Kenneth Branagh Finally Talks About Directing Marvel's Thor
I'm going to make a confession. Back when the news first hit that Kenneth Branagh was going to direct Marvel's Thor, I pessimistically wrote that "Branagh seems like the worst choice to direct a comic book movie since Joel Schumacher." Now that I've seen Valkyrie, however, my opinion has changed. Watching Branagh act in that film has made me change my opinion about him. Maybe it was just the lingering sour taste of Sleuth that made me so opposed to Branagh, but for whatever reason, watching him in Valkyrie made me slightly more confident. Since the news first broke in September, Branagh has been keeping quiet about the project, but MTV finally got him to break down and talk about directing "The Mighty Thor."
No, the title hasn't changed, as Branagh clarifies, "I think it will be Thor." So why did he want to direct a high profile comic book movie? "To work on a story about one of the immortals, Gods, extraordinary beings, inter-dimensional creatures," he told MTV. "There's science fiction and science fact and fantasy all woven into one. It's based on Norse legends which Marvel sort of raided in a brilliant way." And for those, like me, who are skeptical about the scale of the project and Branagh being able to handle it, he emphasizes that, "it's a chance to tell a big story on a big scale. It's a human story right in the center of a big epic scenario." Sounds like he at least understands the monumental task that he is taking on.
As for who will play Norse God of Thunder, aka Thor, Branagh wouldn't even hint as to who it might be, but he did give us this tease: "There's been lots of talk [about casting]… but we are too early at this stage. We're getting the story and the visual effects together and all of that is very exciting. Someone sensational is going to play the part but it is early days." Either he's really good at keeping things under wraps or they really haven't chosen anyone yet. Considering Marvel has Thor set to hit theaters on July 16th, 2010, Branagh better get to work quickly on finalizing these sort of details, as they're probably planning to shoot early next year. And I'm sure I'm not the only one who wants to see another great Marvel movie!
They better choose someone good for the lead. Not just some big name douche.
-Peter- on Dec 13, 2008
How did his acting performance give you more hope for him as a director?
Ben on Dec 13, 2008
Have you ever seen his version of Hamlet? It's a huge, sweeping epic with visuals that surpass most films I've ever seen. Branagh gives one of the best performences in screen history in that movie, and as far as I'm concerned, if you can do an epic Shakespeare film, then you can do an epic comic book film. I mean, did Chrsitopher Nolan ever do anything that big before taking on Batman? No, but we all know that Nolan turned out to be the right man for the job---and I'd argue that Branagh's Hamlet is bigger than anything Nolan did before Batman. Obviously, we'll have to wait and see whether Branagh was the right choice, but he is a brilliant actor and director. However, I would not base my opinions on him as a director based on him as an actor--it just turns out that he has directed some great films, like Hamlet (and Henry V).
DinoChow on Dec 13, 2008
he little do you know he has casted himself as thor, he's bulking up for the movie hahaha
ralph on Dec 13, 2008
I have the utmost faith in Branagh--he sure does understand the huge task he signed on for. "Sleuth" was what it was, namely a flick based on a two character play---or something to that effect. I think that "Thor" will be just as great as "Iron Man". This reminds me of the shaky confidence that Jon Favreau provoked in us when he was first announced as IM's director. I'm sure Branagh, Raimi, as well as Favreau will bring their a game directorial chops to their respective projects after "The Dark Knight" raised the bar! It will be alright. "Thor" is in good hands.
Spider on Dec 13, 2008
it doesn't matter, we all know the avenger film will hit big but the movie will suck, so as iron man 2, and the incredible hulk 2. And don't forget thor as well as captain america.
darrin on Dec 13, 2008
I love how you Judge Branaghs directing abilities off one movie he acted in. Then You saw Valkyrie which sucked and you change you mind. Have you even seen any of the the other movies that he has starred in or directed? Can you name 5 without looking his name up on IMDB? I would put money on that you couldn't. "And I'm sure I'm not the only one who wants to see another great Marvel movie!" From what I have seen on your site and the types of movies you like, I don't think you know what a great movie is.
Vinnie on Dec 13, 2008
I have a question for you Alex, why are you basing Branagh's directing capabilities on Sleuth and not his other works (which I for one think are brilliant)? That's like saying that Spielberg can't make Indiana Jones because he made the Terminal.
BahHumbug on Dec 13, 2008
i think alex just pwned vinnie. =)
finch on Dec 14, 2008
#10 you managed to make it down to the opinion difference. That is not what #8 was really saying. You judged Branagh entirely after your viewing of Valkyrie. Branagh has made so much more and better movies in the past that you judging him solely because of his latest work is completely ridiculous. Besides #8 makes a good point. This site is too obsessive with comic book flicks. Nothing can even touch your Iron Man or Batman worship.
Shige on Dec 14, 2008
One nil to Alex. A commanding and strong response.
Smiffy1 on Dec 14, 2008
I still dont see this working...Thor is just tooooo damned corny.... Ironman has the world of high tech...stuff that, if not here now is just around the corner...immortals, gods?? how absurd...sounds like straight-to-dvd....
moldybread on Dec 14, 2008
I think he'll give it a poetic take The guy's a Shakespearean buff, from Hamlet to King Lear & Othello Question is, can Thor be seen as a tragedy?
Jaf on Dec 14, 2008
Well he's probably going to take it down the Greek tragedy route more so than apply his love for Shakespeare in terms of his knowledge in the theatrical arts. I have a feeling this is ONE comic to film adaptation that the Marvel guys will be VERY open to allowing a reinterpretation of his origin along with any major changes necessary--in order to excise all the corniness.
George on Dec 14, 2008
As someone who LOVES Branagh's Shakespeare movies, and who shares a birthday with him, I'm rooting for him and think he will do a wonderful job. I think that he will bring the reverence to the Norse legends and root of the heroic journey of Thor that he brought to the Bard's work. It seems that his focus is on accuracy, emotion, and juxtaposition of great characters. Which I really think Thor will need to make it into the mainstream like Batman, Iron Man, Superman, etc. I've always viewed Thor and his visibility in mainstream US on a level with Daredevil. aka: not much 🙂 I also think it's a bit off to judge his *directing* ability based on his *acting* work.
William Mize on Dec 14, 2008
sorry alex. i understand what you are saying but, don't get why KB bugs you so much as to single him out like that. you need to give the guy a chance first. by the way, while were on the topic, KB was brilliant in "shackleton", "peters friends", "hamlet" and "conspiracy". 4 very different roles but outstanding in both. i don't see why he can't do the same with different styles of movies in the directorial chair.
dan on Dec 14, 2008
#18 - Those Shakesperian films ARE why Thor will make a great film, because those films are epic. Because of the care taken to the seriousness of the story and the dedication to getting everything just right. It's because he's a director of immutable force. No matter how hokey or pretentious those films seem, they are guided by the hand of a director who knows exactly what he wants. Seriously. You don't want some action director for this; you want someone who's gonna make Thor REAL.
Fuelbot on Dec 14, 2008
In Branagh's defense, Sleuth wasn't so much a directorial catastrophe as it was a script blunder. All the elements of the movie were well-crafted except the most important part: the writing. That said, why Branagh would have thought Pinter's abysmal script 'good' is unclear.
Rabican on Dec 14, 2008
Im more concerned that this is backed by MTV. Bleh.
Jimd on Dec 14, 2008
How on Earth is a great performance any indication of a directors talent? Quentin Tarantino is far from a talented actor but he's one of the greatest directors of our time. Being on either ends of the camera is vastly different. It takes a lot to do either profession well, and it takes very different skill sets. Branagh's a fine actor, no doubt... but that doesn't mean a whole lot. I think anyway you slice it Thor directed by anyone is going to be a bad movie and a box office flop. He's not relevant enough. Ironman was a hit because of it's ties to the modern world and it's funny, suave lead... Thor is about centuries too irrelevant to make a smash.
adrian on Dec 14, 2008
i said that would happen when you broke the news alex!!!
fanboy d on Dec 14, 2008
I think that Branagh is such a weird choice for a director it can either b glorious or mediocre! No deeper analisis needed, we'll just wait and see. Me personaly, well i think it's gonna rock!!! F*CK YEAH!! :))
sng. Sheep on Dec 14, 2008
Andy, who says anything about Shakespeare? I'm talking about his skills as a director which are evident from his previous films. Alex is basing his opinion off of Sleuth.
BahHumbug on Dec 14, 2008
First, you guys have gotta see Dead Again, a Branagh film from long ago. It's not Shakespeare, but a damn fine drama which takes place in two separate eras. Second, even if a director doesn't use a lot of CGI they can certainly tap into the knowledge of others around them and get what they need. Remember, it is the tale, not he whom tells it. Finally, I gotta hand it to some of you: when is someone ever judged by only one film when they have a slew of credits to their name, both as an actor and director?
Fritz Blaze on Dec 15, 2008
If the Avengers movie is about Loki using the Hulk I think it could all be very cool. It'd be fun to see the uber-realistic Iron Man and Cap juxtaposed against the more fantastical elements like Thor. Kinda like Reign if Fire in that regard. It'll be cool.
ballyhoo on Dec 15, 2008
Reign OF Fire. sorry
ballyhoo on Dec 15, 2008
Kenny is the perfect choice.
D-9 on Dec 15, 2008
New comments are no longer allowed on this post.