Looking Back: Ethan Chooses His Own Top 10 Favorite Films of 2011

December 30, 2011

Ethan's Top 10 Films of 2011

Well, after tomorrow, 2011 will be yet another chapter in the history of cinema, and while we've already gone over some of the films that disappointed us and left terrible tastes in our mouths, now is the time to reflect on the films that remind us why we absolutely love going to the movies. There are plenty of films that I enjoyed quite emphatically from the epic conclusion of Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part II to the subtle, quiet but riveting financial crisis drama Margin Call. However, not even those films made the cut to be included in my Top 10 Favorite Films of 2011. So find out what actually tickled my fancy below!

Before dishing the picks for my ten favorite films of the year, I'd like to point out that there are a handful of films such as The Artist, Shame, War Horse and Melancholia that I feel like could have had a solid chance of being featured on this list, but just simply didn't make it to local theaters for me to check them out in a timely manner. So without further ado, here are my personal picks for the ten best films of 2011:

The Muppets

10. The Muppets - It's pretty much the most mainstream, crowd-pleasing film on this list, and while it doesn't make you reflect nearly as much as some of the other films I contemplated putting into the #10 spot, The Muppets left me with a happy feeling that I rarely feel upon leaving movie theaters. If life's a happy song, then The Muppets contains some of the best notes that have ever been played as Jim Henson's iconic characters made a huge return to the big screen that captured the spirit that still lingers from their days on television and meshes it with just the right amount of contemporary comedic sensibilities helped by star and writer Jason Segel, co-writer Nicholas Stoller and director James Bobin.

From the handful of moments where our characters break the fourth wall to the self-aware musical numbers and dozens of Muppet cameos, this film has touched the hearts of young children and nostalgic adults alike, and I found myself feeling like both of them in one wide-grinning man in his mid 20's. Quality movies like this for the whole family just don't come around unless Pixar and to a lesser extent DreamWorks Animation are involved. This is also the only film on the list that I was compelled to see twice in theaters, and felt just as elated and charmed as I did upon the first viewing with my whole family around Thanksgiving.

My Week with Marilyn

9. My Week with Marilyn - This is one of those films that looks like it's trying to rake in Oscars, but in reality, the blends the light and dark of Marilyn Monroe's bright shining star during the story time in her life while she was filming The Prince and the Showgirl with director and star Sir Laurence Olivier. Thankfully, the film wasn't simply a tragic portrait of a girl consumed by fame, but also a charming comedy about show business, and a fleeting but real romance that blossomed between Monroe and one Hollywood dreamer who just happened to be at the right place at the right time.

Kenneth Branagh turns in a funny and spot-on performance as the intense, high-strung, aging Olivier, and Eddie Redmayne proves that he's a star in the making as an aspiring filmmaker, looking to make it big at any turn. Judi Dench and Emma Watson round out a fantastic supporting cast, but it's Michelle Williams who lights up the screen as Ms. Monroe, nailing even the most subtle mannerisms and inflections the blonde bombshell exuded decades ago. I love looking back at the years in cinema I wasn't able to witness personally, and honestly, I wish I could've spent an entire year with Marilyn.

Attack the Block

8. Attack the Block - Original sci-fi films like Attack the Block are hard to come by, but when they come from across the pond with a paltry $13 million dollar budget with stylized special effects that look better than some blockbusters today, you know they're something special. In its simplest form, this film is like Shaun of the Dead but with Aliens, but even more respectfully, Attack the Block feels like a film that just came out of a time capsule buried in the 1980's. With the same feeling as a film like Gremlins, there's laughs to be had, but plenty of bloody action as well.

John Boyega makes a breakthrough performance as the leader of a rag-tag team of hoodies in South London who find themselves chased by tons of silhouetted aliens with glowing teeth, the kind of creatures that could come straight from your dreams. A mix of practical and a small amount of computer effects brings these creatures to life and make them one hell of a force to be reckoned with on the block. The rest of the mostly unknown cast (plus Nick Frost) feel like a genuine group of friends that easily make you think this is something that could happen right down your block. Trust.

Crazy Stupid Love

7. Crazy Stupid Love - Fantastic romantic comedies are hard to come by but are just as plentiful as generic horror films. Few measure up to the greatness and originality of films like When Harry Met Sally or Annie Hall, but every now and then the subgenre gets a golden goose to shut naysayers up for awhile. Crazy Stupid Love is that film with a fantastic script from Dan Fogelman and phenomenal direction by Glenn Ficarra and John Requa, this film is witty, hilarious, touching and heart-wrenching. Whether you're a young couple in puppy love, an experienced couple heading towards engagement or a long-married pair of soulmates, this film has something for everyone.

The film contains just one of Ryan Gosling's three spectacular performances this year (you'll find one higher on this list and the other, Drive, barely missed the cut), and it's just a perfect example of why this guy is going to be on the big screen for a long time. Steve Carell turns in yet another great performance with just the right blend of drama and comedy, and the same can be said for Julianne Moore and Emma Stone. In addition, unlike most romantic comedies, there are actually a couple of interesting twists you might not see coming, and make certain scenes that much more funny.


6. Submarine - Few countries do dark and twisted humor better than the United Kingdom, and comedy actor Richard Ayoade has mastered the art quite well with his directorial debut based on Joe Dunthorne's novel of the same name. With a style and tone reminiscent of Woody Allen, Ayoade's storytelling commands your attention and takes you back to a time in adolescence when wooing the girl of your dreams was the most earth-shaking task in your life. Combine that with some signature dry humor from across the pond, and this film is one of the best coming-of-age tales to hit the big screen in a long time.

Craig Roberts turns in a stunning breakthrough performance and his romantic opposite Yasmin Paige plays mysterious, manipulative and secretly melancholy so well that your teenage self would have had a crush in a heartbeat. British name talent like Noah Taylor, Sally Hawkins and Paddy Considine turn in great supporting performances surrounding our adolescent main characters, and I'm thankful that as a producer, Ben Stiller was smart enough to throw his weight behind this film (even making a short but sweet cameo that doesn't take you out of the story) and let Ayoade make a truly fantastic film.


5. 50/50 - Dramas try to make you feel sad, comedies try to bust your gut with laughter, but it's a rarity to have a film that can do both so successfully and effortlessly. Writer Will Reiser draws upon his own experiences and survival of cancer to craft this wholly funny and emotional story about a young guy in his 20's who has his life turned upside down when he's diagnosed with cancer. It lacks melodrama, but still brings a tear to your eye. It makes light of a touchy situation, but doesn't have to force it. Reiser and director Jonathan Levine accomplish something truly special in a film that is simultaneously harrowing and hilarious.

Joseph Gordon-Levitt proves yet again why he's still around after acting as a child in Angels in the Outfield and "3rd Rock from the Sun" and his chemistry with Seth Rogen makes this friendship and the hardships it endures that much more genuine and difficult to handle. Anna Kendrick and Bryce Dallas Howard both shine playing two different sides of romance in Gordon-Levitt's life as he struggles with illness and a worrisome mother played wonderfully by Anjelica Huston. For anyone with a family member who has had or currently has cancer, this might be just what the doctor ordered.

Midnight in Paris

4. Midnight in Paris - The best way to experience Woody Allen's most recent comedy is with as little knowledge about the story as possible and you'll find yourself getting lost in a whimsical, fantastical world just like Owen Wilson in Midnight in Paris. Taking the best bits of culture, comedy and Paris, Allen has crafted one of his best films in years (and considering he makes one every single year, that's saying something). Allen has had his hits and misses over the past 20 years, but when Allen gets it right, he completely nails it, and Midnight in Paris just proves that Allen is still in his filmmaking prime.

Wilson comes through magnificently in a simple but captivating performance and the supporting cast around him that includes amazing work from actors like Corey Stoll, Alison Pill, Tom Hiddleston, Kathy Bates, Marion Cotillard, Lea Seydoux and an awesome but brief role for Adrien Brody, make this a fantastic ensemble piece. Notice that I haven't revealed the plot information for the film, and I would even go so far as to tell you to steer clear of any trailers or reviews of the film before sitting down to watch this magnificent, vibrant comedy. It's better if you let yourself get lost in cinema and the City of Lights.

The Beaver

3. The Beaver - For the longest time, this film, which has a Black Listed script from writer Kyle Killen, was my favorite of the year, and I had a hard time figuring out my Top 3 films because of it. If I could, I might proclaim a tie for first place with the top three films, because The Beaver surprised the hell out of me when I saw it way back in April. Coming from an unlikely group of creative talent including Jodie Foster in the director's chair and star Mel Gibson, working without much favorable publicity and no big movies to his name lately, I was blown away by how this film resonated with me and just struck all the right chords both dramatic and darkly comedic.

This was a film that was once said to star Jim Carrey and even Steve Carell, and while each of those comedic actors can stretch their dramatic chops rather well, Gibson brought some gravitas to this role that would've been difficult to see beyond the comedic aspects of a man using a beaver puppet as therapy for himself. Even the subplot romance between Anton Yelchin and Jennifer Lawrence hit me hard, and made this drama a truly pleasant, low-key surprise from 2011.

Like Crazy

2. Like Crazy - This film first premiered at the Sundance Film Festival at the beginning of the year, and the buzz was more like a roar. Therefore, I was wholly disappointed when I was unable to get into the final screening, on the final day of the festival. However, the 10 month wait was well worth it, and the heart-wrenching indie romance lived up to the hype. This might not be a film you've heard about much yet because it only got a limited release, but however you can get ahold of this film (as long as its legal), do yourself a favor and watch it. But don't expect to feel all that well afterwards.

Hailed as the Blue Valentine for a younger generation, this romance will lift your heart up and slam it to the ground. Oh, and it also does that about three or four times. It may not make you want to see the movie, but this harrowing love story will make you feel like you've just been broken up with in the worst way possible. Anton Yelchin and Felicity Jones show that they're some of the finest young talent working today, and really make you feel like you're watching two of your best friends endure the most difficult relationship of their lives. Don't watch this one alone.

The Ides of March

1. The Ides of March - George Clooney previously delivered one of my favorite politically centric historical dramas (it's also simply one of my favorite films of all-time) in the form of Good Night and Good Luck at a time when fear-mongering and the exploitation of insecurity was high and patriotism was a scary buzz word driving a lot of poor decisions. This time Clooney is back, and while he doesn't have much to say about politics that hasn't already been said, it comes at a time when political ideology is everything, and no matter what your political beliefs, hope is pretty hard to come by. Sadly, this dark look into the world of campaigning doesn't offer much solace, but it does bring a well-written, directed and acted drama that will serve as a milestone for all involved.

Ryan Gosling delivers the performance of his career (yes, I think it's better than Drive) as a hopeful but somewhat naive campaign manager looking to take his candidate straight for the presidency. Gosling's intensity, especially in lingering, absolutely silent but menacing gazes show the actor's range and have shot him to the top of my list of favorite actors. Meanwhile, Clooney plays the face of that campaign, a face that just might be too good to be true. The film contains some of my favorite monologues of the year, and makes great use of Philip Seymour Hoffman (unlike Moneyball) and Paul Giamatti. Regardless of your political ideals, this is a film that doesn't take aim at any particular party, but rather puts politics itself in the crosshairs and pulls the trigger without hesitation.

Honorable Mentions: Win Win, Rise of the Planet of the Apes, Drive, Margin Call, Being Elmo: A Puppeteer's Journey, Warrior, Hugo, Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows: Part II, Super 8, Moneyball and Take Shelter

So there you have it. 2011 seems to have come and gone rather quickly, but looking back at my favorites while putting this list together, there was a fine assembly of films to be seen this year. Some people are saying the lack of frontrunners for awards season seems to indicate otherwise, but I like the idea of a level playing field where one film doesn't clearly seem to be better than the other. This list in itself was hard to come up with, and filling my #10 spot was a real chore in the decision-making process. But now comes the time to hear from all of you. What are you favorite films of 2011? Do you agree with my choices?

Find more posts: Editorial, Feat, Opinions



The Ides, really .... so 1-dimensional, unoriginal ... performances were top notch, true.

Robert L. Tuva on Dec 30, 2011


Interesting list; I did not expect to see Like Crazy in the top 2.

Peter Kosmal on Dec 30, 2011


Ethan...as ole Abe Lincoln once said, 'Best to remain silent and be thought a fool than to speak out a remove all doubt'. Come on, man! A Muppet movie? Really? I don't know what the point is of '10 Favorite Movies' is, but this one is so silly and immature it's beyond belief! Look, I liked Ides of March...a lot...but one of the all time best films....come on, man!

Bo on Dec 30, 2011


Thanks for delivering a condescending quote from Abraham Lincoln that would much better be served as advice to yourself when I'm just trying to spark discussion amongst movie lovers from fellow film connoisseurs with different tastes. It's not meant to be an objective list to tell people what are definitively the best movies of the year (that's impossible), but rather just what our favorite films turned out to be. The Muppets has appeared on several Top 10 lists, so I'm sorry if your inner child doesn't seep through in your love for film to make it one of your favorites of the year. The point of this list isn't to be pretentious or holier than thou. It's a pick of personal favorites, so accept it as such. Feel free to put your Top 10 out here so we can all see just what a mature list is supposed to look like.

Ethan Anderton on Dec 30, 2011


My respect to you, Ethan.

RFabry on Dec 30, 2011


You have really thin skin.

Zoinks on Dec 30, 2011


That said I really enjoyed your list

Zoinks on Dec 30, 2011


Kiss ass. -__-

GrassyKnoll67 on Dec 31, 2011


LMFAO, you did not have to  own him like that.

Anonymous on Jan 1, 2012


I know right?!? How dare he have different opinions than you?! It's an outrage.

T_lynn4 on Dec 30, 2011


Now that's how a great list looks like! Finally 50/50 shows up. And even Crazy Stupid Love is there; I didn't think that was possible. But the honorable mentions could have easily made a great list on their own.

Anonymous on Dec 30, 2011


Ethan, you are without a doubt the best person on this site. Lovin the list.

Rops on Dec 30, 2011


had I not seen the muppet movie I too would make some idiotic comment, but I have to admit, it was damn good! I was never a muppet fan but the writing was right on and addressed everything that needed addressing. I saw this with my fiancee last night, no kids and still really enjoyed it. I would have to add "Tree of Life" to any list this year..

Lando on Dec 30, 2011


"attack the block" and "crazy stupid love" didn't make my top10 list (it's in jeremys article) but they were honorable mentions - both were good movies. of course these lists are subjective........but, for discussion - i have no problem with muppets, marilyn, submarine, or 50/50 in the slots you put them in. however - your top 4 are befuddling surprises to me. there is no way (in my thinking, of course LOL) that any of those are better or even as good as "take shelter" or "we need to talk about kevin".........you CAN'T leave those out of the top 4 (let alone the top 10) can you???

Anonymous on Dec 30, 2011


I did love Take Shelter, but these films just struck more of a chord with me. And I haven't seen We Need to Talk About Kevin yet, but I'm dying to.

Ethan Anderton on Dec 30, 2011


don't miss it - it's intense.

Anonymous on Dec 30, 2011


I was with you until Ides of March.  It was a good movie but for me it just blended in with everything else i saw this year.  But to each their own.   I was most impressed to see 50/50 on this list.  That may be in my top three for the year and hardly anyone saw it, and those who did aren't giving it much credit.  I thought it was a fantastically touching film though.

Aero027 on Dec 30, 2011


I agree with most of the list. I personally hated Like Crazy until the final 5-10 minutes of the movie though. I'd give the first 90% of the movie a 3 and the last 10% a 10. I wish the whole movie could've had as much emotion as the final scene. Just so you know where I stand Blue Valentine was my favorite movie last year by far

Rschaller15 on Dec 30, 2011


I have trouble respecting any 2011 list without Drive on it, but since you gave it an honorable mention, I'll accept it.  I have yet to see Like Crazy, Submarine, and My Week With Marilyn, but other than that its a pretty nice collection of movies.

Jordan Scott on Dec 30, 2011


Ill accept this list, but i just dont understand how "Shame" "Warrior" "Drive" or "Girl With The Dragon Tattoo" arent on it haha

John on Dec 30, 2011


I would've never guessed that My Week with Marilyn would be in a top ten, but I'll have to check it out now. I completely agree about crazy, stupid love, 50:50, The Ides of March, and Margin Call though.

Anonymous on Dec 30, 2011


Finally a top 10 list with Attack the Block on it.

The_Kid89 on Dec 30, 2011


Ethan is a (censored) idiot! These repetitive themes regarding his "best" list categories from 2011 with each new day proves it. This guy is getting paid to display his incompetence on a daily basis. He will always use the personal preference excuse to make up for his poor critique on movies and then tries to attack people who point out that fact in general. From now on, I'm only viewing posts from Alex or the rest of the Firstshowing staff, this guy is a Grade A wannabe.

ThaTruth on Dec 30, 2011


From someone who tries to show their "street cred" by spelling their name with an 'a', if I were Ethan I would take this post as a compliment. What part of "personal top 10" do you(and some others like you) not understand? These are HIS favorite movies. You didn't have to read the article, but you did and now you feel it's your duty to attack HIS personal choices? I don't agree about a couple of them, but that's what makes these lists fun: they start discussion. Unfortunately when cretins like you get involved, though, they stop being fun. So take your sh!tty attitude tha' otha' way. 

Scotty97 on Dec 31, 2011


 It seems like maybe you should take your own advice. Though it is a bit extreme, it is his opinion on the article. I happen to disagree with this list as well but I'm not as verbal as others. You became the proverbial pot calling the kettle black when you rushed to the author's defense, attacking someone's point of view, no matter how extreme it is. I'm sure Ethan is a big boy and doesn't need you rushing to his defense every time someone disagrees with him. You get no brownie points for kissing ass on a movie website. So you and Truth are both idiots in the end but at least he's not contradicting himself. Have a happy new year and seek professional help.

Tk421 on Dec 31, 2011


Can't wait to see My Week With Marilyn! I have yet to see a couple of films to make a definitive 2011 list, but I agree there were a lot of great movies this year 🙂 I have to disagree with you on Ryan Gosling in Ides, I thought he was better in Drive, but maybe that's just me.. Drive and Melancholia are my two faves so far! Midnight is up there and 50/50 was a pleasant surprise indeed. Glad to see Super 8 and Apes at least getting mentioned, loved those!

Davide Coppola on Dec 31, 2011


my ten favorites would have to be,in no particular order -true grit -black swan -source code -warrior -the fighter -rise of the planet of the apes -drive -another earth -thor -captain america the first avenger

the driver on Dec 31, 2011


You just picking movies you saw this year? Because two of those are from 2010 my friend.

Anonymous on Dec 31, 2011


whats your point ?? its not like he can give an opinion on movies he didnt see. 

Anonymous on Jan 1, 2012


Actually, three are 🙂 I guess he lives in Europe, like me, and hadn't had the chance to see them untill 2011. That's probably the reason why movies that came out in october-december 2012 aren't on this list, I expect some of them in his list of next year!

Steven Fivez on Jan 2, 2012


Nice you included Another Earth and Drive!

Steven Fivez on Jan 2, 2012


Ugh I wanted to like Ides of March so bad. It looks great and it was acted wonderfully but I just found it so boring. I guess I need to see "My Week With Marylin" it does look good but I never really had any interest in seeing it but with it landing everyone's top 10 makes me curious.

Anonymous on Dec 31, 2011


I dont get why people get so bend out of shape for the 'whatever' top ten list. Like everything on the net, its always nothing more then someones opinion. Just like i have never understood why people need to 'review' movies, music etc...it's all irrelevant in the end. Imagine we all like the same stuff??

Buzzfunk on Dec 31, 2011


while Attack the Block is my #1 this year (IT WAS SO FUN!) i disagree with every other movie on this list. but to each his own

Anonymous on Dec 31, 2011


see "thatruth", this is what a constructive criticism looks like. Respectful but in disagreement. 

Scotty97 on Dec 31, 2011


My personal top 10: 10: Super 8   9: Thor   8: The Muppets    7: My Idiot Brother(Paul Rudd continues to shine)   6: The Descendants   5: The Flowers of War   4: Captain America(classy comic book movie with solid acting, if not the best         script)   3: Melancholia   2: The Tree of Life(I can't believe this isn't on more lists)   1: 50/50(Struck a very personal chord with me, and I related to the characters a             lot)   And again, these are my personal favorites. Not the movies I feel should change the world and be everyone's favorites. 

Scotty97 on Dec 31, 2011


Two Marvel movies on one list? There are two films on here I'd allow but the rest of the list is scrap. Did you not see Drive or Warrior? I know you're not trying to change the world with this list but don't destroy it either.

FilmFreak82 on Dec 31, 2011


My top ten are as follows:10- X-Men:First Class 9-War Horse 8-Tinker,Tailor,Soldier,Spy 7-Take Shelter 6-Warrior 5-Drive 4-Mission Impossible:Ghost Protocol 3-Carnage 2-Shame 1-The Artist

Sherlong2010 on Dec 31, 2011


ides of march felt like a remake of Primary colors( i hope that was the name) with John Travolta, Billy bod Thorton and Kathy bates.

Anonymous on Jan 1, 2012


i cant post a top 10 list as i honestly dont think i went to the movies 10 times this year(including DVD's) The Adjustment Bureau  is my #1 though.

Anonymous on Jan 1, 2012


Great list man! I'm glad someone else liked/saw "The Beaver" besides me and my ex gf! Haha. That and seeing "Warrior" in your runner ups is awesome. That film seriously received NO attention and I think it's one of the damn finest sports films I've ever seen. Well I might as well list my top 10 since I'm here. 1) Warrior 2) Shame 3) Melancholia 4) 50/50 5) Drive 6) I Saw The Devil 7) Like Crazy 8) The Descendants 9) Bellflower 10) Source Code

Drew on Jan 3, 2012


1- Warrior 2- Who cares...

Mister Y on Jan 5, 2012


Let's not forget Cedar Rapids . . .

Mike on Jan 10, 2012


Like Crazy was impeccable. A lovely film and definitely worth 2nd spot. 

Tarhna on Feb 5, 2012

New comments are no longer allowed on this post.



Subscribe to our feed -or- daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main account on twitter:
For the latest posts only - follow this one:

Add our updates to your Feedly - click here

Get the latest posts sent in Telegram Telegram