SXSW Review: 'The Beaver' is Full of Honesty, Emotion and Deftness
by Jeremy Kirk
May 5, 2011
For the limited opening of The Beaver this weekend, we are re-posting Jeremy's full review from SXSW.
Walter Black (Mel Gibson's character in The Beaver) has issues. Husband, father, and head of a toy manufacturing company, he suffers from severe depression, so much so, in fact, that he has alienated his family from any real connection. Walter is at the end of his rope, or tie, quite literally when he stumbles upon a stuffed puppet, a beaver, laying in a dumpster. Walter takes the puppet and begins communicating through it to his family and colleagues. He sees the puppet and his voice through it as the only way to communicate, to create that bond with the familiar world around him that he has long since lose.
The Beaver, directed by Jodie Foster, is a film that will lose audiences pretty much from the concept level. It asks a lot of the viewer just as Walter asks a lot of those he interacts with through the beaver. It's a premise that is sure to divide potential audiences, and the film goes in directions that are sure to divide viewers even more. However, The Beaver, not exactly the lighthearted family drama one might be expecting going in, is a phenomenal story of one man's disconnect from his own world as well as his sanity. It's a film about mental illness and presents a much darker tale when all is said and done than what is first anticipated. Nonetheless, Kyle Killen's screenplay is remarkably inventive and firm, Foster's execution is spot-on, and Mel Gibson's lead performance is absolutely breathtaking.
The first element you notice in The Beaver that takes it up several notches is Walter's inability to even speak to his family. Save for voiceover narration in the beginning, in which Gibson introduces us to his "Beaver" voice - we'll get to that momentarily - we don't even hear the character speak a line of dialogue until he has found the puppet, hit rock bottom, and begins his bond with this inanimate object.
It's all a dark subject matter when you think about it. Walter is mentally ill. He is painfully depressed. However, Foster's direction and Killen's script don't keep it from ever being funny. There's a situational comedy that stems from Walter talking to his family with the puppet. It's not so much the filmmaking fun of the character or his mentality. Far from it, but the puppet brings the character to life, and you begin to get a taste of how uplifted and charismatic this man once was before the darkness set in.
The puppet itself is a big factor in this, too. It truly is a separate character in The Beaver, even though it's just a stitched up puppet with staring eyes and buck teeth. The design of the puppet is where its liveliness begins but it's heavily aided by the way Gibson works it and Foster shoots it. The puppet's head moves around, observing Walter's world, even slowly rising behind objects as if waking from a nap. More than a few times Foster shoots the puppet in focus leaving Walter in soft focus behind it. It forces you to watch the beaver as its own character rather than just an extension of the film's protagonist, and that goes a long way in selling the audience on the premise.
But it's not all Walter's story here. Foster plays Meredith, Walter's wife, and Anton Yelchin plays Porter, his son, with solidity. Porter is a character who doesn't understand his place in the world. He hates his father, yet he finds himself acting more and more like him. The hole he is slowly punching through his bedroom wall with his forehead presents concepts of both escape and frustration, and Yelchin delivers the performance with a tight grip. The subplot involving Porter's relationship with a fellow student played by Jennifer Lawrence seems there to give him one more reach to the outside world but little else.
But it's Gibson who really shines in The Beaver. Nuance and pain brimming in his eyes and every wrinkle in his face, the actor firmly grips the mental state of his character here. It's not a highly original idea Gibson playing someone with mental problems, but the actor finds fresh and powerful ways of making you sense you've hardly seen it before. That's not even getting into the masterful way he works the puppet and gives it its Ray Winstone-esque voice. Gibson is subdued and thoughtful about his role up until the tonal shift, the moment when we realize what we thought was "rock bottom" earlier could even get worse for Walter. It's in those later moments when Gibson is able to go full Riggs, come out of the proverbial shell, and make Walter's true voice heard.
It's those later moments that are sure to divide viewers greatly (as it already has). A darkness presents itself that you didn't see coming, but it never feels depressive for the sake of being depressive. Killen's script has something definite to say about mental illness, resulting in outbursts of emotion both good and bad.
The Beaver ends up being not about one man's therapy that helps him recreate his bond with the world but a much more deep-rooted tale of one man being held hostage by his own mental state. It's about buildings that can only rise after the rubble of a disaster has been cleared, the bonds that can only be formed by pushing through and allowing the ones you love to shape them. The shift in The Beaver is where it may lose even more viewers than from the premise alone, but it's at that moment when the film solidifies itself as being truly great, staggeringly emotional and abjectly beautiful. The Beaver has a voice, and what it has to say is something magnificent.
Jeremy's SXSW Rating: 9 out of 10
wow i forgot about this movie...now i REALLY want to see it...thanks for the review
Jericho on Mar 17, 2011
People can fault him for some of the comments he's made, which is understandable, but you cannot fault him for being a damn good actor! Very nice review btw!
Cruzer on Mar 17, 2011
I'm probably going to love this flick because I've read a few other things that Killen has done, and the guy is good. Damn good. Almost everything he's written has the same sort of elements that The Beaver has, in that you hear the premise and you think "there's no way in hell that could work", and then the guy weaves his magic and makes it not only work, but work amazingly well. I can only hope that Spike Jonze gets a hand on one of his scripts. That would be amazing.
Anonymous on Mar 17, 2011
I always separate the person from the actor and Gibson is a damn good actor! So, he blew his lid, who doesn't! I think he's making it out ok. All tings considered, Mel really doesn't seem that bad (not that I believed all the crap to begin with). It's apparent that America has focused their attention to another individual who makes Gibson look really good......"duh, winning".
Spider on Mar 17, 2011
The Beaver, directed by Jodie Foster, is a film that will lose audiences pretty much from the concept level. In other words it won't appeal to Transformer type audience because it requires the viewer to have a brain.
Sanka on Mar 17, 2011
So everyone that liked Transformers is a moron? I liked the first Transformers and I'm a computer scientist.I also like Citezan Kane,Bladerunner and the last Hulk movie but I wouldn't be so dumb as to confuse them all with each other.
tir na nog on Mar 17, 2011
Flcl on Mar 19, 2011
Apparently 6 people do.
Cody W. on May 6, 2011
7 people do.
Xerxexx on May 6, 2011
Sanka has a point. Also like Flcl said "who cares?" Transformers fans usually have no brain or care for a good/decent plot. They just aw over girls and Micheal Bay explosions. We didn't need your life story.
InkyPinkyBlinkyandClyde on May 6, 2011
Mel Gibson .. That's all I need to entice me to see it.
Hattori Hanzo on Mar 17, 2011
I was in from the get go.
Anonymous on Mar 17, 2011
i'd go see it, but mel gibson would have to blow me first.
Kittycat10 on Mar 17, 2011
JL on Mar 17, 2011
Haha, fuck I love FS, no other movie blog like you guys.
Cody W. on May 6, 2011
Is gonna be interesting: in one hand you have a good film with strong characters, good acting and Jodie Foster directing. In the other hand, you have all the hate towards Mel Gibson from a lot of the moviegoers (I know no jewish fan of Gibson). Which one will prove mightier at the box office result?
Leinergroove on Mar 18, 2011
Mel! you were a little hard on the Beaver last night!
Anonymous on Mar 18, 2011
Mel Gibson might have joined Tom Cruise and Charlie Sheen in the Nut Bar, but he is still Mel, and that's why I will always watch his movies. Too bad that he and Danny Glover won't do Shane Black's Lethal Weapon 5. It sounded really good.
Last Son on Mar 18, 2011
I would DIE for another Leathal movie. I thought 4 was just terrible but 1-3 all always on high rotation here... love them. "Red wire? I thought you said blue" "hmm I did, didn't I?"
Anonymous on May 6, 2011
I liked this review, I cannot wait for this film. Looks amazing.
Guy on Mar 18, 2011
Is this Lethal Weapon 5?
mr. joshua on Mar 19, 2011
wow glad it got 9/10 looked really good from trailers
A5J4DX on Mar 19, 2011
I really want to see this and now reading your beautiful review more than ever!
David Perretta on May 6, 2011
Love Mel. Looking forward to this film.
LEE on May 7, 2011
New comments are no longer allowed on this post.