Roger Ebert Reveals His 20 Best Films of 2008
Fellow critic Roger Ebert has already announced his 20 best films of 2008 well before most of us have even seen all of this year's movies. Ebert has quickly become my own favorite critic and journalist, largely because he believes in so many of the same things that I believe in (like an animosity towards 3D) and still has such a strong voice in this industry. As for his list this year, he says, "I am violating the age-old custom that film critics announce the year's 10 best films, but after years of such lists, I've had it." So instead of 10, he's bringing us 20 of his favorite films. Whether you agree or not, Ebert proclaims: "2008 was a great year for movies, even if many of them didn't receive wide distribution." Read on for the full list!
"These 20 stood out for me, and I treasure them all. If it had been 19 or 21, that would have been OK," Ebert says. Let's get right into it, and don't forget, these aren't in any particular order!
The Band's Visit
The Dark Knight
Rachel Getting Married
Synecdoche, New York
Ebert also named his "Special Jury Prize" winner, which was My Winnipeg, and listed 5 documentaries separately, all of which can be seen on his website. I've only actually seen 10 of those on his list, but plan on catching as many of the remaining 10 as I can, with a few screenings already scheduled in the next few weeks. I think he has one of the best lists we'll see all year, because he covers the big ones (even Iron Man) and the more important, but usually ignored, ones (like The Reader and Rachel Getting Married) and even a few that not too many people know about (like Ballast, Chop Shop, and Shotgun Stories). If you've been looking for a few movies to catch up with from this year, start here. Ebert won't steer you wrong.
Reader Feedback - 45 Comments
You can count The Fall as an 2008 film? Awesome
Angelo on Dec 7, 2008
Also, these are in a particular order. Alphabetical that is 😀
Angelo on Dec 7, 2008
No "In Bruges" that's a shame that all i can say
Davor on Dec 7, 2008
No Tropic Thunder????!?!?! Epic Fail
yourmom (I know...but im not going to use my real name) on Dec 7, 2008
NO Gran Torino on his list! Im glad he has W. on his list. That is a really good film. Chuck
entertainmenttodayandbeyond.com on Dec 7, 2008
Gran Torino, and The Wrestler should have easily replaced W. and Iron Man.
al on Dec 7, 2008
Cloverfield ? Incredible Hulk ? In Bruges ?
Kill the Batman on Dec 7, 2008
step brothers is no.1 in my book
Darrin on Dec 7, 2008
Why would Incredible Hulk be on there? I just hate how comedies never get the credit they deserve.
Aaron on Dec 7, 2008
I think he hit the nail on the head, but I would have liked to have seen The Vistor on here, that movie was beyond amazing!
Lolly on Dec 7, 2008
I'm glad he has the Fall up there... but W? Really?
CSpuppydog on Dec 7, 2008
Curiously enough, no Benjamin Button. I was surprised to see this omission. Seeing as how many have tipped it to be the one to beat at the Kodak theatre.
leo on Dec 7, 2008
Hulk looool rofl
Narf on Dec 7, 2008
I'm not sure if he's counting Gran Torino towards a 2008 list because it is only being widely released in January. But aside from that, I would've liked to have seen In Bruges on there as well.
jman571 on Dec 7, 2008
number 6 have you seen either? or are you simply making wild asumtions?
ben potter on Dec 7, 2008
and p.s. in bruges was a peace of shit.
ben potter on Dec 7, 2008
YEAH!!! The Fall...my first blu-ray movie Ebert's review of it is blunt: "Watch it because you'll never see anything like it again" Seeing this list makes me feel like I'm missing the entire underside of the cinema iceberg
Jaf on Dec 7, 2008
No Hulk, what a crock but then again he's always been kind of a cock.
dac_fan on Dec 7, 2008
#15, haven't seen either, but they are also not wild assumptions. Arronofski has yet to disappoint, neither has Eastwood ever since Letters From Iwo Jima. Iron Man was pretty overrated shit, a good movie? yeah, but great? absolutely not. W. was an enormous let down. As for me making wild assumptions, not at all. Its called a prediction and plenty of them are made during the award show season.
al on Dec 7, 2008
kill it with fire
dude on Dec 7, 2008
where the fuck is the wrestler?
Not You on Dec 7, 2008
what a flawed list
Scott McHenry on Dec 7, 2008
No Hulk? Oh my god are you kidding me? Of course the Hulk isn't on his list, that movies a fucking joke!
Betterchill on Dec 7, 2008
#19 Correction: Eastwood hasn't disappointed since Changeling. Which was a disappointment.
Who Fitzed Edmund? on Dec 7, 2008
That is a terrible pic of Roger Ebert.
YOU!!! on Dec 7, 2008
Darren on Dec 7, 2008
I've like Roger for a long time myself as he has been a huge proponent of good anime for best animated feature for many years; especially Miyazaki films. This year was an excellent year for movies; big and small productions. I have no qualms with his list for the movies I have seen, but it does seem empty without "The Wrestler".
L on Dec 7, 2008
i agree with ebert because the movie the fall is unlike any movie i have ever seen before great cinematogrophy along with a great story
anthony on Dec 7, 2008
He isn't very photogenic is he? Well neither am I. I like his picks, for 2008.
xerxex on Dec 7, 2008
The Band's Visit? why is that on a 2008 list?
oscar on Dec 8, 2008
Its nice that he picks movies from different categories. A lot of critics just ignore f.e. action movies like Iron Man and Dark Knight. Even if i wasnt a big fan of either, they were "the best of their genre" this year. Too bad even 1/5th of those movies havent been screened in Finland. Cant wait to see Frost/Nixon, Che, Happy-Go-Lucky, Milk, Slumdog Millionaire and W.
max on Dec 8, 2008
Iron Man? Hahaha, oh, God.
Lopretni on Dec 8, 2008
The lack of The Wrestler saddens me. Everything else though is good by me. Then again there's no Benjamin Button........
Itri on Dec 8, 2008
Whats up with that picture of him? It looks like he had neck surgery or he's recovering from a stroke.
Nick Sears on Dec 8, 2008
I have no problem at all with this list! Ebert, showin' them how it's done once again. Some of these movies I missed (The Fall, W.) and some that haven't come here yet (Che, Frost/Nixon, Slumdog Millionaire). I'm glad I caught some of the smaller ones (Synecdoche, New York, The Band's Visit) and I guess I'll try to catch Rachel Getting Married and Happy-Go-Lucky while they're still out there int he theaters. They didn't really seem like something I'd be interested in, until I remind myself that what I'm interested in are good films. Angelo (#2), best comment of the month. So far.
kevjohn on Dec 8, 2008
I'm not at all surprised that you emulate Roger Ebert, Alex. You both write reviews at a fourth grade level.
Zinglebert Bemzidak on Dec 8, 2008
Fellow critic Roger Ebert - THATS KIND OF PUSHING IT DONT YOU THINK ALEX. EVEN USING THE TERM CRITIC LOOSLY.
what ever on Dec 8, 2008
Ebert is a tool. I can't believe this guys views are seriously "treasured". Like the holy fucking grail. Please...think and judge for yourselves.
wm on Dec 8, 2008
Once again where the hell is curious case of benjamin button?
leo on Dec 8, 2008
@38 WORD! i mean, wtf? ebert is just an old man who thinks his opinion has a weight. it doesn't! iron man under 20 best films? he cannot be serious, i mean, it was shit, it short, and it had that shitty smell of hypocritical patriotism.
lol on Dec 10, 2008
Guys. Relax. These are HIS favorite films of the year. His opinions are his own. You can't say he's wrong. He's right. Are they your favorites? Maybe. Maybe not. I admit, he named a lot of great movies. Some I still need to see. THE FALL is now on my list of must see.... Hey... Wait.. What the..??? Where is Space Chimps??? OMG Roger knows nothing!!! LOL
dhthompson on Dec 15, 2008
I'm so glad The Fall is on there! amazing visual masterpiece!
dave13 on Dec 15, 2008
im glad slumdog is in. it will be the best picture in the coming oscars, i bet. we need underdogs in the oscars . let's vote for slumdog. it will be A VICTORY of asian movies, eventhoug an englishman , boyle , directs it.
maya on Jan 13, 2009
Great Feature on Roger. Check out Roger’s response to the 5QuickQuestions: http://5quickquestions.wordpress.com/2009/01/20/7-roger-ebert/
Josh on Jan 21, 2009
Milk? What a fag
Jackson on Feb 8, 2009
Sorry, new comments are no longer allowed.