Positive/Negative: Divisive Reactions to Refn's 'Only God Forgives'

May 24, 2013

Only God Forgives

This past Wednesday morning at 8:30AM, Nicolas Winding Refn's ninth feature film, Only God Forgives, premiered inside the Grand Lumiere at the Cannes Film Festival to a crowd of critics and press from all over the world. The response 90 minutes later was instantly divisive, with reactions ranging from incredibly negative and "hated it" to overly positive and "loved it". While the majority of responses I saw seemed to lean towards the negative side, there's always something fun about emerging from a film that gets such split response. As long as there are people who did love it (like me!), there's something curious there to discuss.

Only God Forgives stars Ryan Gosling as an American living in Bangkok, Thailand who ends up in a brutally violent feud with Chang, a badass retired police officer who commands more respect than anyone in the entire country. While I've already written my own positive review and hundreds of other reviews have been published from Cannes, I wanted to collect a sample of both the positive and negative responses from twitter. There are plenty of reviews to read, but there's also something amusing and intriguing about seeing such polar opposite reactions, such vitriol and love, for the same film. Great films start discussions.

Up first, here are most of the positive reactions that were posted after the film premiered earlier this week:

Only God Forgives

As for the negative reactions, as many have no doubt heard, the film did get booed at Cannes (which isn't uncommon for films that critics dislike). However, I was there myself at the very first press screening. When it ended there was at first a pause of confusion in the audience, then some applause began and continued while the booing started up as well. It was a fair mix but the negative reactions have been strong online:

It's interesting to look back at the split in responses. While there are some elements of Only God Forgives that everyone seems to agree on (cinematography and score are great), its emptiness seems to be the big problem that many are lingering on. It's also not Drive, in any way, and can barely be compared to Drive beyond Ryan Gosling being in it and Refn's moody, atmospheric style. However, simply the fact this film is creating such divisive discussions and such strong opinions is actually good thing, it means it is having an effect, even if it's a bad one. Even if it's one that begins negative but becomes interesting with extra thought.

As we all know, everyone will eventually have the chance to see Only God Forgives and form their own opinion. It may be embraced much more by fans and regular moviegoers than critics in the end. I was at the world premiere of Drive in Cannes back in 2011 and that received more universal praise, but again, these are such different films but I'm intrigued to see how it plays outside of France. Only God Forgives (watch the trailer) is written & directed by Nicolas Winding Refn (of the Pusher Trilogy, Fear X, Bronson, Valhalla Rising, Drive). It will be released in theaters on July 19th this summer. See for yourself if it's good or bad.

Find more posts in Cannes 13, Discuss, Feat, Hype

Discover more around the web:

  • Nielsen700
    Damn, some people didn't like a movie and some other people did? Crazy stuff...
    Refn's work is polarizing if nothing else. I am so psyched to see this. If it's like VALHALLA RISING, then I will sure love it.
  • Xerxexx
    Films are supposed to be polarizing. Look at Ironman 3. I fucking loved it while a lot of people hated it.
    • conradthegreat
      I'm one of the people who totally hated Iron Man 3.
      • Wafffles
        Duly noted.
      • Xerxexx
        Hello. I loved it and look...we can be civilized...*loads shotgun*
  • racquetman
    Many people, including some critics, are predisposed to dislike movies like this. Refn isn't making films for the sheep and I thank the gods for it.
    • mistermysteryguest
      A bad film is a bad film.
      • racquetman
        I wasn't aware that there was a consensus that this was a bad film. Did you read the article?
  • I feel like I'm taking crazy pills with this guy, but I hated Drive, Valhalla Rising, and Bronson so I probably won't even watch this. I've given him an ample amount of chances, but he's definitely not for me. Glad some people like him, but I don't know why. His stories go no where, he can't develop characters, and he adds gratuitous violence in places that don't fit with the rest of the narrative. People compare him to Tarantino, but at least Tarantino is a good writer and knows how to form solid dialogue in addition to his over the top fight scenes.
      Yeah, he's a Van Gough in a Kinkade world.
    • racquetman
      I would say that Tarantino is too much talky and Refn is too little talky. Malick seems to think people don't have tongues, period.
      • Mufasa
    • mistermysteryguest
      I definitely hated Drive.
  • jah p
    I'm hearing the best parts of this movie are the performances of K Scott Thomas and the Thailand crooked cop character, rest of the film is a violent mess from what I've been told..
  • Bob
    OGF is a really strange, slow, mental movie. It's really not like Drive. It's a mix between Gaspar Noé's, David Lynch's and Refn's (duh!) movies. This film is like Enter the Void in a way, it is an experience. I'm glad movie like that are created. I understand why people hate it (slow, hyper violent, cryptic, no "story"). But i wanna watch different things at the movie, i wanna be surprise and shocked. And this movie does the job well.
  • lewinston
    Hold up... look at the pictures of the people who loved it vs. the pictures of people who hated it... artsy divide?
  • Y8
    nly god forgive is an useful film with high rate from the audiences
  • look at the pictures of the people who loved it vs. the pictures of people who hated a movie and some other people did? Crazy stuff...
  • lol




Alex's Top 10 - 2016
1. La La Land
2. Paterson
3. Arrival
4. Captain Fantastic
5. 20th Cent. Women
6. Pete's Dragon
7. Jackie
8. Kubo & Two Strings
9. Everybody Wants
10. Wilderpeople
Click Here for Thoughts

Jeremy's Top 10 - 2016
1. Moonlight
2. The Handmaiden
3. High-Rise
4. Elle
5. Arrival
6. Kubo & Two Strings
7. 13th
8. Jackie
9. Toni Erdmann
10. The Witch
Click Here for Thoughts


Subscribe to our feed or daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main profile on twitter:
For the news posts only, follow this acct:
Add our feed to your Feedly: follow us in feedly