Paul Blart Director Steve Carr Hired for the Short Circuit Remake

October 27, 2009

Steve Carr - Johnny 5

This right here, this is when we know this movie is going to suck. Say what you will, but there's no giving Steve Carr the benefit of the doubt on this one. Besides directing the pile of crap known as Paul Blart: Mall Cop, his other credits include Are We Done Yet?, Rebound, Daddy Day Care, Dr. Dolittle 2, and Next Friday. Sure, the script, written by "Robot Chicken" writer Dan Milano, might not be that bad, but Carr is going to screw it up. This Short Circuit remake is going to go onto his filmography right there along with the others as yet another piece of crap. This finally confirms what we knew all along - this remake will suck!

Variety says that "the remake is a robot reboot that brings the iconic Johnny 5 into the 21st century." Built by the military to be a highly sophisticated weapon, Johnny 5 develops a conscience and personality after being hit by lightning. He befriends a lonely boy and his fractured family. Normally I'd like to be optimistic and say that maybe it has a chance of being fun, but this time I've just got to accept reality, and Steve Carr is not going to deliver a good movie. The original was classic because it's a campy 80's kids movie that we all saw as kids. But remade nowadays by the Paul Blart director, there's just no chance it'll be any good, sorry!

Find more posts: Movie News, Opinions



I actually rather enjoyed Paul Blart en Dr Dolittle 2..

Gabs on Oct 27, 2009


Although I don't want to, I have to agree. This movie is going to suck, no matter how bad we want it to be good. I mean even the original sucked. It just sucked in that wonderfully humpty dumpty way that only 80s movie can, and we loved it for it. It was like Mannequin for kids with a robot. However, Paul Blart and most of the other movies on Carr's resume just suck, no saving grace, they just suck.

AwwMan on Oct 27, 2009


finally, with all the fluff and love you guys give to just about everything on this site I am finally glad you just outright say it will suck. I think Daddy Day Care was good, but that was mainly because of the kids and Steve Zahn.

branden on Oct 27, 2009


A little bit biased are we... You haven't even seen a trailer yet.

Vold on Oct 27, 2009


good to see you're unbiased on this one. Man, and I thought film journalism was losing its ways...

notes on Oct 27, 2009


Oh come on, seriously, you're going to defend the guy who made Paul Blart: Mall Cop and Daddy Day Care and Dr. Dolittle 2? You really think he'll actually make a good movie out of Short Circuit? You guys are bias if you really think that's going to happen.

Alex Billington on Oct 27, 2009


:'( Another memory ruined by a limited imagination at Hollywood.

Link1983 on Oct 27, 2009


The thing about the original "Short Circuit" is that its the kind of movie where if you liked it at all, then you probably like it just as it is. It's not like the movie needs to be "made better" by modern technology. The original Short Circuit is about as good as the concept can really be. On the other side, there's plenty of people who didn't like the original, and probably won't have any interest in the remake. So the question really stands: "Who is this movie for?".

DRM on Oct 27, 2009


The theme song "Who's Johnny?" will be covered by an all-star lineup including Miley Cyrus, Katy Perry, the 5th runner up from the next round of American Idol and Carr's daughter who, like, totally wants to be a singer.

ElDeBarge on Oct 27, 2009


Awesome, another one of my fondest childhood memories about to be raped beyond recognition. To hell with this remake.

Breach on Oct 27, 2009


Steve Carr should make "Short Circuit vs. Paul Blart" instead. Just think of it; one movie and we'll get rid of one crappy director and two crappy movies.

Hattori Hanzo on Oct 27, 2009


What? Hey Hollywood throw some of that waste money my way eh?

JimD on Oct 28, 2009


Why are we remaking this movie? Hollywood can't come up with any novel robot films? This will probably be an alright movie for a new generation, but this generation already has Wall-E .

Mark on Oct 28, 2009


I am part of the small amount of people that thought Paul Blart was rather decent of a film, not going to EVER own it but still enjoyable. However Short Circuit shouldn't get remade, period. It is going to be right there with Footloose, Fame, and all the other late 70- mid 80 movie remakes that shouldn't be made.

Negro on Nov 3, 2009


Daddy day care and Dr Dolittle 2 were alright. Not great but alright. But i agree it shouldn't be remade...

Will on Nov 4, 2009


Alex, I usually back you up but right now I'm not too sure. Johnny 5 was the best robot ever. He'd kick the shit out of R2D2 any day and he'd even make some campy one liners while doing it. Don't hate on it yet. I hated Rob Cohen with every fiber of my being after the first Fast and Furious movie but I still enjoyed XXX. The mere thought of a Johnny 5 in this era will be good. You can't sit these kids down nowadays and have them enjoy a good 80's flick. If it's not titties and guts, they don't want it. I say go for it, make the movie and lets see what the new Johnny 5 will look like. I bet it will be a CGI robot though, can't compete with them 80's prop guys.

that guy on Nov 9, 2009


I like Steves movies. Sit back, relax, enjoy some laughs. You try directing a movie and see how good you are. Jeff

Jeff on Nov 20, 2009


How can anyone spend millions on making a movie and hire great actors and sound track artists etc, and flunk out big time? The fact that it even sees the light of day must mean it's at least halfway good surely? I don't usually bother going to see movies or rent DVD but this is one I would definitely see regardless of what the critics might say, purely because I loved the originals so much. Hopefully they'll keep some of the best elements of the original in place and improve on any deficiencies.

Tim on Jan 27, 2010

New comments are no longer allowed on this post.



Subscribe to our feed -or- daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main account on twitter:
For the latest posts only - follow this one:

Add our updates to your Feedly - click here

Get the latest posts sent in Telegram