Comic-Con 2011: First Impressions of 'The Raven' with John Cusack

July 22, 2011

The Raven

Earlier this week one hell of a splatter appeared in the form of a new poster for the forthcoming period thriller The Raven with John Cusack playing iconic writer Edgar Allen Poe. This week Relativity Media brought the first trailer for to Hall H at Comic-Con 2011 with James McTeigue (V for Vendetta, Ninja Assassin) in tow to talk about the film. Taking cues from Sherlock Holmes, the filmmaker is attempting to craft a suspenseful murder mystery in the form of a fictional story taking place in the last five days of Poe's life, but it seems like a half-hearted copycat narrative that just didn't impress me upon first inspection.

Alice Eve comes along for the ride as our damsel in distress and Luke Evans is basically Poe's Watson-esque sidekick, but he's proactive as the real detective investigating a brutal murder that mirrors the grisly deaths in Poe's published stories. While the concept itself seems like an interesting idea, its execution just feels too much like Guy Ritchie's take on Sherlock Holmes, but lacking any humor, fun or genuine suspense. While the film at least looks good aesthetically, the suspense and the thrills McTeigue is trying to ignite just don't seem to come through, mainly because it's hard to accept Cusack as Poe.

Don't get me wrong, I love John Cusack, and he certainly looks like part, but he still walks, talks and acts like John Cusack who simply seems to be dressing up for some kind of high school play. That sounds harsh, but just within the trailer that was shown, I found it extremely difficult to get invested in the mystery of the grim murders copycatting Poe's stories. Don't get me wrong, in hearing Cusack talk about Poe as a person and illustrating just how much he knows about the writer, it's clear he's immersed himself in the part, but his performance doesn't really reflect that.

If this is a taste of things to come with more historical figures getting caught up in action, adventure, mystery and suspense (remember there's a Leonardo Da Vinci led action adventure on the way, not to mention Anonymous which involves William Shakespeare), then I'm hoping this trend dies down soon. Unless another trailer comes along and changes my mind, I'm not sure that this film will help McTeigue recover from the disaster that was Ninja Assassin. In addition, I think this will probably have Cusack going back to witty romantic comedies for his next film, though I'd really like to see him find a golden script like Grace is Gone again. But for now, I will watch The Raven, nevermore.

Find more posts: Comic-Con 11, Editorial, Opinions



has to be the dumbest complaint i have ever seen

hg on Jul 22, 2011


I think the whole critique was based around his need to use the last sentence.

Tyler Morgan on Jul 22, 2011


It's dumb if you don't understand film. Ever seen Max? The terrible German pre-World War II film Cusack starred in? With his American accent and his High Fidelity shtick? he was bloody terrible. He's going to ruin this movie.

Rich on Jul 23, 2011


oh i sure hope ill get to see that one single expression cusack has in every single movie hes ever made.

Anon on Jul 22, 2011


blue steel?

Ano Nymous on Jul 23, 2011


grosse point blank?

Jericho on Jul 23, 2011


well if you want to be technical, if you read all those really old written interviews then Edgar Allen Poe acts like John Cusack

Jericho on Jul 22, 2011


hmm...who can I sell my Hieronymus Bosch vs Inter-dimensional demons script to?

Sethamus on Jul 22, 2011


I agree with you on John Cusack.

Anonymous on Jul 23, 2011


Man John Cusack looks even more douchey than usual with that terrible facial hair. Oh, and that last sentence? Woof. 

Lebowski on Jul 23, 2011

New comments are no longer allowed on this post.



Subscribe to our feed -or- daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main account on twitter:
For the latest posts only - follow this one:

Add our updates to your Feedly - click here

Get the latest posts sent in Telegram Telegram