Joaquin Phoenix in Early 'Batman vs. Superman' Talks as Lex Luthor?

December 18, 2013
Source: Variety

Joaquin Phoenix

We already know that Jason Momoa is in the running for some sort of villain/hero role in the gestating comic book sequel Batman vs. Superman, the follow-up to this year's Man of Steel from director Zack Snyder, but now we have word on a potential talent being lined up for the film's primary villain. Variety has word that Warner Bros. wants to get their Her leading man Joaquin Phoenix for a role in the film, but it's still very early in the process, so it's far from a done deal. The actor has strayed away from blockbusters and is currently considering a role in Sea of Trees, the next film from Good Will Hunting director Gus Van Sant.

The question is, who is this primary villain? The smart money is on Lex Luthor, and it's not hard to envision Phoenix knocking that role out of the park after playing the dastardly emperor in Gladiator, undoubtedly the biggest film he's ever done. It would certainly add some weight and gravitas to the comic book film that seems to be on rocky waters with a crowded cast that will include Ben Affleck as Batman and Gal Gadot as Wonder Woman, with some other roles (like The Flash) left to be filled. Remember that Callan Mulvey (300: Rise of the Empire) is still being lined up for a villain role, but apparently that's not the primary antagonist. We hope that Phoenix will decide to enter the blockbuster world and really turn some heads.

UPDATE: THR reports Warner Bros. is bringing in Chris Terrio, screenwriter of Argo, to do a rewrite on Batman vs. Superman. So we have an Academy Award winning writer working on this movie. Cool?

Find more posts in Casting, DC Movies, Movie News

Discover more around the web:

  • Al Apone
    Luthor makes sense, but I would love to see him playing the Joker.
    • Such heroic nonsense
      Dont think Joker is for him. And also The Joker wont be coming back anytime soon.
      • Al Apone
        Joker probably wouldnt be a right fit into this movie tbf, but should be in the next Affleck-Batman movie. No reason to keep Joker out, now that we are starting with a new Baman Universe.
        • Charlie Hard
          I would like for them to introduce villains that haven't been seen in any of the Batman films from the comics before getting to The Joker. Maybe even the Riddler or Mr.Freeze. Then have the The Joker be the one behind the scenes for the first few movies and save him as the main villain for the final film.
        • Such heroic nonsense
          Not saying to keep him out, but we need to give all his other villains a chance to appear, and also, besides this movie being about how batman and superman coexist, its also about the introduction of other justice league heroes.
      • OfficialJab
        They could just get Day-Lewis to play Ledger playing the Joker again.
        • Sherlon
          WORD! Can you imagine if two different actors get Oscars for playing the same character?! Only Day-Lewis could knock the Joker role outta da park at the moment
        • Such heroic nonsense
          That would be epic if Day Lewis was 30 years younger. Hes too old to do that now.
  • Such heroic nonsense
    Not sure how i feel about this. If we get the "Gladiator days" Joaquin Phoenix when he performed magnificently, then perhaps we could have a good Lex. If we get the "I've-gone-Bat-Shit-and-i-think-I'm-a-rapper", Joaquin Phoenix then this movie is proper-fucked as Tommy says in Snatch.
    • Phillip Gockel
      You do realize that the rapper shtick was all a fake for the film they were making, right? Whether it was good or not is beside the point, Joaquin never went "Bat-Shit" nor did he think he was a rapper.
      • Such heroic nonsense
        Either way, the guy still went bat shit and left acting for awhile cause he was in some sort of life turmoil and was possibly heading in the wrong direction. Surely you havent forgotten about the famous interview with David Letterman where the guy was obviously on something.
        • RectumRaider
          that interview was part of the publicity stunt for the movie you diddley darn ignoramus. Ben affleck is going to look like rob schneider if Joaquin is lex luthor.
          • dbucks
            If anything, Phoenix and his friends' stunt was more like a Charlie Kaufman performance. The movie was a part of the performance. Too bad it flopped b/c it could have been really funny.
          • Such heroic nonsense
            HA! Pfffft now who is the diddley darn ignoramus believing what the media and the interview claiming it was all for a mockumentary at face value?! You know the guy checked into rehab at a time for alcoholism. ARGH nevermind, whats the point in arguing with a simple-minded robot. Anyway, stick to your day job raiding rectums and dont comment on anything, ever!
    • IamSlave
      His roles in The Master and Her seem to suggest that the "Gladiator days" Phoenix never left.
  • Charlie Hard
    I doubt Joaquin Phoenix would take the role for Luthor but nothing seems impossible now knowing Ben Affleck surprisingly took the Batman lead with that mind. It would definitely be an inspired choice. Other than that not sure who else they would pick if he turns it down. Bryan Cranston? Brad Pitt? Tom Hanks? Woody Harrelson? Nicolas Cage? Bennedict Cumberbatch? John Goodman? or even the possibility of Christian Bale. Well granted Bale just came off playing Batman but he would need to be bald for the role. Just throwing in other possibilities....
    • Such heroic nonsense
      Jesus, how did you come up with such a horrible list? I only agree with Cranston.
    • Sherlon
      I keep saying...Benedict Cumberbatch is the ideal lex luthor. Joaquin Phoenix can make a good Vandall Savage IMO
  • mgazo
    i can get w/ this choice. i have stated i thought justin timberlake would make a good lex. i really dont want old lex. i want a young and established w/ tons of charisma lex. joaquin phoenix would be a lateral choice for me. in addition i had not seen runner runner when i made my previous statement. not so sure about affleck and timberlakes onscreen dynamic lending itself to the man of steel part 2.
    Yes. Bring the pain! This would be such a great fit. Phoenix's presence is palpable.
  • Snowmanfloza
    Joaquin would be my dream Lex Luthor
  • Xerxexx
    I like it.
    • I love it.
      • I want some more of it.
        • Xerxexx
          I try so hard, I can't rise above it.
  • Well He's got the nut-ball part down!
  • mooreworthy
    The man in the bat suit didn't put butts in the theater, it was the villians. Same for this movie.
  • Nathan D
    I don't know what the plans are with this movie, but I'd like to just see Batman and Superman fighting it out, with no added superheros or villains or cameos, and keeping the 'next year on DC Universe' teases to a minimum. Just Batman vs. Superman. There's a lot to explore as it is.
  • DavideCoppola
    I like the update. The script is what it's all about. If you have a bad script you can have the best actors and the most stylish director, but your movie will still suck.
  • Morvidus
    Chiwetel Ejiofor is still my first choice...
  • Ehsan Davodi
    Precise Choice
  • thejon93rd
    This sounds like great casting to me. Benedict Cumberbatch as Mr. Freeze, that would be awesome, let's redeem that character. Shall we begin?
  • borninatrailer
    Well, why don't we just have Andy Dick play Soloman Grundy while we're at it? Jesus.
  • cobrazombie
    Lex Luthor again? Zzzzzz




Alex's Top 10 - 2016
1. La La Land
2. Paterson
3. Arrival
4. Captain Fantastic
5. 20th Cent. Women
6. Pete's Dragon
7. Jackie
8. Kubo & Two Strings
9. Everybody Wants
10. Wilderpeople
Click Here for Thoughts

Jeremy's Top 10 - 2016
1. Moonlight
2. The Handmaiden
3. High-Rise
4. Elle
5. Arrival
6. Kubo & Two Strings
7. 13th
8. Jackie
9. Toni Erdmann
10. The Witch
Click Here for Thoughts


Subscribe to our feed or daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main profile on twitter:
For the news posts only, follow this acct:
Add our feed to your Feedly: follow us in feedly