Editorial: Why the 'Star Wars' Spin-Offs Should Avoid the Origin Story

September 22, 2015

Star Wars Spin-Offs

The Star Wars universe has untapped cinematic potential. Even though we've already seen six Star Wars films and a seventh is on the way, Lucasfilm has barely scratched the surface of the expansive universe that exists within the Star Wars mythology. This is undoubtedly why many are very excited for the first spin-off movie in the Star Wars pantheon, Rogue One (subtitled "A Star Wars Story"). The film aims to explore a ragtag group of Rebels and their attempt to steal the Death Star plans, acting as a prequel to A New Hope. However, even though Rogue One is a prequel, it's not necessarily an origin story. It's not about any one particular individual or how they came to be – and it's all the more better for it. With that said, let's explore why the upcoming Star Wars spin-offs should avoid the origin story approach altogether.

One could argue that the origin story first became popular in this modern era starting with Christopher Nolan's Batman Begins in 2005. Nolan successfully rebooted the Batman franchise with a movie that explored how Bruce Wayne became Batman, something that had not been done before in live-action. Nolan's attempt was to make Bruce Wayne as interesting as Batman – and it worked. However, the impetus for that creative decision partly came as a result of the Bruce Wayne character being fundamentally underdeveloped in the previous live-action movies. Batman Begins was really the first Batman film that was invested in both the Bruce Wayne persona just as much as the Batman persona, if not more so.

This approach had a huge impact on Hollywood. Soon enough, almost every popular franchise was rebooted with an origin story. James Bond got the reboot & origin story treatment with Casino Royale in 2006. The first Iron Man film, while not a reboot, was an origin story. The X-Men went back to the 1960's to explore how the X-Men came to be with X-Men: First Class in 2011. Even this summer 20th Century Fox tried to reboot the Fantastic Four with an origin story that was more grounded and realistic, echoing back to Nolan's Batman. J.J. Abrams, who would end up directing Star Wars: The Force Awakens, explored some of the origins of James T. Kirk and Spock in a relaunch of the Star Trek franchise.

Rogue One

However, after a decade of reboots and origin stories, it seems most audiences might be getting tired of exploring the "how the hero came to be" storyline. When Sony and Columbia rebooted Spider-Man for the second time in ten years with The Amazing Spider-Man, many fans sighed in annoyance. "I have to sit through the origin story again? I just saw this." This might explain why Marvel Studios and Sony are avoiding the origin story for the third cinematic reincarnation of Spider-Man in thirteen years. They heard the fans and they listened. It might be a good idea for Lucasfilm to listen to some passionate Star Wars fans who might not want to endure seeing two hours of how Boba Fett came to be, for example, especially since most of his backstory was covered in Attack of the Clones. Do we really need to see his origin story again?

Boba Fett is a noteworthy example because rumors are circulating Lucasfilm is developing a Boba Fett spin-off movie – perhaps one that Josh Trank was scheduled to direct until he left the project earlier this year. Now, one could argue that Boba Fett works best as a mysterious loner and a supporting player rather than the star of his own film – much like how Wolverine works best when he's the loner sidekick and not leading the X-Men. However, if Lucasfilm is going to do a Boba Fett standalone movie, here is one thing they should consider: leave his origins alone. A lot of fans were annoyed with Boba Fett's backstory in Attack of the Clones and regardless one can safely say by exploring Boba Fett's origins it removed a lot of the mystery and allure of the character. Some characters work best – especially villains – when you don't know that much about them. Hannibal Lecter is more terrifying when he's just slithering behind a glass cell taunting FBI profilers. When you try to explain how he became a cannibal – like in Hannibal Rising – people seem to stop finding him all that interesting.

Take this fan-made film (via Vimeo) directed by Eric Demeusy called Star Wars: The New Republic Anthology. Even though it's only 90 seconds long, it acts as an ostensible teaser for a Boba Fett standalone film. What really makes the film or trailer stand out is how it positions Fett, having escaped the Scarlacc Pitt in which he fell into in Return of the Jedi. The trailer teases a story where Fett, having recently escaped the Pitt, takes on new adventures post-Jedi. The story potential there is practically limitless. Here you have unexplored cinematic material with a story focusing on Fett, most likely forgotten and left for dead, having to re-define himself as a bounty hunter for hire. Perhaps many in the galaxy don't fear him like they used to, so Fett must prove himself again if he wants to be valued as a bounty hunter in the galaxy. That seems a lot more interesting than a two hour origin story explaining the man behind the mask that we've seen before.

Quite frankly, Boba Fett is going to be a more interesting character the less we know about him. Audiences don't care about what makes him tick – they care more about what he does when he's ticked off. Bryan Fuller's "Hannibal" TV show is a great example of redefining a classic character but not ruining him by exploring the origins of how he came to be. When Hannibal begins, he is fully formed. The interesting aspect of the show is how he cunningly navigates Will Graham and those around him. In a similar sense, it would be interesting to see Fett react to a galaxy that has since forgotten about him, where he must prove himself worthy again, not a story where he doesn't really become Boba Fett until the end. That's what people come to see anyway – their favorite character, not a story of how they became their favorite character.

Boba Fett

According to the plot synopsis, Star Wars: The Force Awakens picks up some 30 years after Return of the Jedi ends. With the Expanded Universe being essentially ignored and with Lucasfilm president Kathleen Kennedy confirming the new films won't acknowledge those stories, that's 30 years of unexplored material that could make for some really interesting films. Chris Miller and Phil Lord are reportedly developing and will direct a Han Solo spin-off movie that will allegedly explore the origins of Han Solo – but why? People might argue Harrison Ford is a big reason why that character works and that argument has credence – even though Abrams' own Star Trek proved you can take iconic characters and reinterpret them with new actors – and it can work.

The Star Wars mythology is about to become a lot less unexplored on film, which means famous characters will likely get reinterpreted with new actors. Instead of exploring Solo's origins, what about that 30 year gap between Return of the Jedi and The Force Awakens? It might be difficult to find an actor that looks exactly like 30 year-old Harrison Ford, but de-aging digital technology has come a long way – Marvel's own Ant-Man proved that earlier this year. If you can de-age an actor, you can certainly use prosthetics or CGI to make someone look like a middle-age Harrison Ford.

Regardless, if Lord & Miller do tackle a Han Solo story in his earlier years, hopefully it doesn't painstakingly explore Solo as a child – the last thing fans want to see is another Jake Lloyd fiasco. It would be more interesting if Han Solo was already a space pilot trying to make his way into the universe. You could even explore how he first comes across Chewbecca, but the last thing fans probably want to see is Solo and Chewy meeting in elementary school. However, a story where a young Han Solo, Chewy and maybe even Lando Calrissian get into trouble and explore the galaxy? That could be interesting. You don't need to explain how Han Solo came to be in order to tell a story about Solo in his younger years – and that's what I hope filmmakers like Lord & Miller take into consideration when developing their spin-off movies.

After all, the stories that you could tell in the Star Wars universe are practically limitless and don't need to rely on exploring how every popular Star Wars character came to be in order for them to be successful or thematically interesting. Sure, you could tell an Obi-Wan Kenobi origin story – or you could explore the 20-30 year time gap between Revenge of the Sith and A New Hope, focusing on an aging Obi-Wan who tries to avoid detection and looks over a young Luke Skywalker. The story could even take a page out of The Clone Wars and feature the return of a fan favorite – Darth Maul, who could help Darth Vader in destroying the rest of the Jedi. How cool would a Ronin type story be featuring Ewan McGregor as Obi-Wan again and one of Star Wars' coolest but most underdeveloped villains? The possibilities are about as endless as the stars in the Star Wars galaxy… or rather, galaxies. Do you agree the Star Wars spin-offs should avoid the origin story? What do you want to see in the spin-offs? Sound Off in the comments below!

Find more posts: Editorial, Star Wars

Discover more around the web:

Reader Feedback - 32 Comments


who cares if it's an origin story or not. just make good movies. it ain't rocket science.

cg on Sep 22, 2015


quiet...origin stories are bad because the internet says so

Ssssssss on Sep 22, 2015


This article is downright important. I want to nail it to Disney's front door, Ninety-Five Theses style.

Steve on Sep 22, 2015


Origin stories are usually disappointing endeavors. New fresh stories about new characters in the SW universe are what I'd love to see.

Xerxexx on Sep 22, 2015


There are many examples of where they are not

Ssssssss on Sep 22, 2015


There is so much to explore but it's essential i think the stories overlap like the marvel universe. I always like cameo's from other characters in a universe. Origins story's can be told onley if they have a good angle, but onley if it's good. Personally I can't imagine rogue one will be a hit, it looks odd in a lightsaber and Jedi universe, but maybe they have great story. Darth maul i would definitely want to see, but it must be realy badass and i think it can't be done with a low pg rating....

ari smulders on Sep 22, 2015


The original Star Wars barely had any lightsabers in it...there's a ton more to the universe than lightsabers and Jedi's

cg on Sep 22, 2015


I disagree. Lightsabers, Jedi's and the mythology are the keypoint of Star Wars.

ari smulders on Sep 22, 2015


No they are not. Clearly you've never seen A New Hope. We see lightsabers for about 30 seconds and the word Jedi is used 2 or 3 times. You have no clue what you are talking about.

Ssssssss on Sep 22, 2015


haha! And you are???? Show me your credentials and i will accept you as my guide in the Star Wars universe. If you don't get that the Jedi mythology is the basis of Star Wars you are a fool and worth talking with.. Look at the latest trailers and you will get it....

ari smulders on Sep 23, 2015


No way they'll ever do Darth Maul as a movie. Let's see a r-rated Darth Maul Netflix series like Punisher and Daredevil.

bumboclot on Sep 23, 2015


that would be awesome indeed!

ari smulders on Sep 24, 2015


I think what makes Boba Fett so interesting is that we know so little about him. We don't even know what his face looks like (shut up about Attack of the Clones)! For all we know, his nose was bitten off by a womprat on some far off planet. Shedding too much light on him, might actually tarnish the character....also his "death" in Return of the Jedi was pretty undignified and comical. Do we need a movie where he's trying to redeem himself and reestablish his reputation as a badass? So many possibilities, but also so many chances to make a terrible movie.....

TheOct8pus on Sep 22, 2015


I totally agree! First on the screw Attack of The Clones version, he can look like whatever, i don't care! Better yet just have him keep the helmet on the whole time like in the new Judge Dredd movie. Would be neat to see a Boba Fett film where we really get to see him cut loose!

BNN667 on Sep 22, 2015


Dan - you seem to forget that we had a Star Wars spinoff back in 1984 entitled "The Ewok Adventure". You can't ignore it now. That shit's canon.

TheOct8pus on Sep 22, 2015


I would not mind them making the origin stories. I would just like them to be of the more abstract characters. Boba Fett is the one most fans would like because his roguish nature in the films and expanded universe (now disqualified). All that really matters is that they make the damn thing well. Good director and a good writer.

DAVIDPD on Sep 22, 2015


I feel like with Fett, they could do something Fury Road-esque. Where Fett is the titular character (like Mad Max), but his role is not the focus of the film, but rather everything around him. He'd still be a draw for the audience, but we wouldn't have to get into any BS about who he is, where he's from, etc. He could remain mysterious and still be badass. Boba Fett: Fury Road

michaelscott on Sep 22, 2015


I was thinking more of a Rom-Com with Boba Fett and that chick with the tentacles growing out of her head .

TheOct8pus on Sep 23, 2015


Actually I think the prequels were what started the "origin story" craze.

Bounty 4 Zuckuss on Sep 22, 2015


Biggest complaint is that with Disney owning SW we will never get a Sith-side story.

Xerxexx on Sep 22, 2015


ok...and you know this how?

Ssssssss on Sep 22, 2015


Disney caters to children. No way would they allow a movie based on a sith remaining a sith and not redeeming themselves.

Xerxexx on Sep 23, 2015


What's wrong with a redemption story?

OfficialJab on Sep 23, 2015


Nothing, I love a good tale of redemption...but I wanna see a legit sith stay sith and dominate not redeem himself.

Xerxexx on Sep 23, 2015


disney has arguably the best villain back catalogue ever! so this comment holds no water

angel figueroa on Sep 22, 2015


Of all Disney villains I've yet to see a film based soley on the villian being a villian throughout. Usually its a redemption tale.

Xerxexx on Sep 23, 2015


I'm just here to say that I love Star Wars, and this is an exciting time for me. Thank you for listening, carry on.

grimjob on Sep 22, 2015


In response to the notion that they might be able to find a younger looking Harrison Ford to play a younger Han Solo, either for the years between Ep.3 and 4, or between Ep.6 and 7, I doubt they will find someone who can act the way Harrison does. I say that, because Harrison has a way about him that no matter the role, he seems to both fit the roll, and still be the same (if that makes sense). To me, Indy Jones was Han Solo in a hat. Deckard was Solo as a 21st century cop. Air Force One was Han Solo as the president. Get my drift? He is a good actor and can do many different types of roles, but it's still Harrison Ford and what he brings to each and every roll can't be duplicated by a younger actor who simply looks a bit like him. I'd rather have someone who looks nothing like him that has the same acting style take on the role, but that's a stretch as well. De-aging, like Michael Douglas in ANT-MAN? Sounds good, but you'd have to convince Harrison to sign on for one or more new movies to act in, or at least do the voice acting with some Andy Serkis type with white bubbles all over his head doing the physical acting part, which also makes little sense. I am really wanting a Han Solo adventure movie, and don't need it to be an origin story. I read a book of short stories written in the early 90's about a few Solo and Chewie smuggling adventures that took place in the few years leading up to A New Hope, those could make a great movie, and as much as Harrison would be missed, a quality actor who can pull off the Han charactier would be better that a simple look alike. Dissertation over LOL

theslayer5150 on Sep 23, 2015


Good point. That's why I'm nervous whenever someone mentions a standalone Han Solo movie. There's only one person who can play Han Solo and he's too old to play him like he used to. I heard rumors about that dude, Anthony Ingruber (Youtube Han Solo imitating sensation) getting the part, but like you said, it would just be an imitator/lookalike and he wouldn't have the "soul" that Harrison Ford brought to his early films. They should just stick with new, original, expanded universe stories....

TheOct8pus on Sep 23, 2015


Somehow I doubt the Batman origin story would have existed if not for the Spider Man origin story - both as a plot and as a viable box office performance. The only thing that really makes the "origin story" rehash so boring is the lack of creativity. I have seen Spiderman get his powers and geek out WAY too many times (not to mention that whole high school nerd with powers thing was already perfected with Teen Wolf). I have seen Bruce Wayne lose his parents about 40 different times. Even Superman has had another origin. Throw in Ant-Man and every other Marval character and you have a whole lot of repetition! I don't care though because Solo is not a super hero! The story of a smuggler and his run ins with Jabba the Hutt, his relationship with Lando, how he met Chewie... alll of these plotlines make for a superior movie to any super hero origin story!

bumboclot on Sep 23, 2015


who directed this short/teaser... well done

shane willett on Sep 24, 2015



chris on Sep 30, 2015

Sorry, new comments are no longer allowed.




Alex's Top 10 - 2020
1. Nine Days
2. Berlin Alexanderplatz
3. Pixar's Soul
4. Pieces of a Woman
5. Feels Good Man
6. Another Round
7. The Truffle Hunters
8. Sound of Metal
9. Lovers Rock
10. Nomadland
Click Here for Thoughts

Adam's Top 10 - 2020
1. Spontaneous
2. Promising Y. Woman
3. Nomadland
4. The Vast of Night
5. Blow the Man Down
6. The Invisible Man
7. Minari
8. Possessor
9. Feels Good Man
10. Color Out of Space
Click Here for Thoughts


Subscribe to our feed or daily newsletter:
Follow Alex's main profile on twitter:
For the latest posts only, follow this acct:

Add FS.net to your Feedly list: click here