Fantastic Fest 2012: MGM's 'Red Dawn' Remake is Satisfying Enough
by Jeremy Kirk
October 4, 2012
Wolverines! Yes, it's what the 1984 actioner Red Dawn is most known for. Yes, it's a line that's repeated in remake. And yes, it's every bit as cheesy as you remember. Thankfully, that moment in all of its '80s haze of nostalgia is NOT indicative of the remake. This version of Red Dawn works around its hokier tropes—of which there are several—and delivers a nice blast of a film by way of family drama, which is continuously supported by a quite amazing troupe of young actors. The bad guy mixup is well documented and noticeable, but that too falls aside to let sheer enjoyable action entertainment take over. I repeat. Wolverines!
The image of dozens of parachutes deploying over our skies as part of an apparent invasion was always a haunting image from the original. It's an image overblown by CG here, the dozens turning into hundreds, but the intense feeling of dread still comes with it. This time around, the parachuted invaders are North Korean and the invaded territory is the rainy forests of Washington instead of Colorado. The dynamic is much the same. A group of teenagers hide out in the wilderness as they regroup and form plans to take back control of their hometown. Drama ensues among the group, particularly between two brothers who have lost their father in the invasion. Chris Hemsworth and Josh Peck play them in the remake.
Hemsworth and Peck play off each others role effectively, drawing the viewer into every sibling rivalry spat that builds up and explodes between them. There might not be the most likability to them at times, especially for Peck who's roped with the part of the brash, younger brother who always does things his way. But Peck's acting strength pushes through any amount of disconnection one might have with his character. Hemsworth once again steps in as leader of the group, and once again he knocks it out of the park taking charge of every scene and situation his character finds himself in. Giving him an Iraq War veteran backstory helps those emotional beats as well as the action pieces.
And this is where the Red Dawn remake works best. The action is effective enough with first-time director Dan Bradley working his way in and out of every set piece. Though at times its too shaky, remnants of a near-bygone era finding their way back into this film, which was actually shot in 2009. They were still employing the shaky cam technique like sync sound in those days, and Red Dawn is not a film that tried to shake that unwelcome trope. As rough as Bradley's cinematography is, there's still an understanding of how every action scene goes down. Unlike some action movies where it's a random, blurred image shooting at another, random, blurred image, you're able to follow the actors here. Of course, everyone they're shooting at is Chinese, and lengths aren't gone very far to get to know more than a few of them.
It all plays just like you expect it to, a few of the teens dying to keep the realism of the film's violence out in front of you. A few come out of nowhere, hitting a beat of shock like few films have been able to do recently. Unfortunately, the structure of the film allows for shocking moments and a fine, final set piece, but it all ends on such a whimper that the biggest shock of all is when the credits begin rolling. The ambiguity of the original's ending was well enough. There was still a finality to it, but the new film ends like the pilot episode of the "Red Dawn" TV series would end. As long as there's a new episode coming next week, it works fine. As a stand-alone, it's attempt to set up for a sequel is both jarring and undeserved.
This remake won't be going down in history as one of the great, war movies of all time. Not even the original Red Dawn holds that honor, but it does still work as satisfyingly engaging shoot-’em-up with enough heart to make all the flying bullets count. The same elements work with the remake, combining emotional storytelling with blockbuster action pieces, not all of them as interesting or as exciting as they should be, but well enough to keep you interested until the next one comes along. As Josh Hutcherson, another stand-out in the film's young cast, shouts the famous line, it's meant to strike a chord, to have the audience standing from their seats and applauding along with a sentiment of home-grown Americana. It doesn't quite pull that off, but the grin it puts on your face until another, decent, action set piece shows up is just enough.
Wolverines? Sure, why not.
Jeremy's Fantastic Fest Rating: 6.5 out of 10
Shit sandwich? Sure, why not. A punch to the balls? Sure, why not. Red Dawn 2012.
Bobo_Vision on Oct 5, 2012
I will watch to see Tanner Foust's driving.
DAVIDPD on Oct 5, 2012
The brothers weren't always fighting in the original and thus supported each other, with a far more realistic interpretation of being a brother. The notion of the shakey cam (which at last is getting dismissed for the pointless fad that it was - maybe 3D will be recognised for this soon) is enough to make it DVD only.
Payne by name on Oct 5, 2012
They should have had the balls to keep China as the main villains, with North Korea playing back-up the way that Cuba backed up Russia in the original. It's supposed to be a satire on the paranoia we felt about the doom that the Soviet Union supposedly always held over our heads. North Korea is a weak and pitiful country where outward appearance is where all their money goes. The trim uniforms and AK's the boarder guards sport is designed to demonstrate strength. What you don't see is their desperate food shortage, unbelievable poverty, and a slave driving government. Even the soldiers, who get food rations first above the rest of the population, are beginning to feel the effects of their food shortage. And if the soldiers are starving, you bet the people are suffering a lot worse. And, generally, I think a lot of us know that. If this is supposed to be a satire of our fears of North Korea, it missed. Any of you honestly afraid of a North Korean invasion? Do you think they have the planes, fuel, ships, or ANY kind of supplies to sustain an invasion? But China is a much different story, especially with China beefing up their navy and creating a missile capable of bypassing anti-air measures and wiping out aircraft carriers on a single hit. China is the fast rising economic powerhouse with the same government that crushes protests and gags free speech. They have the numbers, the resources, the military, and the overall power to actually launch an invasion. China is where the paranoia surrounds and should have been the focus of this movie. I can't imagine ticket sales in China making up for a lackluster villain. I think it would make more money in every other market had the enemy been China. But now studios don't have to worry about movie bans, since I'm sure North Koreans don't get to watch Hollywood movies anyway.
Guest on Oct 6, 2012
Just back from seeing it. Hokarific. If hoke were snow, we be shoveling for a month. The premise itself, surprisingly, ISN'T the first hoke. You see, the truth comes out in the movie that our old enemies, the Russkies helped. They seized the East Coast. The November Kilos grabbed the West Coast, and the center of the country is "Free America". No nukes in this one. Hoke #1: The new EMP weapon. Anyone who has been in the military knows all you have to do is ignite nuclear weapons in the atmosphere over a country and shazam, you fry all the unhardened circuits. Not new at all. Hoke #2: The Wolverines manage to do things even the original Wolverines didn't do. Like fire endless streams of rounds from their captured AKs and never change a magazine. Hoke #3: They get the jump on some former Marines from Free America. I don't care if a Marine is 90; if he can move, you don't get the jump on him. Crap gotta go. More hoke later.
Hokey-meter on Dec 3, 2012
Hoke #4: All the NorKors drive AMERICAN vehicles. Lots of 'em. Where did they come from? Hoke #5: Where was the National Guard? You mean to tell me that, even with the circuitry down for civilians, the NG guys didn't respond? Military stuff is hardened, EMP wouldn't affect it. And even so, why would the Guard simply just not show up? And then, there were plenty of civilian vehicles still moving. EMP would've burned up any with electronic ignitions. Hoke #6: The NorKors have nice new digital camo uniforms. The Russian Spetsnaz sitting in on the big meeting is wearing an old pattern. REAL old. Hoke #7: How did the Ilyushin 76 transports get to the States anyway? They are too big for aircraft carriers. They haven't the range to fly here on their own from NK. Hoke #8: I know the Company (that's the CIA) has been having its problems of late, but there's no way they miss a deployment of troops large enough to make a land invasion of the CONUS (CONtinental US). We should've been there waiting on them. If I can think of any more hokey things from the new RD, I'll post 'em. (Don't think I didn't like the movie. It has its great moments. I like realism in my war movies though and it was definitely missing here.)
Hokey-meter on Dec 3, 2012
New comments are no longer allowed on this post.
FOLLOW FS HERE
Follow Alex's main account on Twitter:
Add our posts to your Feedly › click here
Get all the news sent on Telegram
LATEST TO WATCH