Toronto 2009 Review: Drew Barrymore's Whip It
by Alex Billington
September 20, 2009
My first introduction to the world of roller derby and thankfully there was no painful initiation. Whip It is no masterpiece, but for the directorial debut of Drew Barrymore, it's pretty damn good. I'm looking forward to whatever she directs next, but for her debut behind the camera, I was considerably impressed. As for her stars, Ellen Page has never looked better on roller skates, and Alia Shawkat has never been funnier. It's a sweet, charming, occasionally humorous, and fun little southern film, but it doesn't hit as hard as the girls in the derby do. I wanted to love it but just couldn't. There's just not enough to appreciate, I guess.
Whip It tells the story of Bliss Cavendar (Page), who lives in a small town outside of Austin. Her mom (Marcia Gay Harden) keeps putting her in beauty pageants but that's not her calling and she knows it. One day while shopping in Austin, some roller derby chics stop by the store she's at. The next day she pulls out her Barbie roller skates and tries out for the local league of five teams. She makes it onto the Hurl Scouts, the worst team in the league, and it becomes an underdog story about going for the gold. Well, it becomes a story about friends and finding the path in life you want to take, even if your mother doesn't approve.
While Whip It is fun, it's got some issues, mainly with its script. It was written by Shauna Cross, a derby girl herself, who also wrote the novel that it's based on. She's a writing newbie, but unlike someone such as Diablo Cody, isn't exactly the most experienced screenwriter. It also never delves deep enough into the sport side of things. Sure we get to see a few matches, including almost all of the final match, but we don't learn too many of the rules, only the basics and that's it. Even when their coach whips up a playbook and puts it to use on the track, we never get any fun explanations, just a short scene showing it in use. It felt like there could've been more, especially considering the film made me curious to learn about the actual sport.
Overall I was impressed with Whip It and I enjoyed it. Barrymore isn't a strong point (in front of or behind the camera), but Ellen Page and her sidekick Pash (played by Alia Shawkat) are, along with the derby girls, including Kristen Wiig, Zoe Bell, and Juliette Lewis. If you go in pretty much expecting Mighty Ducks but on roller skates with a bunch of punk chics, you won't be disappointed. But don't expect more than that. Sure it's a bit typical, sure you may see some of the plot points coming a mile away, but that doesn't mean you can't enjoy it. At least I had a good time, and that's what counts the most when I'm watching movies.
Toronto Rating: 7 out of 10
No surprises on Barrymore, she looked out of place and odd from the first trailer
Movieraider321 on Sep 21, 2009
Finally I hear people talking about Alia Shawkat in this. Apart from IMDB, nowhere has mentioned her! I do miss ol Maebe Funke!
Marcus on Sep 21, 2009
You mean an underdog goes on to win the big match?!?! What an extremely original idea!
StabmasterArson on Sep 21, 2009
@ StabmasterArson It has become just as cliche to have the underdog lose in the end, while gaining an important lesson. Film looks cool. I don't trust the review.
Alex on Sep 21, 2009
The Movie looks awesome, and it will help bring the sport back into the main stream. I for one am excited to watch the movie and to see how many girls will come trying out for their local teams! And I am glad Drew was able to direct such a fun, and exciting movie. From what I heard she did a lot of research on the sport. Our team plans to be at opening night at the local theater and pass out information to people wanting to know more about the awesomeness of Roller Derby. I'm pretty sure we will have to weed through all the girls who want to look like a derby girl, and the girls who really want to kick some arse, but it will be well worth it. GO DERBY! w00t 🙂 Lisafer #664
Lisafer on Sep 22, 2009
Drew Barrymore is always out of place- in front of and behind the camera. Her ET money and Sandler love is what has kept her at the forefront. Her ideas/movies are unoriginal and copied. I don't trust many of the lovefest reviews on this site- and thankfully my expectations have been tampered, then again I didn't have any. I rate this on a scale of: Going to the Movies! -- Downloading-- Buying DVD -- Renting DVD -- Going to someone else's house to watch this (they paid to rent it) -- TV -- Not Downloading as Not Downloading.
Jon the Rob-ot on Sep 22, 2009
From the trailers I have seen, his movie looks great, still haven't see an release date for the UK though? hope it gets released here in England. My team, the London Rockin rollers will deffo go see it!!! Kit
Kit Kat Power #664 on Oct 11, 2009
I don't know what there was not to like about this film. Girls on rollerskates. I think I'll watch it again.
Crapola on Jan 1, 2010
Sorry, new comments are no longer allowed.