Marco's Official Top 10 Film Experiences of 2008

December 31, 2008

Marco's Official Top 10 Film Experiences of 2008

Another year at the movies and another list of top ten films. I personally believe the rumors about 2008 are all true -- it has been a bad year for movies. How else can you explain so many mediocre titles ending up on all the top ten lists everywhere? My personal list is just as disjointed. I only gave four stars to my top pick and three-and-a-half to the three other titles below it. The rest of my top ten list is made up of three star movies that moved me in one way or another. That's pretty sad considering I usually have an abundance of four stars movies to choose from. Let's just get right down to it, starting with my honorable mentions.

Honorable Mentions

(In alphabetical order) Baghead, Ballast, Bigger, Stronger, Faster, CJ7, Changeling, Dear Zachary, Funny Games, The Incredible Hulk, Iron Man, Religulous, Sangre De Mi Sangre, Shotgun Stories, Slumdog Millionaire, Towelhead, Tropic Thunder, The Visitor.

Speed Racer

#10 - Speed Racer

Completely misunderstood when first released, Speed Racer was the biggest eye orgasm of 2008. The colors and its production design popped off the screen and for all their hard work, the Wachowski Brothers got decimated by critics everywhere. If you have a Blu-Ray player, the best way to experience this gooey cinematic experience is in HD. But don't blaze up before watching it, you might have a seizure.

The Bank Job

#9 - The Bank Job

Jason Statham (rightfully) gets a lot of shit for making quick money grabs like Death Race and In the Name of the King, but The Bank Job proved that not only can he carry a film but he can make a great one too. Shot like a '70s film by director Roger Donaldson, this intricate crime caper of stolen money and blackmailed royalty got shafted by audiences when it was first released. Do yourself a favor and seek it out on DVD.


#8 - Redbelt

I've always loved David Mamet and consider him to be one of those unique directors where his worst movies are more entertaining than the best efforts of a studio hack. Redbelt is not his strongest effort, but in a year where most films failed to stand out in any significant way, a good Mamet film is easy to recommend as one of 2008's highlights. Chiwetel Ejiofor stars as a martial arts instructor caught in a surreal web of lies, blackmail, and razor sharp dialogue. Joe Mantegna, Rebecca Pidgeon and Ricky Jay are all Mamet regulars, so they know exactly what they're doing. One of the biggest surprises was seeing Tim Allen convincingly act. His small role as a big shot movie star almost made me forget The Santa Clause ever existed.


#7 - Frost/Nixon

Ron Howard is a B-level director with A-level status. A Beautiful Mind, Cinderella Man and The Da Vinci Code are expendable studio movies that have done nothing to challenge him as a filmmaker. And before you say Apollo 13, let me remind you that was 13 years ago (funny how the math works out). I consider The Missing his best film but it's also his least successful. Frost/Nixon is a return to form for Howard, a way to challenge himself the way he did with The Missing. The verbal grudge match between Richard Nixon and journalist David Frost is nothing short of riveting. The obvious standouts are Michael Sheen and Frank Langella as Frost and Nixon but the film is also carried by great supporting work, primarily Kevin Bacon and Sam Rockwell. Here's hoping Ron Howard stops chasing dollar bills and keeps focusing on good movies.

Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired

#6 - Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired

Most of my feelings on Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired can be read in my full review, but the short version is this: you owe it to yourself to see this film. If you're a regular on this site you're a film geek just like me. This gripping documentary is an examination of one of the biggest and most talented filmmakers of the last several years. Granted his life story is a backdrop to the larger look at his alleged rape of a minor, but the court proceedings and audience confliction make this a must see. The "Wanted and Desired" of the title refers to the fact that despite his alleged criminal past, Polanski fled to France to avoid charges and is looked upon as an ordinary citizen (desired) wherein the US he is still a "wanted" fugitive.

The Dark Knight

#5 - The Dark Knight

There is a feeling going around this month that if you are a professional critic and don't include The Dark Knight on your top ten list, something was very wrong with you. I call bullshit on this fanboy bullying but still believe TDK to be a great film on my own volition. Yes, there are problems with the film in terms of logic and suspension of disbelief, but as a piece of entertainment the craftsmanship cannot be ignored.

The Fall

#4 - The Fall

Visual director Tarsem redeemed himself in a big way this year with The Fall, a whimsical fairytale of a precocious young girl and the suicidal stuntman feeding her imagination. The film was shot over the course of several years while the perfectionist director achieved the exact look he wanted, making the finished product well worth the wait. Fans of Pushing Daisies will recognize actor Lee Pace as the depressed stuntman weaving quixotic stories to his young audience.


#3 - Wall-E

Yes boys and girls, there was a better, geekier film than The Dark Knight this year. The more I see Wall-E, the more I fall in love with it. I agree the first half is stronger than the second, but that doesn't bring the film down in any significant way for me. As an aside, is it just me or is Eve a bitch? In the first half especially, all Wall-E wants to do is impress Eve and she acts like a spoiled bitch in need of a good slap. Case in point, there's a sandstorm coming early in the film and Wall-E wants to protect Eve by bringing her into his lair so she won't get hurt. The moment he touches her she pulls a gun on him. WTF?!? I know I'm just rambling but I couldn't resist. Pixar is officially making adult films that kids can see too.

In Bruges

#2 - In Bruges

Writer/director Martin McDonagh's film is finally starting to get the attention it deserves. In Bruges is an action film written like a play and it makes perfect sense since McDonagh is best known as an acclaimed playwright. Colin Farrell and Brendan Glesson put in the best work of their careers as hitmen hiding out in Bruges, Brussels until the heat from their last job blows over. Mayhem, prostitutes, smoking and midgets are mixed for comedic flavor making In Bruges the most fun of 2008.


#1 - Elegy

I seem to be alone in praising this so highly, but I don't care. While other films were considered safe bets for the top slot, my heart kept going back to this one, which I guess makes sense since it's a love story after all. Ben Kingsley commands the screen as a commitment-phobic college professor who falls in love with one of his students (Penelope Cruz). All the messiness of love and relationships is put under a microscope in director Isabel Coixet's story of insecurity and melancholy. I only fell in love with one film this year -- Elegy made me giddy to be a film geek and also made be believe Ben Kingsley could still make real movies.

Find more posts: Awards, Discuss, Editorial, Opinions



Pretty good list since it's labeled top 10 film 'experiences'. I'm glad you put In Bruges so high on your list. That film was just great to watch and is in my personal top 5. It sucks more people didn't see that movie. I'll bring it while talking to my friends but none of them have seen it. Maybe it's because for some reason i cant seem to find a blu-ray dvd of the film.

Steven on Dec 31, 2008


Most of this list is fairly stellar but what is the fascination with Redbelt? That movie is a steaming pile of cliche bullshit!! Although, Chiwetel Ejiofor's performance is fairly flawless (as usual) the rest of the film,characters, cinematography, and story are just lame at best. Mamet is not nearly as good as everyone likes to think. It seems to me that everyone is afraid to say something bad about him for fear of being ridiculed by all their hipster friends or random art critics. Oh no, Roger Ebert won't think I'm smart! Whatever will I do?

Chilli Cheese Man on Dec 31, 2008


speed racer is my no.4. happy new years

darrin on Dec 31, 2008


a decent list... i really enjoyed speed racer, the visual style, and fast pace of story progression (even though it was a 2hr movie) was great and overall even though its supposedly a kids oriented movie i think anyone of any age will enjoy it loved religulous... laughed all the way through and the arguments provided can not be ignored by any reasonable person death race is briefly mentioned in the Bank Job description... i was suprised how entertained i was by that movie (that movie being death race, bank job was ok)

Janny on Dec 31, 2008


Great list. My #1 would be Wall-E. To me it has the same type of genuine axe-grinding emotion There Will Be Blood did, which gripped me so.

Bob on Dec 31, 2008


i agree with comment #1 in bruges definitely deserved to hit more lists.

Reece on Dec 31, 2008


The Bank Job was a laughable film. Jesus Christ man that and Speed Racer are on your list, I'm sorry man but those movies blow. Well, I guess thats why we are all entitled to our own opinions. Anyways, no Synecdoche, New York, no Wrestler, not even in honorable mentions but you have the Incredible Hulk? At least you have Shotgun Stories and Changeling on there.

Betterchill on Dec 31, 2008


I haven't seen most of the movies on your list, but I enjoyed this year in movies mainly because I am seeing a new trend. A trend that is combining entertaining crowd-pleasers with good film making. I enjoy both high action fun movies and love and respect well made movies. I was happy to see a number of movies that combined both of these elements with Iron Man, Wall-E, The Dark Knight, and most recently Valkyrie. Those four are well made movies that I really enjoyed and was also well entertained with. If this trend continues in Hollywood I will be very happy.

Jordan on Jan 1, 2009


Wow...that's the first list I've seen with Elegy at the top...I guess I'll have to give it a shot now.

peloquin on Jan 1, 2009


Same with The Fall...not many good reviews of that out there. I'm also wondering why you didn't include any kind of documentary...there were definitely a few which are top ten worthy.

peloquin on Jan 1, 2009


@ peloquin: My #6 pic "Roman Polanski: Wanted and Desired" is a great documentary. "Religulous" is an honorable mention doc and there were a few others I considered (Standard Operating Procedure, Man on Wire) . Overall it was a pretty good year for docs. Also, give "Elegy" a shot when it hits DVD in March. You won't regret it. 🙂

Boxoffice Marco on Jan 1, 2009


Best experiences, not best films...alright, here goes: 1) The Dark Knight 2) Cloverfield 3) Iron-Man 4) Wall-E 5) Speed Racer 6) Slumdog Millionaire 7) There Will Be Blood 8) In Bruges I haven't seen many of the "for your consideration" films of this year yet, so this list will surely change once I do/

Keith on Jan 2, 2009


I'm so glad that you've put THE FALL on the list. Such imaginative and warm stories deserve much more attention 😉 Tarsem is a genius.

DEZMOND on Jan 2, 2009


the dark knight was great for me but i hated wall e.

shirley on Jan 2, 2009


I like the theme of this list. It makes the most sense. Movies -- or atleast watching them is a personal experience and an arbitrary rating system or list of the best really don't hold any merit. But best film experience is a very tangible topic. As for my list I'd have to say; 10. Benjamin Button 9.Smart People 8.Forgetting Sarah Marshall 7.Burn After Reading 6.Last Chance Harvey 5.Milk 4.The Dark Knight 3. Changeling 2. There Will Be Blood 1. Revolutionary Road

adrian on Jan 2, 2009


The Fall was a pretty cool movie....the scene with the butterfly that turns into an island is pretty incredible.

bill on Jan 2, 2009


I haven't seen most of those but now I will. I like how you included both artsy films and big budget. You always give an honest, intelligent perspective to the films you review and I appreciate that. Nice job.

nell on Jan 6, 2009


best 2008 experiences to me: revolver a guide to recognizing your saints stop loss the dark knight vicky cristina barcelona wall-E Iron Man THe Incredible Hulk RocknRolla Burn after Reading that´s it

Djalma on Jan 7, 2009


agreed that elegy was one of the best of the year. no one else seems to be mentioning it. I just dont get why Felon isnt getting more respect from you guys. That movie rocked

Dan on Jan 9, 2009


Congratulations (and thanks) for recognizing the all-but-ignored THE FALL as one of the great filmgoing experiences of the year. There is more to enjoy in any randomly selected five minutes of this tribute to storytelling in all its forms--from spoken word to movie screen--than in the entire length of almost anything else released in 2008...or for that matter, within recent memory. Tarsem's painstaking work with his actors rivals that of Mike Leigh, and his visual flare and astonishing use of locales achieves the magic THE PRINCESS BRIDE promised but, with William Goldman's smart script sabotaged The Meathead's dull directing, failed to deliver.

mintonmedia on Jan 17, 2009


All English Language Huh?

s on Jan 24, 2009


I totally agree about Wall- E surpassing Dark Knight. But what about Doubt? I think that it had great acting(Hoffman, Streep, Adams, Davis-all were stellar) and mis en scene. John Patrick Shanley definitely redeemed himself as a film maker after Joe Vs. Volcano.

Las Vegas Lawyer on May 19, 2009


Speed racer was great, have to see a bunch more before i decide

Products on Aug 5, 2009


I enjoy both high action fun movies and love and respect well made movies. I was happy to see a number of movies that combined both of these elements with Iron Man, Wall-E, The Dark Knight, and most recently Valkyrie. Those four are well made movies that I really enjoyed and was also well entertained with.

Grow Taller 4 Idiots on Nov 16, 2009

New comments are no longer allowed on this post.



Subscribe to our feed or daily newsletter:

Follow Alex's main account on Twitter:

For only the latest posts - follow this:

Add our posts to your Feedlyclick here

Get all the news sent on Telegram Telegram