Officially Announced: Guillermo del Toro is Off of The Hobbit!

May 30, 2010

Guillermo del Toro / Peter Jackson

Holy crap this is big. It was announced by Peter Jackson & Guillermo del Toro today on TheOneRing that del Toro will no longer direct The Hobbit, but will still co-write the screenplays. "Out of respect to the legions of loyal Tolkien fans," they broke the news on the site and will make sure "the films are everything that the fans want them to be." Del Toro: "In light of ongoing delays… for filming The Hobbit, I am faced with the hardest decision of my life. After nearly two years of living, breathing and designing a world as rich as Tolkien's Middle Earth, I must, with great regret, take leave from helming these wonderful pictures."

This is so sad to hear and means a lot more about the project's delay, which has been stalled since MGM went bankrupt last year and on hold until they find someone to re-finance the entire company. As for the future of The Hobbit, we're not sure what to expect. "We feel very sad to see Guillermo leave The Hobbit, but he has kept us fully in the loop and we understand how the protracted development time on these two films, due to reasons beyond anyone's control, has compromised his commitment to other long-term projects," Jackson said. It sounds like there's a very interesting story behind this and maybe we'll find out more in the coming months about what happened, such as if GDT is announced as a director on another different film.

According to, The Hobbit is still planned to be adapted into two movies, one to be released in December 2012 & the other in December 2013. So as far as they know, it's still on, but no mention of who's taking his place instead. "The blessings have been plenty, but conflicting schedules have overwhelmed the time slot originally allocated," said del Toro. "Both as a co-writer and as a director, I wish the production nothing but the very best of luck and I will be first in line to see the finished product. I remain an ally to it and its makers, present and future, and fully support a smooth transition to a new director." Thoughts?

Find more posts: Hobbit, Hype, Movie News, Opinions



Yes! Now del Toro can move on to other, and better projects

Daniel on May 30, 2010


This. Sucks. I've been stoked for this ever since I saw Pan's Labyrinth.

Drew on May 30, 2010


Damn...He wasted all that time with this movie when he could have been making other films. Now he can start working on Hellboy III.

Thor on May 30, 2010


Wow! Who saw that news coming today? While I love Del Toro's fims, as a huge fan of The LOTR's movies, I wasn't all that thrilled about his involvement in The Hobbit; his style just didn't seem to fit Jackson's vision to me. I sense that his leaving may have more to do with creative differences than anything else and he is using the delay as a way out. Now The Hobbit is back where it belongs, in Jackson's hands and hopefully he will scrap the idea of a dragging The Hobbit out over two parts amd make it a single movie instead as it should be.

Hattoris Hanzo on May 30, 2010


WHAT THE FUCK ?????????????????!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

8=D on May 30, 2010


I like Del Toro as a person, but I don't think he is the one and only who can do this. My hopes stay with Peter Jackson, as long he is with the project i'm with the project!

Rick on May 30, 2010


Now he can start work on Hellboy 3, Ron Perlman isn't getting any younger! I have faith in Jackson I'm sure he will bring us The Hobbit in due time!

Xerxex on May 30, 2010


I am sad now...

Ambient on May 30, 2010


I agree with #4 ... While Del Toro and Jackson are big fans of The Hobbit and brilliant fiml makers, their styles don't mesh. The Hobbit is better off in Jackson's hands and now Del Toro can concentrate on giving us more movies like Pan and Hellboy ... If nothing else, Del Toro's leaving now forces MGM to 'shit or get or get off the pot' as the old saying goes when it comes to The Hobbit. There is definetely more to this story than meets the eye.

Sam Shadey on May 30, 2010


Come on Jackson just man up and get the film rolling under your direction

Sharlto on May 30, 2010


As much as I want to see this, another sign that this will never be made in the coming years. Del Toro would have been perfect for The Hobbit and I don't know if another director could capture his vision.

4k4k on May 30, 2010


Yes, thank God!!! Don't get me wrong Del Toro is one of my favorite director's and I would've LOVED to see him direct The Hobbit but let's face it... The preproduction on that film was terrible and time consuming. We basically had two years of absolute NOTHING. I seriously hope Del Toro now invests his time in making a third Hellboy.

asfsd on May 30, 2010


Great, now Sam Raimi will direct.

Book of Eli on May 30, 2010


How can you blame del toro for pre-production when MGM never gave them the money or even officially greenlit the project?

Rashad on May 30, 2010


Its going to be the man himself, Peter Jackson will helm (direct) The Hobbit. It was a long ploy by MGM so that Del Toro would move on. Peter didnt have the rights at first and now since it took so much time MGM's plan worked. Now in charge once again will be Peter. As said by Associated Press.

The movie man on May 30, 2010


... Shame. Oh well. Now carry-on Guillermo! Lets get to some new ground.

Cracky on May 30, 2010


Why doesn't Jackson just direct it... hell he can almost afford to fund it too!

Will on May 30, 2010


YESSSSSSSSSS!!!!!!!!!! Never wanted him to direct it anyway. That's not to say that I think any replacement will be better, but the last thing I want to see is yet another version of Pan's Labyrinth.

RT on May 30, 2010


NO! 🙁

Al on May 30, 2010



movie mike on May 30, 2010


🙁 I think Mr. Del Toro is a great actor. If anyone saw the Wolfman, they would realize that he will probably still be able to get work on other movies. I'm sure he'll fine. Bummed out, but not the end of the world.

valerie Atherton on May 30, 2010


Yes, Jackson should direct the Hobbit, or does he consider himself to old now for directing another LOTR movie?

George on May 30, 2010


Sad to hear about the time wasted by del Toro, but he has some great non-Hellboy related projects on his plate can't wait for a couple of these films. Not too interested in "The Hobbit" as much as I am some of the other projects del Toro has upcoming.

Professor Brian O'Blivion on May 30, 2010


its all good as soon as they announce a new director fanboys across the universe will jump on his dick just as fast as they did for this one...

kp on May 30, 2010


good good good not the right director for the hobbit anyway, as said before has a different style that doesnt fit in here. hopefully now jackson will direct it as long as its still in the works...

harrison on May 30, 2010


A lot of time wasted, im excited to see what we get from Del Toro. I hope its something fresh, I really can't get excited for a Hellboy III. The previous Hellboy's were good, but weren't anywhere near Pan's Labrynth or The Orphanage in my opinion.

Walker on May 30, 2010


sad sad sad news... I really hope this doesnt mean that we wont see this movie ever come to life. FUCK MGM and along with them all the other fucking snobby know-nothing-about-creativity people in Hollywood!!!!!!!!

Tomi on May 30, 2010


I think they should just kill the movies right now. It's in development and financial hell, lost it's director, and it's financial backing. It will never live up to the Trilogy, best just to let this go.

shadow on May 30, 2010


LMAO @ 22, is he trolling? YAY! Hellboy 3 please.

Ben on May 30, 2010


Del Toro would have been the best man for the job. @22 I think you are retarded I think Matthew Vaughn should direct this, or Tarsem. It's got to be someone as creative and genuis and fantastical as Del Toro, which I think will be dreadfully hard to find

yup on May 30, 2010


This is a bummer. GDT would made something special. I blame MGM.

Candy Castle on May 31, 2010


Tarsem could direct. or maybe peter jackson will jump on?

ryderup on May 31, 2010


J R R Tolkien's novels are life-affirming experiences, mythological stories in which the goodness and courage of men are their primary weapon in the fight against evil. Guillermo Del Toro's movies are about death. The two visions are incompatible. Spain has a long cultural history of producing artists like Del Toro, who explore the mysteries of death in a pessimistic but lapidary vision. For the Hobbit movies to work like LOTR we need the politically incorrect Peter Jackson, whose refusal to produce movies full of cynicism and self-loathing led him to make the beauty of the Lord of the Rings trilogy. The Hobbit is full of innocent curiousity (Bilbo Baggins is a naive hobbit who has never been outside the Shire) and a love of nature and life. You only need a cursory glance at the work of most directors to see that they do not understand these emotions. We need Peter Jackson to direct this movie.

John Van Rijn on May 31, 2010


this is the news ive been waiting for...hes such a crappola director and now they can safely deport him from nz forever. he was a joke, came into the process and added nothing and now has said hes over it. thats good for us too. make another hellboy or pans lab suckfest # 22 is a tard.

kevin rudd on May 31, 2010


Oh well I guess Jackson will direct and personally don't see that as a bad thing. I just hope the whole MGM/ financing debarcle gets sorted soon.

Andy on May 31, 2010


Please god del Toro going to bring his book "The Strain" to the screen. Fantastic book, would put all that twilight bollox in its place. Only del Toro could do it right.

Ryan on May 31, 2010


This Is The Fuckest Movie News In History... Too Little Too Late.

DOLLIE on May 31, 2010


George W. Bush....first he destroys our COUNTRY....then the WORLD....and Now MGM....and finally "The HObbit"" YOu soul-less cocksucker!!!! Your evil knows no bounds.

Clover on May 31, 2010


That stinks! Del Toro's Middle Earth would look so bad ass! All of his trolls and Orc's and monsters would look amazing. The only way this won't disappoint me is if he actually starts At The Mountains of Madness!!!!

Joe Ho on May 31, 2010


Wow! Well now maybe Del Toro can make At the Mountains of Madness and Jackson can direct The Hobbit...all is right with the world.

Jeep-Fu on May 31, 2010


I predict that the Hobbit will be directed by Alan Smithee

Andrew on May 31, 2010


I fucking love Guillermo Del Toro... but it's a bummer that he pulled out of the Hobbits. Damn.... I was looking forward to that. Well, he could direct mY Spec Script though. Its baddass n I know Guillermo would love it. Hells Yeah!!!!!

Noma King on May 31, 2010


Anyone interested to know about my Spec Script and if Guillermo should direct let me know so i could tell u guys.

Noma King on May 31, 2010

44 From the Wellington Daily Newspaper. Every cloud has a silver lining, and I think we may have one here.

cinemabandit on May 31, 2010


In truth, immediately i did understand it. But after re-reading I think i understand

VTR1000 lady on May 31, 2010


Peter Jackson must direct. His vision is what made LOTR great.

vold on May 31, 2010


FUCK! he better make his Frankenstein movie then

DoomCanoe on May 31, 2010


YESSSSS, maybe they can finally get michael bay to direct the hobbit now!

america on Jun 1, 2010


Okay...he can't do the Hobbit, that sucks........but can he direct that H.P. Lovecraft film he was talking about doing? 😀

julian on Jun 1, 2010


now that we've all had our little rant, FOCUS.Mr. Jackson has the ability,the experience and the cash, so hey,if it works, don't fix it.

mona on Jun 1, 2010


Apparently McG has showed interest to take his amazing career into new depths and visual wizardry...

the gimp on Jun 2, 2010


Well after the unholy pile of faeces he turned out with Hellboy 2 this is actually some good news.

gabbo on Jun 6, 2010


#34 - John Van Rijn You're such a moron. Who can say that Jackson's pre-LOTR works are non-cynical and full of a love of life and nature? The LOTR movies were full of affirmation of nature, life and mythology because of Tolkein, not Jackson. Del Toro would have followed in the same vein as Tolkein with The Hobbit. Keep your racist bilge elsewhere.

SlashBeast on Oct 14, 2010

New comments are no longer allowed on this post.



Subscribe to our feed or daily newsletter:

Follow Alex's main account on Twitter:

For only the latest posts - follow this:

Add our posts to your Feedlyclick here

Get all the news sent on Telegram Telegram