What Does the Oscar Race for Best Animated Feature Look Like Now?

November 20, 2013

Monsters University

Never being met with the same respect as the other categories at the Academy Awards, the Best Animated Feature race is always one of the most interesting ones for to analyze and cover each year. This category is about as different from the others as it gets at the Oscars, so it's always worth a little bit of a different focus. It's also one of the harder ones to predict, especially when Pixar doesn't have a runaway frontrunner (which is becoming more normal now) in their prequel Monsters University. With the impending release of Frozen, the final contender for the prize, I wanted to discuss the category to see where the race is headed.

In case you aren't aware, depending on how many eligible animated features come out in a given year, that affects how many nominees there are. If at least 16 are deemed eligible, we get five spots. This year, there are 19 films in contention, so it appears that the full amount of slots will be in play. The cartoons submitted for 2013 are as follows: Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2, The Croods, Despicable Me 2, Epic, Ernest and Celestine, The Fake, Free Birds, Frozen, Khumba, The Legend of Sarila, A Letter to Momo, Monsters University, O Apóstolo, Planes, Puella Magi Madoka Magica the Movie – Rebellion, Rio: 2096 A Story of Love and Fury, The Smurfs 2, Turbo, and The Wind Rises. From those 19, we'll eventually get our five.

If you want to separate those flicks a bit, you can categorize them. Basically, Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2, The Croods, Despicable Me 2, Epic, Free Birds, Frozen, Monsters University, Planes, The Smurfs 2, and Turbo are the big studio contenders, with Frozen and Monsters University appearing to be locked in from there and basically co-frontrunners. Aside from them, the indie players are Ernest and Celestine, The Fake, Kumba, The Legend of Darila, A Letter to Momo, O Apóstolo, Puella Magi Madoka Magica the Movie – Rebellion, Rio: 2096 A Story of Love and Fury, and The Wind Rises. From there, The Wind Rises seems all but assured of a nod (and could be a dark horse winner too), so we essentially have three spots filled, which leaves 16 movies vying for those final two places at the table.

Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2

Which two will make it though? Well, it really depends on who you ask. If you peruse various Oscar predictions, you can see a wide variety of titles predicted in addition to the aforementioned trio of Frozen, Monsters University, and The Wind Rises, which is pretty prudent thinking. The two most popular predictions (and to be honest, these final two slots are just filler, as one of those three will win, but more on that later) seem to be The Croods and Ernest and Celestine. Earlier in the year Free Birds was predicted a lot (including by yours truly), but poor reviews have hurt it to the point where it's no longer in much of an enviable position at all. The other one that is at least somewhat strongly in play is the sequel Cloudy with a Chance of Meatballs 2, but it's probably behind the other filler contenders, give or take Free Birds.

Personally, I'm currently predicting (with at least a mediocre degree of confidence) the lineup to look like this: The Croods, Ernest and Celestine, Frozen, Monsters University, and The Wind Rises. From there, I think that unless the emotional vote for Hayao Miyazaki proves too compelling to resist and The Wind Rises wins it all, Walt Disney's phenomenal new princess flick Frozen is in the pole position to take the Oscar. It's still very early though, so don't take that to the bank or anything. After all, Monsters University is still a Pixar film, and that means a lot in this category.

It's worth noting that all three of those top contenders are Disney releases, so the Mouse seems poised to win again in this category. Hell, they also have Planes in play (though don't bet on that one getting nominated), so hypothetically four of the five ultimate nominees could come from Uncle Walt. It may not ultimately mean much (the same thing happened last year too), but it's just another bit of information to have at your disposal.

In the end, you should remember that we haven't even seen any of the precursors talk about this race yet, so a lot is still to be decided. I'm pretty confident that it's going to be the aforementioned three horse race, but it could turn out in any number of ways. Pay close attention to this one, as it could go down to the wire. It'll be fun to watch though, no doubt about that!

Find more posts: Awards, Editorial



Honestly, this has been a pretty rough year for animated features. I hope FROZEN wins because 1) I think it will be an honest to goodness good movie, and 2) It's an "original" film, where most of the others that were not terrible were sequels.

DAVIDPD on Nov 20, 2013


It definitely deserves it.

Joey Magidson on Nov 20, 2013


An original film... based on a book.

Guest on Nov 21, 2013


Loosely based, yes.

Joey Magidson on Nov 21, 2013


Hence the quotation marks.

DAVIDPD on Nov 22, 2013


Monsters University's art direction and animation are truly outstanding. Just a generally fantastic film, though still pales to Pixar's previous. I haven't seen Frozen but boy, that flick is getting good buzz. I despised Cloudy 2 and didn't care for The Croods. Who knows. From the sound of it Frozen has this in the bag, which I didn't think was possible, considering how annoying I found those trailers involving the snowman to be.

Tyler Scruggs on Nov 20, 2013


I didn't think so either, but having seen both, Frozen is heads and tails the better film...

Joey Magidson on Nov 20, 2013


With the reviews it's getting, I'd say Frozen is the likely winner.

ion677 on Nov 20, 2013


I'm one of those who've written an early rave, so I'm inclined to agree...

Joey Magidson on Nov 21, 2013


I'd agree that Frozen and Monsters University are locks, and I'd even go as far as to say that I think The Wind Rises is a sure bet too. The remaining slots are anybody's guess: they've gone both really mainstream and really obscure in the past, so who's to say.

mylesedwardhughes on Nov 20, 2013


Pretty much...

Joey Magidson on Nov 21, 2013


I'm rooting for Frozen!

Jess on Nov 20, 2013


You're definitely not alone there.

Joey Magidson on Nov 21, 2013


I'm rooting for Frozen and The Wind Rises, let's just hope the academy doesn't go with Pixar again, I mean it's Monsters University and not a bad movie, but last year Rise of The Guardians, Wreck-It-Ralph, and Frankenweeine deserved the oscar waaaaaaayyyyyy more than Pixar's Brave.

Fidel Reyes on Nov 21, 2013


I preferred Monsters University to The Wind Rises, personally, but Frozen knocks them both out of the water...

Joey Magidson on Nov 21, 2013


Haha I see what you're getting at I guess I'm just a Hayao Miyazaki fan rooting for his work, and don't get me wrong I am really into Pixar, I was a little kid when toy story came out and Andy's age when Toy Story 3 came out so I hold a special place in my life for Pixar, but I hope they don't win the Oscar, it wouldn't bother me but I think other movies deserve a shot too.

Fidel Reyes on Nov 22, 2013


Fair enough, no worries...

Joey Magidson on Nov 22, 2013


What was the last winner that wasn't kind of disappointing?

Kim on Nov 21, 2013


That would probably be Toy Story 3 for most...

Joey Magidson on Nov 21, 2013


Frozen does seem to be the favorite, but with The Wind Rises being Miyazaki last film and all... maybe?

Nielsen700 on Nov 21, 2013


That's the spoiler, yes...

Joey Magidson on Nov 21, 2013


i would love it if rebellion at least got a nomination, if not a win... i fear that it won't, given some of the other popular potential nominees/winners, but the animation and story were both spectacular and it would be a shame to see that ignored.

seaofstorms on Dec 10, 2013


The under the radar contenders certainly have a chance...

Joey Magidson on Dec 10, 2013


Madoka Rebellion definitely deserves a nomination. Even though it definitely won't win (that goes to either The Wind Rises or Frozen), It would be nice to at least SEE that the Academy thought it was good enough to be one of the contenders... plus, if we were just judging by animation alone, Rebellion would beat out Frozen any way (I think Frozen's animations is beautiful, but THIS: is just inpossible to beat, and that's just the first 3 minutes.)

Rachel on Jan 1, 2014


Meh, ever thought of the possibility that maybe critics didn't find Madoka as good as its fans thought? Ever thought of the idea that maybe it didn't deserve to be nominated?

Fernando Garcia on Apr 7, 2014

New comments are no longer allowed on this post.



Subscribe to our feed -or- daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main account on twitter:
For the latest posts only - follow this one:

Add our updates to your Feedly - click here

Get the latest posts sent in Telegram