SXSW FILM FESTIVAL
SXSW Review: Chuck Palahniuk's Choke
by Ken Evans
March 22, 2008
Chuck Palahniuk is definitely one creative and crazy writer. I haven't had the pleasure of reading any of his books, but a few of my friends have and they really enjoyed them. If you don't know who Palahniuk is, then perhaps you have heard of a movie called Fight Club. That's right, he also wrote that. Choke, his newest book turned into film, is set to be released sometime in August this year. I had the pleasure of seeing it at SXSW and walked out torn between the offensive content and extremely enjoyable and creative story.
Choke is the story of Victor Mancini (Sam Rockwell) who is a sex addict that works as an historical interpreter at a Colonial re-enactment town. His life is riddled with problems, all of which stem from the kind of man he is deep down. His mother (Anjelica Huston) is hospitalized in a mental facility and can't tell the difference between her lawyers and her own son. Besides being a sex addict, Mancini struggles with the need for affection which he fulfills by forcing food down his throat at restaurants. By doing this he knows that someone will save him and thus building a bond between the victim and savior. As his mother takes a turn for the worse he learns a secret that shakes him to his core.
What is so great about films like Choke and Fight Club are that they are immensely unique and creative stories. Palahniuk has an ending he wants you to get to, but the way in which he gets you there is fraught with twists and turns that make the whole journey enjoyable and something different then we normally experience in a film. As an author, I think he is incredible and would love to check out some of his other books.
Don't be tricked into thinking that since you liked Fight Club, you will also like Choke. I'm talking about the films and not the books. The subject matter is totally different and they bear no resemblance to one another. David Fincher was at the helm of Fight Club and his vision for that film was what made it so great. The story for Choke just doesn't lend itself to the stylistic approach that Fincher took. All that said, you can decide whether or not you want watch Choke based off of the actual story from Fight Club instead of the cinematic style.
All in all, Choke had my attention the entire film. It was funny and extremely cleaver. I loved how all his problems had a purpose and tied together at the end. The problems it will run into theatrically surround the many sex scenes and nudity. It all makes sense given the face that he is a sex addict, but the length and graphic nature of some of the scenes might cause a huge portion of moviegoers to lose interest. Choke will do well with Palahniuk fans, avid film watchers, and those who see it knowing only that it was written by the same guy who wrote Fight Club. Not one I would rush out to see, but I expect it will eventually do really well on DVD.
Loved this book. Moreso then the novel of fight club, which is quite different from the film. Another book by Chuck people should check is Survivor.
mike on Mar 22, 2008
All these assumptions you're making about what a terrific writer Palahniuk is-I wish you'd read just ONE of his books before throwing such unrestrained compliments his way. I read both Fight Club & Choke-and the former's film adaptation was amazing,the book was horribly written (really simplistic,and just meekly going chapter to chapter without any real enthusiasm-Choke was downright awful).I beg you,just pick up any one of his books and bloody hell give it a read.
twispious on Mar 24, 2008
I hope they eventually adapt Chuck's 'Diary' and 'Invisible Monsters' for movies, i really love those books!
Ross on Mar 24, 2008
Sounds like twispious is jealous. Chuck is a brilliant writer. And relating to your comment on Choke being awful, Chuck himself told you not to waste you're time reading it (it's on the very first page) and you still did. So what does that say about you. So, how about next time, don't review someone elses review and go write your own
PeashooterPj on May 6, 2008
I know that Chuck Palahniuk's Choke has been out for a while now but Chuck is such a brilliant writer that I thought I would drop a kudos comment. I have read this book at least twice and recommended it to at least four other people. This was all based on this original post which recommended the book. Thank you much I will be back..
Maylon on Dec 26, 2009
Sorry, new comments are no longer allowed.