Toronto Review & Video: Joaquin Phoenix's Doc 'I'm Still Here'
by Alex Billington
September 9, 2010
What the hell did I just see? My second film of the Toronto Film Festival (first was The Town) that I just saw today was the Casey Affleck directed documentary I'm Still Here about Joaquin Phoenix's attempt to become a rapper. The film just hit limited theaters today and also showed in Venice, so there's some good buzz for it already. I will admit that I actually enjoyed this, it was entertaining and it was a fairly fascinating character study, but it's not perfect, and it's not anything more than just a bit of entertainment. And I'm still not even sure if it was all just an act or not, but that's one of the most interesting ideas. Was he just acting?
We all know the story - a few years ago, Oscar nominated actor Joaquin Phoenix decided to
announce claim that he was retiring from acting to pursue a career in hip hop. While we got to see some of his bizarre public appearances, like his rap-performance-gone-awry in Las Vegas and his funky David Letterman appearance, Phoenix and Affleck decide to show us a bit more of the behind-the-scenes of it all, including a taste of what is/was going on in Phoenix's crazy mind. However, it doesn't ever answer the question of why he decided to become a rapper nor does it really address the issue of this all being a hoax, but it does at least show enough to entertain those ideas (and that's about it) as it follows Phoenix's year long journey to become a rapper.
Here's what interests me the most about this doc. If we learn later that it was all an act and Phoenix did just create this wacky character and play it out for over a year, will we eventually look back at this as an amazing performance? The problem is that there is no greater message in I'm Still Here and it's not even anything to be considered "art" in a way that some really fantastic performances can be. But at the same time, I feel like if we learn that this was all a setup, I'll be even more amazed that he did all that he did. It's not anything to be proud of, but I never really thought I was watching him "act" at all (except for one scene with P. Diddy).
If you're intrigued by the wackiness of the whole situation and interested in seeing Joaquin Phoenix lose his mind, then I do suggest seeing this, especially because it's a unique character study that will definitely leave you either dumbfounded or questioning whether this was all a a big hoax or not (for better or maybe worse). To wrap things up, Peter from SlashFilm and Jordan from The Film Stage and I recorded a quick video blog while in the media lounge at TIFF with a quick discussion on the film, which you can check out below.
Reader Feedback - 14 Comments
So... How was "The Town?"
Graham on Sep 9, 2010
i was thinkin the same thing Graham, the same thing
HB on Sep 9, 2010
yeah how was "The Town?" I'm gonna check this out for sure.
Xerxex on Sep 9, 2010
I, for one, can't wait to see the town! My first thought as well, Graham.
Traveler on Sep 9, 2010
Best series of posts unrelated to the original topic ever. I hope someone at Magnolia reads this.
Mark on Sep 9, 2010
the guys on speaking are retards. he didn't live as a character for years, nobody does that. he put it on when the cameras were rolling and stopped when they shut off. i saw this movie and i was terrible. not funny, not deep, just a messy film with bad acting.
Beth on Sep 10, 2010
This film was horrific. Even the men in this video don't make it sound worth watching. Casey & joaquin failed at trying to be original and clever. They seriously wasted their time with this garbage. Can't wait for it to flop. I think this is one of my top 10 worst films of all time.
Kend788 on Sep 10, 2010
The question is will you pay watching this !!???
shero on Sep 10, 2010
The amount of hate this movie is receiving is surprising when there exists films such as Resident Evil: Afterlife and Saw 3D. I for one, am quite excited to see this.
Turner on Sep 10, 2010
It is not about Resident Evil: Afterlife and Saw 3D ...because always there will be a better movie in a different genre against such movies .... The problem is in why this movie ? why that poster ? why I have to pay to see Phoenix's bear ... screaming ... fighting .. in bed with another guy ?
shero on Sep 10, 2010
I am sorry, but this is stupid. This is fake and the more they play it like it was real frustrates me a lot. I am tired of Joaquin and his stupid beard.
David on Sep 10, 2010
I've said it before and I'll say it again...this guy does NOT deserve a character study. Maybe if it were in 3D I'd be interested.....
Voice of Reason on Sep 10, 2010
hoolihan on Sep 10, 2010
I AGREE WITH #11
RAY on Sep 10, 2010
Sorry, no commenting is allowed at this time.