He has talent he can act, but along with this he had connection and viability to do this character.

Who do you know can connect with Captain America and what he's about, to also pull off this role. Yes it's acting, but I'm a firm believer that both the actor and the director and the public has to look at this person playing the role, and buy in that he fits the potential, otherwise, it's just a money making machine throwing dollars at any popular person, dressing him up in a suit, and cashing in.

Tristan

TRISTAN on May 7, 2008

126

I think he'd be good. But to those who bash him:

Keep in mind that he _was_ arrested for possession of marijuana when his neighbors complained about the music. He was also naked and playing the bongos. How can you not like that.

http://www.thesmokinggun.com/mugshots/mcconaugheymug1.html

aditya on May 7, 2008

127

haha yea kevin(123) i watched that same clip earlier and was gonna post it, summed up everyones arguments nicely

and after what 126 said, what could be more american? i still think he can do it

harrison on May 7, 2008

128

First things first…as for Scott Speedwhatever and Josh Brolin not a hope in heck should they play Cap. America. Second….there are only four guys right now that should be remotely considered for the part of Cap. America. Matthew McConnaughey, Brad Pitt, Gerard Butler, and maybe Thomas Jane.

The reason is simple for these four to be considered and all the others to be disregarded. The reason is not only are you doing a Captain America movie but you are also doing an Avengers movie with this actor in the CA role. You need somebody who will be able to fit in and not be intimadated or star struck by the likes of Samual L. Jackson, Robert Downey Jr. or Ed Norton. You need an actor not a look alike like Brandon Routh was. You need someone who can elevate their performance and hold their own while all the while putting their own little touch to the role.

Say what you will about Matthew McC. but I think he could potentially be the right choice for CA.

chester on May 7, 2008

129

damn i just went on google and saw pics of this dude JASON LEWIS, and he is Captain America! and if you want some one who can act then i say Josh Holloway!

Lou on May 7, 2008

130

The Cap should be a guy that represents the ideals this country was built on. He should be like a mascot of everything this country (says that it) stands for. He should be someone we can believe in and respect. Somewhat like a Superman of the Marvel universe, but like what #125 Tristan said "300 lbs of physical perfection". Bongos, Reign of Fire, marijuana or not I can never see myself supporting Matthew McC.

silver on May 7, 2008

131

At the same time, remember how much everyone bitched and moaned about Heath Ledger getting cast as the joker? There was nothing but doom and gloom posts all around the internet about that casting choice and not a one of us can deny any more that it seems to have been the perfect choice. Maybe McConaughey will surprise us all and really nail the part. I doubt it, but I also wouldnt be floored if he did.

Goose on May 8, 2008

132

McConaughey? That'd be a definite stepdown from Downey and Norton in Marvel Studios's Iron Man and Hulk. Brad Pitt would have been great in the role ten years ago. To goose, at least Ledger had an Oscar nomination before he was cast as the Joker and the cynicism went into overdrive.

Chris on May 8, 2008

133

To Aditya:
I was arrested last year for beating a dude up and had weed on me. That certainly doesnt mean i would make a good cap. It just means I should have ran faster and I suck at hiding pot. Then again I wasnt naked so you never know i guess.

Cluffy101 on May 8, 2008

134

"300 pounds of physical perfection, between the age of 23-27 yrs "? Are you joking, no. 125? Captain America is a big, physically idealized warrior, but there's no way in hell you'd want him played by anyone in their early 20's, and certainly no one weighing in anywhere near 300 pounds. Have you ever looked at WWE's Brock Lesner? He looks like a muscle bound freak, he's 6'5"… and he tops out at only 265. A 300 pound muscleman would be a terrible choice for Cap, who has always been portrayed in the comics as being agile as the greatest olympic gymnasts.

patrick on May 8, 2008

135

Patrick (134)

Marvel used to put out a series of books on their entire Marvel Universe, complete with stats and powers and weapons, (and even some physics lessons in how the could work). This was in the late 80's. There Cap was listed as 6'4" 285 lbs, able to bench over 800 with effort.

I have seen the Ultimates Hero Universe Dictionary listing him at 6' 3" and 250,
and the current marvel site lists him 6' 2" 240, all saying he presses 800 pounds or better.
Check: http://www.marveldirectory.com/individuals/c/captainamerica.htm

Now you are correct he does have amazing agilityand gymnastic skills, but he also has huge size and Mass. His Generic build of 6'2" 240 puts him at The Rocks size in Scorpian King. But even more muscular to bench 800 pounds (The Rock Can't do that), So picture that, and all the gymnastic ability you talk of. I agree my 300 pound statement was a bit of an exaggeration but it's a mixture of the previous Marvel Specs from 240-285 that they themselves state. Check it out. He was Born somewhere between 1912 - 1917 according to marvel too, so by 1941 when he enters the super soldier program he'd be 24 and basically stops ageing, again check it out. So although experienced and mature mentally and wise beyond his years, his looks are still quite young. Hard combination, for any actor to pull off.
But you're focused specifically on the physical, it's his soul that is the real challenge here, and buying in that the actor that plays him can do that justice (pun intended). It's always been his total immersement in the founding principles of our democracy (The ideals we say we aspire to have) that he totally champions because he whole heartedly believes in them. His very presence commands respect and a feeling of security and admiration for he represents what we all strive to be. No one I see as 'the popular' or 'in the publics eye' choice, is believable to me. Mathew McConaughey, Brad Pitt, etc. To me it would have to be someone that is experienced but has yet to make it big, or a complete unknown. If someone did mention a well known actor that could fit the bill, I'd be fine with it, but I just can't see it so far.

Tristan

TRISTAN on May 8, 2008

136

matt damon

kien on May 8, 2008

137

A'hem. Ya'll need girlfriends.

Stats schmatts.

Hobbits were different sizes than the actors, b/c do you really want to watch midgets or
dwarves covered in hair when they can find a creative solution? (Granted, Willow was cool, but Jackson's movies are pretty damn innovative)

Ever hear of 'Movie Magic'?

I agree we need an actor of impressive stature, but please, for the good of Society (and your ability to socialize w/ the opposite sex)- leave the fanboy Stats out of this.

Djo Fortunado on May 8, 2008

138

Djo'

Movie Magic, yup , Same Magic they used in League of Extraordinary Gentlemen, what a beaut that was, even with well known accomplished actors (Just a comic book gone awry,,,,,in hollyweirds hands). Or Daredevil, or FF.

My point is actors alone aren't enough, it is the culmination of story, directors insight into who the character is, and an actor with the chops to play that character and be believeable, along with effects, and Movie Magic.

as far as :Hobbits were different sizes than the actors, b/c do you really want to watch midgets or
dwarves covered in hair when they can find a creative solution? (Granted, Willow was cool, but Jackson's movies are pretty damn innovative)


That's a ridiculous statement. Of course we need CGI to aid in believeability, and in P.J. LOTR, he uses many great tricks to alter the characters from a distance (Both CGI, Midgets, and children for far shots for point of reference against the human population.) and close ups are a reference between each other, so when two hobbits are together he doesn't have to make them different than interaction of any two Human size actors, it's only in reference to their surroundings( trees, houses etc).

That's different than CAP, OK let me put it another way, Why is the HULK CGI instead of a person in green makeup useing point of reference technique to make him simply look larger than human. Because they can't find a human that's 8 feet tall and weighs a thousand pounds, and because they can't use the overlay technique to adjust smoothly to a human body who'll exist in a huge portion of the film. That's very tough. It's easier to do him as completely CGI. Oh and by the way, since stats don't matter, it would be ok with everyone if the hulk were 5'10" and weight 185 as long as it was solid green skinned muscle…..and throwing tanks around…….. think about that,,,,, My point is, it needs to be a realistic representation of what we "Fan-Boys" (who are a huge reason why these characters are so popular so that these movies are even being made, and why Jon Favreau spent so much time listening and reacting to what fan-boys wrote to him about Iron Man), see it as. Just think about my Hulk example, if you'd be ok with the 5'10" hulk than you're not a fan-boy, if not, well you're in with the rest of us.

Now Cap is human, he's just a stacked guy, physical perfection. That's what he has been defined by and what we have come to expect, so yes, they have to be close to that to make it believable or else it will likely suck.

By the way, I'll ask my wife if I can get the girlfriend you suggest. Or better yet, I'll give you the number of my last two, either of them will certainly be "Justice" for your lack of Fan-Boy Tolerance.

Tristan

TRISTAN on May 8, 2008

139

I'm gonna pimp out Nathan Fillion again, and more to the point explain why I think he'd be a great C.A.

In Serenity & Firefly he played a veteran with a very deep sense of honor, captained his crew and always gave a great delivery whenever he had to give a monologue. (Among being a grade-A ass kicker, Cap often was called upon to give rousing speeches.) When Fillion played this character I had no problem buying into his performance that this character would die for his friends, his crew, and most of all the moral high ground.

Loyalty, leadership & a sense of honor. Everything Captain America is & everything the guy playing him has to bring to the screen.

But that's just my $.02. Your mileage may vary.

jason_md2020 on May 8, 2008

140

Ouch. Please, the more you defend yourself the more frightening you get.

I was only ragging on you, bro. Simple one liner response would've sufficed.

I'm a fan too- but to put it one way, know those pins of Wolverine, saying "Bite Me Fanboy"?

Why would he say that?

B/c he knows how to keep his cool.

So chill out. These are comic books, bub.

Djo Fortunado on May 8, 2008

141

Djo,

If it came across as anger rather than sarcasm you misread it. It's not angerat all, maybe passion for a character that i really feel strongly about. I'm not losing my cool at all.

or here for your one liner; "Angry, you wouldn't like me when I'm angry"

TRISTAN on May 8, 2008

142

Lucas Haas? Why would Robert Downey Jr. be another superhero or Bale for that matter? Typecast anyone???

wm on May 8, 2008

143

I nominate Tristan to play Cap, he's got the monologues down to a tee!

Matoojo on May 8, 2008

144

Marvel should take a lesson from casting the wrong people in big roles, Nicholas Cage ruined Ghost Rider. Then again he ruins everything. He couldn't even play a bald guy if he had to and he is!!! One person no one has mentioned he has that "super hero physique" and can actually pull off serious roles is Ryan Reynolds. Most people know him for doing comedy roles, but go watch him in Amityville Horror. He would be perfect for this.

bARBARIAN OF A NEW ERA on May 8, 2008

145

Hes already cast as Deadpool and he was mentioned earlier up the list. While he would probably do great at the role (hes on of my favorite actors) id much rather see him as deadpool than as Cap.

Goose on May 9, 2008

146

I forgot the Reynolds was to be deadpool and i agree he will make a much deadpool at that. matoojo is right though Tristan should be cap.

Cluffy101 on May 9, 2008

147

Oh what about the guy from Transformers and Hitman? What is his name ? Someone get back to me on that please. Anyways his name aside. The guy is a good actor and very serious but not without a sence of humor. Perfect for the role of cap and the guy is hugh in Hitman. He would wear the uniform and blend into the charactor with ease. What say ye?

Cluffy101 on May 9, 2008

148

NATHAN FILLION!!!!! Just give him some blue contacts, a bleach job and juice him up already. Sheez.

Paigey! on May 9, 2008

149

I think the conclusion is that no-one can seriously be considered for the role of Captain America.

So you have no choice but to go for the one that no one would POSSIBLY take seriously:

hence, Matthew Mecunnuhoy.

Djo Fortunado on May 9, 2008

150

Captain America needs to be a no name or someone who has made a name with hero characters like Brad Pitt (Achilles). Captain America should be a no name just like Superman Returns. Lets face it no one would have expected Brandon Routh to be a close comparison to Christopher Reeves but he was. As for Thor, I have one movie for everybody to think about- 300!!! If Gerard Butler can hide that thick accent of his, he is the perfect Thor. We already saw his cockiness and confidence as King Leonidus, why not the confident Thor? Think about that one.

147- Timothy Olyphant was Hitman and Josh Duhamel was in Transformers. Both are bery good suggestions for Captain America. Only if Josh Duhamel were to put about 30 pounds of rip on.

Dan on May 9, 2008

151

A lot of people are thinking of Josh Holloway to portray him, but I don't really think so. First of all, he (or his character on LOST, I honestly don't know if he is like that in real life or if it's just an act) has a really thick, Southern accent. There's no way I would be able to take cap. seriously if he had that. Second, and maybe more importantly, I am not sure if he can take on the role. I do not know of any other work he is in, and he only plays a con man on an island on LOST. While I do like him, I don't know if he is the best choice.

150- Yes! I agree 100% now. Gerard is the only choice for Thor after 300.

Ajax on May 9, 2008

152

Might I suggest it'd be like Stallone in "Judge Dredd"…physically ideal, but otherwise…

L'il Matt on May 10, 2008

153

Okay, I'll do it. All you had to do was ask. I'm built, good looking, a big fan of Captain America, and I teach acting. Sign me up, please!

Marcus on May 10, 2008

154

Hey, I know this guy. He'd be PERFECT!! We should put an upcoming star in the role of Captain America. Who's with me! Trust me, he will be awesome!

Steve on May 10, 2008

155

i know this may not be the popular choice, but i like Brad Pitt as Captain America, i was watching Troy for the billionth time last night.
Pitt was able to run around and do fancy action hero moves with a shield strapped to his back, not to mention he is blonde, doesn't appear to look too old not any worse than McConaughey anyway, he has the chin and the eyes.

also in the Ultimates comic they joked around that Steve Rogers looks like Pitt.

The Delightful Deviant on May 10, 2008

156

Well, Marcus #153 would probably be better than McConaughey. MARCUS ALL THE WAY!

Ajax on May 10, 2008

157

i like the idea of aaron eckhart but he's gonna be in batman, jason lewis i think would also be a good choice, someone who i think would be good could be ben mckenzie people may think a bit teeny but he's was good in junebug and he's ment to be in the new stanford prison experiment and he's in the age bracket of late early 30's so he would age into the role for future sequals

declan on May 10, 2008

158

I got it, the man that should play old Capn America, is a T.V. actor, who is a fellow cast mate of Matthew Fox. Josh Holloway. He would have to change his voice and beef up a little, I mean if Christian Bale can sound America this San Jose Californi could sound like Good Ole Cap'n America.

Xerxex on May 10, 2008

159

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0574131/

I mean the guy already did Captain Awesome in Chuck, he looks the role to a T and could propel this guy into stardom. I mean seriously for only havinjg limited screen time in the show Chuck he stole a hell of allot of scenes.

Boomba on May 10, 2008

160

What do you guys think about David Boreanaz, Christian Kane, or Scott Caan? Personally I would go with Timothy Olyphant, but these other guys are interesting prospects.

m.penn on May 11, 2008

161

Captain America (Steven "Steve" Grant Rogers) is 6'2", 240 lbs, Blue Eyes with Blond Hair.
The eyes and hair is no problem, but the actor should be able to fit the height at least 6'1" minimum and the actor's appearance should also fit an age around 28 to 35 (38 is pushing it). Someone who is overexposed and a bit short shouldn't play the part. Like : Matthew McConaughey, Brad Pitt (is too short and already being rumored to play the part of Thor anyway), Brandon Routh (already ruined Superman, but who knows).
Who ever's going to play Captain America should be a fresh face and have to be an American, like:
Josh Hartnett–> 6' 3" (21 July 1978), Charlie O'Connell–> 6' 3" (21 April 1975), Josh Duhamel–>6' 3½" (14 November 1972), Noah Wyle–> 6' 2" (4 June 1971), Tom Everett Scott–> 6' 2" (7 September 1970), and Matthew Lillard–> 6' 3" (24 January 1970).

Riordan on May 11, 2008

162

Riordan ever heard of movie magic? You don't think Elijah wood is really 4 ft. tall do you? With camera angles you can easily make someone up to 2 ft. tall (not that i want someone 4' 2” to play Cap'), but I agree that the actor should be at least physically imposing. My picks are (in no order):

Matt Damon- has already achieved bad-ass status (Bourne), can also act (THe Good Shepard, THe Departed, Good Will Hunting), can have blonde hair and blue eyes

Brad Pitt- he can be bad-ass with a shield (Troy), can act well (Se7en & Fight Club), blonde hair blue eyes. Personlly I'd rather see Pitt as Captain that Thor (and definitely over Matt McC)

Aaron Eckhart- Ryan Reynolds was Hannibal King and is now going to be Deadpool so why cant Two-Face be Cap? He has the acting chops, blonde hair, blue eyes and American. He just needs a lil' bulk

Thomas Jane- I would love to see him as Cap' because he can have blone hair, blue eyes, can be a bad-ass, to my knowledge a good actor, and he is extremely dedicated to his roles ( he put on 30 lbs. of muscle for the Punisher). And he is not the Punisher anymore Ray Stevenson is.

Captain America should be like the US mascot or poster boy and the actor should be someone we can take pride in and respect. I think CA should be not only more bad-ass than Superman but also more intimidating like what Logan said when he speaks everyone shuts up especially RDJ

As for Thor the best choices are Sean Bean (LOTR), Gerald Butler (300), Kevin Durand (Lost), and Karl Urban (LOTR). With Sean Bean being the best and most bad-ass choice. The others just don't compare to Sean Bean in my book they are just Plan B's. He just screams Thor.

silver on May 11, 2008

163

One of my first thoughts for Captain America is Thomas John Patrick Welling who played Clark Kent on the TV series SmallVille.

Brad on May 11, 2008

164

Thomas Welling is around 6'2 or 6'3 in height with the right build (perhaps with a bit more training) and a "pretty boy" face who would appeal to the female audience no doubt. I haven't watched SmallVille enough to know if his acting abilities are up to the task.

Brad on May 11, 2008

165

dulph lundgren or zack morris from save dby the bell would be a good choice

richard fairbrass on May 11, 2008

166

I think you need a younger actor, someone like Devon Sawa, who isn't into much right now. A person with a name would ruin this character.

Jessica Lugo on May 11, 2008

167

silver on May 11, 2008,
I agree, Matt Damon is too short and also way out there to play C.A.
Imagine C.A. wearing high heel boots, LOL, and I don't want to watch a movie filled with camera tricks just to hide the actor's obvious imperfection. Bad Ass you say, Nobody expected R.Downey to play Iron Man and he still kicked ass.
If you're not worried about height, Josh Duhamel and Skeet Ulrich look much better than Damon (he Suck and still look like a kid).
FYI Brad Pitt is the top choice to play Thor already.

Kim on May 11, 2008

168

still cranking out the super hero movies? yawn.

galactus on May 11, 2008

169

has anyone suggested Cole Hauser yet? I watched tears of the sun the other day and he was pretty good in that, he's also not bad in pitch black. He's only 33 and i'm sure (like just about anyone) could bulk up if put on the right fitness regime.

Matoojo on May 12, 2008

170

Garrett Hedlund

txlamb on May 12, 2008

171

I got it Rosie O'Donnell wadda ya think?
C'mon Rosie as Cap'n America nobody would want to messd with us in fear of being devored in her evil storm of no use.

Xerxex on May 12, 2008

172

Haven't people already been nominating Eric Dane from Grey's Anatomy? Don't watch the show, but he seems to have the look and physique. He's fairly low profile which is what you want, but he also has mainstream awareness

MonkeysFirst on May 12, 2008

173

Oh my Gosh, Damon doesn't even fit the height requirement not to mention that his face is to square and young looking. Damon, on the other hand, is a perfect candidate to play the role of James Buchanan "Bucky" Barnes also known as "Winter Soldier". He will have enough time to prep for the "Invaders" as "Winter Soldier". You guys don't worry he'll get his chance to play a Marvel Hero.
Now for those of you who doesn't even know who "WINTER SOLDIER" is, PLEASE educate and familiarize yourselves with the Marvel Superheroes characters and their alter ego before recommending any actors who doesn't even come close to these Superheroes.
Make sure you have a single Marvel Comics and know a thing or two about any Marvel Characters their background and their alter ego.
PLEASE stop making silly suggestion and read some Marvel Comics and get to know the Marvel Heroes and their background first.

KoolGenes on May 12, 2008

174

I read Marvel Comics all the time, dude.

That's why I honestly think David Letterman should play the Red Skull.
Marvel's best move is not to take themsevles too seriously (i.e. Spidey's script for the first two movies; full of fanboy easter eggs, but chock full of jokes letting regular people KNOW they shouldn't take what they're seeing on the screen 'seriously'.

That's the trouble w/ making a Cap movie. There's nothing funny about Captain America.
There's also something really silly about trying to picture him in reality.

Let's face it, boys. Marvel's stuck.

There. Will. Be. No. Good. Captain America. Movie.

Djo Fortunado on May 12, 2008

175

Dennis Quaid.

If he was 10-15 years younger I'd love to see him take the role.

Then again, you never know with makeup artists and digital graphics these days.

Nick the Greek on May 12, 2008

176

Captain America could absolutely be a fantastic movie. There are so many different avenues and approaches they could take to ensure that it resonates with movie fans today. Remember you are making a movie for movie fans, not a movie for comic fans. You can completely change his orgin story to the current events of today. Instead of having him as the son of Irish immigrants, you can have him from say Texas. Or you can have him frozen as in the comic books and brought back to this time period and have him as a fish out of water in todays time exploring the new world. It is true isn't it, like it has been written, Captain America doesn't need to find America maybe America needs to find Captain America. Again, this could be a complete rewriting in orgin of Captain America that is more relavent in todays world. The one thing that I think Captain America could bring to the movie is a sense of charm, romance, chivalry and especially nobility that will endear him to movie and comic book fans alike. Don't be afraid of change and make a good movie based on principles of character and it could be something that people haven't seen in awhile which would make for a great movie.

I personally think that Matthew McC could bring a certain charm to the role and elevate it to new hieghts.

chester on May 12, 2008

177

Ugh Xerxex don't even joke like that, i threw up in my throat a little just thinking about that

K so who do they hardcore fans think should play CA? (asked in a serious non-sarcastic tone) And yeah I heard pitt was in the running to play Thor I just don't like a lot of the other suggestions. I'll admit I'm not a comic-reader but i know enough to get by…or so i thought:) And sadly i don't think you could get Damon to play a side-kick. And i can't picture Tom Welling with blonde hair.

silver on May 12, 2008

178

That and Botox.

Djo. on May 12, 2008

179

The key to making a good Cap Movie has little to do with casting Cap, in the end.

First you need to highlight the more Iconic aspects of the character, pinpoint what about his story mak