Discuss: Did That First Look at 'Red Skull' Live Up To Expectations?

February 7, 2011

Red Skull

Meet Johann Schmidt. You may know him better as Red Skull. He has been unmasked! In Marvel's debut of footage in the form of a 30-second Super Bowl TV spot for Captain America: The First Avenger, a quick flash in the trailer revealed our first look at actor Hugo Weaving as the Third Reich's Red Skull. As this is a big reveal (in addition to seeing Chris Evans kickin' ass as Cap) I thought I'd snap a shot and open up the floor to discussion on his look. Red Skull first appeared in Captain America Comics #7 1941, created by Joe Simon and Jack Kirby. Does he look as good as you expected? Warning: spoilers may follow!

Marvel's Captain America: The First Avenger is directed by Joe Johnston, who previously directed Honey I Shrunk the Kids, The Rocketeer, Jumanji, October Sky, Jurassic Park III, Hidalgo and The Wolf Man. The screenplay was written by Christopher Markus & Stephen McFeely (writers of Life & Death of Peter Sellers, You Kill Me and all three Chronicles of Narnia movies, from Lion, Witch, Wardrobe to Dawn Treader) and also Joss Whedon. Paramount is bringing Captain America to theaters starting on July 22nd this summer.

Red Skull Photo from Captain America

Find more posts in Comics, Discuss, Hype, Opinions

Discover more around the web:

  • Rmelendez
  • Rmelendez
    looks like THE MASK, went Red
  • Kgsupes7
    I thought that it looked awesome. I just glad that they didnt do it CGI. That would have been as bad as Ghost Rider!
    • ..or the Green Lantern Suit
      • Capt. Americano
        lol yeh that GL suit looks like crap
  • Moon
    It looks over the top to me.
    • It's kind of supposed to be. The first 'true' Red Skull wore a mask of skull. I dunno how they could make it any better.
      • Anonymous
        im glad somebody realizes that its not an actual red skull, it was a mask. What theyve done for this movie, basically looks perfect. Im happier with what theyve shown of the red skull than of the stuff of cap himself, to be honest
      • Awtan90
        I'm confused. Why are you happy they switched the arrangement? He's supposed to be a man with a normal head wearing a red skull mask but this image clearly shows him as a guy with a red skull for a head and peeling off a mask that looks like a normal face.
        • As silly as this is going to sound, he could be wearing two masks. I wish I could cite an issue, but I'm certain I've seen it happen in the comics. It would help to know the context of the picture too. They've done it both ways (mask and scarred head) in the comic so I'm good with either.
    • Diggobick
      dude it looks perect
  • CLZ
    could be worse
  • Krankie
    I think it looks really good. Its going to be the best marvel movie so far!
  • Dave
    u no what i dont get about hollywood, why does EVERYONE constantly have to have glazing white teeth?! i mean this guy is the last person youd expect to be worrying about his teeth, he would deffs need to be brushing 3 times a day from childhood for that perfection, lets face it i think red skull has more on his mind. dunno why there to afraid to make a villian look a bit FUCKING villanious in hollywood, anyway, yeah looks alright, but the teeth thing is getting to me recently ...
    • ChrisC5g
      oh man that was spot on the best comment yet, honestly i think 2 Face's makeup job is way better but what do i know.
    • Hamster
      Red Skull always had bright teeth in the comics. The first incarnation of the Red Skull was an American business man and nazi. Can't be a business man with ugly ass teeth. @ Alex: Also.. I do believe the introduction of Red Skull was in Captain America Comics #1 not #7.
      • Dave
        possibly but i dont think the fact that hes a buissness man affected their decision to give him glazing white teeth, i think there just arseholes! lol
      • You're both right. Alex has the edge though, because the first appearance of Johann Schmidt (true Red Skull) was Cap #7. The one that appeared in #1 was an agent of Johann.
        • Yea... get your comic facts straight Hamster, hahah! ūüėõ
    • That is bothersome, but the camera doesn't always capture those finite details. But to your point: To capture it they would need to exaggerate it, which they should have. Red Skull is not concerned with vanity I'm sure.
    • Anonymous
      um, contrast? and (in my opinion) it makes him look more "skeletal" rather than rotten zombie esque... and did you not see Iron Man 2? Whiplash looked like he'd been in a Siberian prison for the past 20yrs... and they had a shortage on tooth paste.
      • Dave
        yeah, and it looked authentic, and he felt genuine? never looked like an actor from hollywood, thats my point, they shud be trying not to look like actors from hollywood, because you know they sort of are 'actors from hollywood' and there you know, sort of 'acting'?!?!?!
    • dangelp
      the joker in The Dark Knight did not have anything close to white teeth, just saying
      • Dave
        ok i mean.. in general... i never said every single film of all time?!
  • Craig
    Looks pretty good. I think they could have gone with less skin, but then again that would risk looking like Two-Face from TDK.
  • FOOM
    As already said, looks a lot like the Mask! As also already said, pearly white teeth do my tree in too! OK so I am a Brit and am used to less than perfect teeth..... but there is simply no way exposed teeth with no gums to cover them would look like a toothpaste ad! Then skin crawls when people in movies snog on meeting after being lost in the desert/outback/jungle for weeks with no tushy brush or Colgate....yuck!
  • Grichmer
    I'll be honest, it looked better than I expected it to. Can't wait to see the movie!
  • Risk
    Badass! Nergasm
  • Anonymous
    I think the important thing about the design, which appears to be a combination of latex and CG elements, is that while it looks like the character, it keeps a good similarity to the actor Hugo Weaving. I'm hoping this ensures that he keeps his expressions and mannerisms in line with the performance. Seems to be the case so far... This movie just keeps looking better and better!
    • Hamster
      Ya. Reminds me of what they did with Voldemort in Harry Potter. CG'd out the nose.. but all the expressions can still come through. HP wasn't as heavy on prosthetics tho.
  • Voice of Reason
    • voodoo2
      Ooh, somebody stop him!
  • Cornholen
    something about the teeth doesnt seem right
  • Splinter
    I like it a lot its simple they did not try to go to crazy with it and as for the comments of it looking like the mask..... THEY ARE BOTH DONE FROM A BASE OF THE HUMAN SKULL HOLY CRAP ABOUT 90% OF PEOPLE HAVE THE SAME SKULL SHAPE!!! DUHHHHHHH IT IS GOING TO CARRY THE SAME SHAPE !!!! most people like to talk about how crappy they do things in cinema honestly if you can do a better job prove it if not shut it. or if you know you can do it better start working your way in the industry to change it or make it better. Overall im looking forward to this movie, as well as thor, i trust Evans and Hemsworth will do it justice. Lastly im glad they went with prosthetics on this one im getting tired of CG CG CG although the thin version of Rogers looks really good lol
    • Anonymous
      I agree with you on the skull matter, lol you're so right; but I really read that remark about 'you do it if you're so cool' many times and believe me, it's not worth the trouble. I'm looking forward to Cap too :), not that sure about Thor though, but I know it's too early to judge them... ūüėČ
  • He looks awesome!!! However, I have a sneaking suspicion that this reveal won't happen until late in the film.
  • Anonymous
    Looks good. I would prefer it to look more like flesh/muscle but that would be too violent, this way is fine
  • I do like it but I think the eyes should have been bigger. As if he didn't have any eye lids. You know, as it is with a skull in all.
  • i think he looks awesome ūüėÄ
  • Guest12
    OMG its Skeletor from masters of the universe!
  • AGallagher410
    Could you get some more stills from the tv spot possibly?
  • Anonymous
    I love how people are complaining that it doesnt look grotesque enough. do you guys not realize that the actual red skull from the comics was just wearing a mask?
  • Anonymous
    I think it looks pretty badass.
  • Captain Guest
    Comic book movies do not follow comics 100%. Certain things have to be done differently because it is a movie and not a comic. It does matter if comic book Red Skull wore a mask or which guy was the first Red Skull. In the movie continuity, that is the Red Skull right there and he looks pretty damn good.
    • Snears
      I agree, I think it's dead on. If you aim to please everyone, you'll end up pleasing no one. This goes hand-in-hand with comic book movies. I think they are going to be some minor adjustments for the plot transcendence toward film to be exciting, surprising and thrilling. If you ask me, I think its dead on. Johnston seems to know what he's doing, and I'm pumped!
  • Buzzfunk
    I think everyone would agree that looking at how bad these comic book movies can go, it's all looking pretty darn good. It's never going to be perfect but you gotta give them credit for going with the dirty and gritty look.
  • grapefruit
    It looks great. It's a joy to see my favorite comic book characters come to life on the big screen.
  • Anonymous
    not bad at all :}
  • range
    the look of the redSkull must be improved, now it is plastic shiny, it should be more of wornout, degraded, chemical etched, not so shiny head. suddenly it looked like a popstar with redface (just for fun)
  • shadoworen117
    I think it would be cooler if his eyes were full, as if he didn't have eyelids.. kind of like that one enemy in Hellboy 1.
  • Its cooler then a guy with the words 'red skull' painted on his naked ass.
  • Insider
    This Red Skull looks cheap and plastic. It needs to look like real flesh. This is the age of CGI for crissakes. Dark Knight had Two-Face. And they want to go cheap and give us this cheap prosthetic plastic Halloween mask? I don't think so. I will not pay to see this. I will not take my family to see this.
  • It looks a little like Michael Jackson dipped in food dye but a little sexier.
  • Best thing about Cap so far!
  • !5AAK
    Looks great! Maybe add a litle darkness to the eyes but frickin awesome. I'm sure Hugo will kick @$$.
  • Ebay Busybee
    I know next to nothing about this film, but if this character is Hugo Weaving it will kick ass.
  • HDCandela
    I am in shock as to the content of the comments.  How easily lead you all are.  Is this the best that your generation has to offer?  The red skull mask was the best that it could be, convincing.  However, even more important, the Red Skull and his purposefully applied philosophy was perfect in it portrayal.  Tyrants start out having to convince others to follow, and seem quite reasonable at first.  They make all the right "friends" at first.  It is very easy to choose their leadership, or to choose the wrong person for the right or wrong reasons.  Then, over a period of events, steps, and actions they rot the entire buschel of apples.  By the time their followers might swallow their pride to say they made a mistake, everyone is kept in line through fear, anger, fanaticism, money, or their own place in the pyramid power structure.  My grandpa, flawed to a lesser degree than I am in a different things, said, "The Germans in WWII, they knew better."  It was a sociological, cultural, and religous statement for him.  He was Pennsylvania Duetch.  He was a Captain in the Army.  The logical transition of German National Socialists into the followers of the "Red" skull who is very international socialist fits.  The name "Hydra" fits.  In many ways it represents any goverment that goes that route.  Even the elietism moments leading up to telling the doctor not to scratch his car fit.  The Red Skull is Obama and/or Polosi, Reed, Soros, Wen Jiabao, Putin, the CEO of B&S, the CEO of MS, Fanny & Freddy (building large numbers slave constituancies), etc.  It is not just the war in Lybia, Egypt, Jordan, Bahrain, etc. but all of those places where the Obama has decided to switch sides and support Al Qaeda.  It is also in America where Obama is trying to bankrupt our country while building huge federal frame work run by "CZARS" who were former terrorists.  They bombed Americans, robbed banks, did not pay taxes, worked with the mafia, and forced a political curricullum on schools that brainwashes kids rather than teaches them to think crittically.  I have an idea.  Let's go back a little further.  Maybe we should ask Vince Foster, the US servicemen who supposedly killed themselves rather than invade Hati, the Greeks on Cyprus, Christian Kosavars, people who died when FEMA supposedly helped New Orleans by trying to shut down rebuilding efforts requiring detention in the stadium, etc. if The Red Skull mask was convincing.  Look at Obama and Polosi, they do have The Red Skull thing.  The movie was an excellent example  showing what it means to be truly American and truly unAmerican.  How few of you can tell the difference, because you do not know the difference.  Now, go back to your discussion of superfluous aesthetics if you want.   -HDcandela       




Alex's Top 10 - 2016
1. La La Land
2. Paterson
3. Arrival
4. Captain Fantastic
5. 20th Cent. Women
6. Pete's Dragon
7. Jackie
8. Kubo & Two Strings
9. Everybody Wants
10. Wilderpeople
Click Here for Thoughts

Jeremy's Top 10 - 2016
1. Moonlight
2. The Handmaiden
3. High-Rise
4. Elle
5. Arrival
6. Kubo & Two Strings
7. 13th
8. Jackie
9. Toni Erdmann
10. The Witch
Click Here for Thoughts


Subscribe to our feed or daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main profile on twitter:
For the news posts only, follow this acct:
Add our feed to your Feedly: follow us in feedly