New 'Straw Dogs' Poster Remembers How Reflections Actually Work
Last month, we got a look at the first poster for Straw Dogs, the remake of the 1971 film from director Rod Lurie. Considering the fact that the original poster has been regarded as one of the best of its time, apparently those who crafted the new poster just didn't think they could do any better and merely recreated the poster, but with James Marsden's glasses broken and Alexander Skarsgaard being reflected in them. But you can't have a reflection without glass, and while I would've preferred the whole poster be redesigned, a new version, with better real-life representation of reflections and glass has surfaced.
Seems weird that they removed the color from inside the lens of the glasses, but whatever:
And just to refresh your memory, here's the original first poster with the reflection on no glass:
L.A. screenwriter David Sumner (Marsden) relocates with his wife to her hometown in the deep South. While tensions build between them, a brewing conflict with the locals becomes a big threat to them both.
Straw Dogs is both written and directed by Israeli filmmaker Rod Lurie, of The Contender, The Last Castle, The Nazi, Resurrecting the Champ and Nothing But the Truth. This is a remake of David Zelag Goodman & Sam Peckinpah's 1971 film, based on Gordon Williams' novel "The Siege of Trencher's Farm". Screen Gems is finally bringing Straw Dogs to theaters starting on September 16th this fall. Anyone interested in this?
Reader Feedback - 12 Comments
"But you can't have a reflection in broken glass" -really, hmm? Think I'm gunna go break a pair of old glasses and take a look 🙂 I am pretty sure you can't have 1 reflection like in the poster above, but multiple 🙂
David Banner on Jul 9, 2011
They made Skarsgard's face in the place where the glass had fallen, ie, reflected in his eye socket. I see why they changed it... 😛
Traveler on Jul 9, 2011
Yes, that was pretty lame! I agree that the reflection looks fake, but I don't see why it would be "impossible to have a reflection in a broken glass". Actually, if you look closely at the original, you can kinda see a face reflection as well, but it's really more subtle. Unless I'm imaginating this...
Moutchy on Jul 9, 2011
Either way it's crap.
Adamreeo on Jul 9, 2011
That is still not how reflections work.
MegaMan3k on Jul 9, 2011
It's just a film poster. It doesn't have to be real, it represents a visualisation of a fictional creation. Yip yip.
Crapola on Jul 9, 2011
Hi Ethan, Just thought you might find this interesting. It's the latest concept poster for my upcoming film project which is a dark superhero story titled 'Body Count' and I posted the image on my facebook page back on June 4th, 2011. This is how a reflection in broken glass should look. You can checkout the poster on my facebook page.
Desi Singh on Jul 9, 2011
This actually looks cooler. This reflection looks more realistic. Great job!
Shadowman on Jul 10, 2011
But did they reverse the image of the actor's face in the glasses too?
woodge on Jul 9, 2011
Ah, I see what you did there Alex 🙂
David Banner on Jul 10, 2011
I just want to remind you of this little gem... I actually liked the Tyler Perry poster better than the first straw dogs poster. Thank god they redid it - I like the new one better than the tyler perry one. There's no way a tyler perry poster should be better than a straw dogs poster, remake or not.
Jack Minor on Aug 3, 2011
Sorry, no commenting is allowed at this time.