Review: Rob Cohen Delivers an Ocean of Boredom with 'Alex Cross'
by Jeremy Kirk
October 19, 2012
It's not that James Patterson's original novels were great philosophical masterpieces. Director Rob Cohen and his screenwriting team weren't working with the deepest material when it came time to make Alex Cross, rebooting a franchise that began with Kiss the Girls and Along Came a Spider. Tyler Perry is no Morgan Freeman, either, but even with all of this working against this film, it still finds a way of shocking you with how utterly dull and uninteresting it all is. Matthew Fox's crazy eyes can't even bring entertainment to what ends up a lazy and numbing experience, but he is easily the best part. Read on!
Perry steps in as the title character, a homicide detective and criminal profiler who pulls clues out of the air and works them nicely into the case at hand. His latest involves an assassin working his way down a kill list. Cross and his team must track the killer down before he can complete his list, but the tables turn when the detectives find the cross-hairs aimed at them.
Yeah, that pretty much read like the inside flap of a James Patterson novel, and yeah it's pretty thin. The synopsis could have included some little tidbits about Cross wanting to move his family out of Detroit and into Washington DC, where an FBI job is waiting. Or it could have included some information about Cross' relationship with his wife, who has just made him privy to her pregnancy. All of that is development found in the film, but none of it factors in enough to add any real weight. The procedural of hunting down a sadistic hitman and the violence that ensues is the real bread-and-butter in Alex Cross, and its Cohen and his crack team of screenwriters to make that come off as interesting or, God forbid, exciting. They don't.
Nearly every aspect of Alex Cross is standard thriller chum, plot points and characters tossed without care into ever-deepening ocean of boredom. Patterson's novel, "Cross" - Which I haven't read, but I did read through a few Patterson novels at an age where I was only in the shallow end of storytelling - surely didn't have grand gestures of literature-making or deep crevasses of fully developed characters, but that's just an assumption. The screenplay for Alex Cross definitely doesn't, and darker moments come and go without even a tick on the emotion scale. One main character's demise is revealed via a photo and hardly even alluded to after. Evidently their character wasn't memorable enough to even mention in the third act. As it is the most notable character in the film becomes Fox's eyes. That's when the movie serves as a comedy.
And it works just as long as Cohen allows Fox to be as wacky, insane, psychotic, and any other technical terms for crazy that the actor chooses to be. It's the only area in the film where it seems Cohen makes the right choice, and it seems to just be a matter of leash-loosening he does for the actor. The rest of the film is loaded with the same point-and-shoot care that can be found in such classics as Stealth or The Mummy: Tomb of the Dragon Emperor, both former Cohen films and both much more intriguing than this one.
Action sequences pop up here and there, usually for little reason other than it's been about 15 minutes since the last one, and the director never seems to have a handle on how to capture it. An early MMA fight should have been touting the amazing hand-to-hand choreography the rest of the movie would offer, but it doesn't. Instead, Cohen shoots it like he does gunfights or car chases, with little thought in what needs to go up on the screen and even less care with if it works. It all might work a little better if it weren't so predictable, seemingly chopping up bits from other movies and supplanting them here for your entertainment. And if the action scenes here are awful, the depiction of the act of investigation is abysmal. Remember the "pulling clues from the air" line? That's no exaggeration.
It's left to Perry to make the investigation somewhat believable, and he tries so hard to get it right. It may come as a shock, but Tyler Perry is a good actor, and when he's working in his wheelhouse he seems to lose everything in his characters. However, Alex Cross is very much outside his wheelhouse, and what should come off as the pensive look of a genius working on a puzzle ends up looking more like a man trying to remember his lines. When Alex Cross does eventually get "crossed," that pensive look should turn to the determined stare of a man on a mission.
That only stare we're focused on at that point is Fox's abrasive gaze. We're also distracted by his emaciated appearance, like he's trying to give Christian Bale a run for his money in the "how much weight can I lose for a part" game. He ends up pulling off crazy acting on a level only meant for Nicolas Cage, and when Alex Cross is the "Sadistic Hitman Show," it's nearly a riot. "Nearly" is the important work there, and nothing in the rest of this meandering coloring book of famous detective stories comes close to matching the fun the actor seems to be having.
Cohen should have taken a few notes from how Fox handles the antagonist. At least then Alex Cross would have been entertaining as a colossal train wreck, the kind of movie that enjoyable only for the sake of laughing about it with a group of friends. As it stands, though, most of what this film delivers are moment after moment of drab suspense and even less colorful drama. Patterson's novels might have been - and probably still are - dime-thin, but the sheer number he's written and the popularity that's made that number possible give reason to believe they are at the very least entertaining. Someone should have let Rob Cohen and his team in on how to get some of that entertainment into their movie.
Jeremy's Rating: 3 out of 10
Reader Feedback - 13 Comments
Harsh! Definitely not going to waste my time! I enjoyed the other movies. But since its not Morgan Freeman, I wasn't going to give it a chance. Now I'm absolutely not!!!
MommyofThree on Oct 19, 2012
Saw it, Loved it!- best action movie of the year! almost as good as Taken 2, only thing that would have made it better is if it had superstars Taylor Lautner and Mehgan Fox, cant wait for Alex Cross 2!
Ashely on Oct 19, 2012
Almost as good as Taken 2? Which was garbage, enough said.
Brian Sleider on Oct 19, 2012
Can't tell if serious...
Phillip Gockel on Oct 19, 2012
careful, people tend not to get jokes
Jay on Oct 19, 2012
Yeah it was really an awesome movie, I liked it too much & can watch twice in a week.
james hitch on Oct 20, 2012
So Tyler Perry is no Morgan Freeman? So what? I haven't seen the movie, but intend to. Perry has never failed to excel at every role he's undertaken. I feel confident he won't disappoint his fans as Alex Cross. We've had to accept change of actors before, sometimes it works sometimes it doesn't. The first thing you have to do is not compare. Perry's Cross is going to be different than Freeman's. How could he not be. Two different men, but more important Cross himself has changed. He is in a different place in his life now. His priorities have changed. I never allow "critics" to make my decision on whether or not I see a movie. I'll go, I'll see, I'll decide. It is my personal opinion that most "critics" are over-paid wannabes anyway. (WC
JeffandWanda Camp on Oct 19, 2012
preach it brotha! Shitty movies need love to
richard on Oct 19, 2012
So lately you've only seen boring films between this and PA4.. Sucks..
Davide Coppola on Oct 19, 2012
Did anyone actually expect this to be good? Come on, wasted review
Cody W on Oct 19, 2012
It's completely fine that you didnt like the movie. I didnt have high expectations for it either, but if you're going to critique it, please make sure to proof read your article. I always assumed this site was fairly professional but I've read multiple articles from you as well as other writers on here and all I have to say is that proofreading your work once could potentially work wonders for your credibilty.
shouserr on Oct 19, 2012
This is exactly how i felt about dredd 3d, I will never understand the buzz about that movie on this website, i was fighting not to fall asleep
Hazedmind on Oct 20, 2012
When you realize in the beginning this movie had Idris Elba as Cross and David Twohy directing, it's obvious how shitty is now.... the producer is probably the biggest asshole in the business. Tyler Perry?.. Really? LOL
JAVIERQ on Oct 20, 2012
Sorry, new comments are no longer allowed.