Sundance 2009 Review: Derrick Comedy's Mystery Team

January 18, 2009

Derrick Comedy's Mystery Team

Last night's world premiere of Derrick Comedy's Mystery Team was quite an experience. Most people already know who the Derrick Comedy guys are, so seeing them finally take the leap from making YouTube videos to a full-time feature was quite impressive. But nothing can prepare you for this kind of never-before-seen crazy, kooky, and sometimes ridiculous, comedy that Mystery Team boasts. They've pulled it off - they've made a sketch comedy feature film that delivers consistent laughs for an entire 105 minutes. It's a different kind of humor, but it works. It looks like Mystery Team is on its way to becoming a hit.

Mystery Team probably has one of the most ridiculous concepts you'll ever hear. Three high school best friends -- Jason (Donald Glover), the master of disguise, Duncan (D.C. Pierson), the boy genius, and Charlie (Dominic Dierkes), the strongest kid in town -- run a shoddy detective business, solving crimes like who ran over the frog or who stuck their finger in the pie. But when a young girl comes asking them to find out who killed her parents, they jump at the opportunity as a chance to finally prove to the town that they really are legitimate detectives. Unfortunately solving a double murder isn't exactly as easy as they thought.

It seems to me that the Derrick Comedy guys are on their way to becoming the first YouTubers to successfully pull off a big screen transition. Most sketch comedy groups can hardly remain funny for a few minutes, but these guys have gone and made a hilarious film that is sure to go down in internet history. While all three of the leads are great, it's Glover who really shines, making this feel like much more than just a comedy with amateur actors. Additionally, up-and-coming actress Aubrey Plaza adds a perfect dynamic as the leading lady who doubts the Mystery Team's abilities. Just wait until you see how it all goes down.

Watching these three guys make fools of themselves on the big screen truly is an awesome experience second to none. I admire their originality more than anything and will gladly support them, and this film, on their path to success. Mystery Team is not flawless, and does have some pacing issues, but overall it's an excellent comedy that the YouTube generation will embrace with open arms.

Sundance Rating: 7.5 out of 10

Find more posts: Opinions, Sundance 09




Ady on Jan 18, 2009


Showing! ... is awesome

Boris on Jan 18, 2009


I'm actually really happy these amateurs managed to make a good movie. I'll be seeing it because I respect all of their other videos.

Bryan on Jan 18, 2009



Fuelbot on Jan 18, 2009


I don't really get how yelling 'First!' adds to the discussion Just being a devil's advocate

Jaf on Jan 19, 2009


i dont really get how just commenting on the first comment yelling First! adds to the descussion either but hey?. Furthermore i have seen most of the derrick comedy videos and think there perfectly done, cant wait to see this movie!

ben on Jan 19, 2009


I really do hope they come up with some sort of distribution idea. Form what I read, they're trying to market their film, so it may be a while before we see it online-- if at all. I won't lie though; I've followed these guys from day one, and would not mind one bit buying their DVD if it means supporting some of the best talent collegehumour has to offer.

Andy on Jan 27, 2009


This was a brilliant movie. I recommend to anyone! And please, pay for it, its that good!

Tim Whybrow on May 31, 2010

New comments are no longer allowed on this post.



Subscribe to our feed -or- daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main account on twitter:
For the latest posts only - follow this one:

Add our updates to your Feedly - click here

Get the latest posts sent in Telegram Telegram