EDITORIALS
Here Are 7 Actors to Consider for Marvel & Sony's New Spider-Man
by Ethan Anderton
February 10, 2015
In case you haven't heard by now, the character of Spider-Man is now being shared by Marvel Studios & Sony Pictures. Your friendly neighborhood wallcrawler will now be part of Marvel's Cinematic Universe appearing in a Marvel Studios release in the next couple years and will begin a new franchise of his own beginning on July 28th, 2017. And because this is a new Spider-Man, it has been confirmed that Andrew Garfield is no longer suiting up as Spidey, creating a major opportunity for an actor to gain superhero status. And I've rounded up my favorite picks as to who I would like to see shooting web around NYC now.
To set the stage here, I'm of the mind that Spider-Man should skew younger, if only to create some extra differentiation between Peter Parker (or maybe Miles Morales), and the rest of The Avengers who range from Chris Evans, Chris Hemsworth and Scarlett Johansson in their 30s to, Mark Ruffalo and Jeremy Renner in their 40s, to Robert Downey Jr. at 50 and Samuel L. Jackson in his 60s. Aaron Taylor-Johnson and Elizabeth Olsen join the Marvel scene in The Avengers: Age of Ultron, and both stars are in their mid 20s, so perhaps finding someone in their late teens or early 20s (or who looks that young) is the best move.
But age isn't the only important factor. You want to find someone who's charming, believable as being a bit of a geek and also a legitimate superhero. He has to have solid comedic timing, but good dramatic chops to match everyone else in the Marvel Cinematic Universe. So taking all those things into consideration, as well as my own feelings, these are the 7 young actors I think would be best for the job:
Nick Robinson
After starring in the indie darling The Kings of Summer in 2013, the soon-to-be 20-year old actor rode that wave to a key supporting role in Jurassic World as well as the forthcoming young adult sci-fi The Fifth Wave with Chloe Moretz. He's charismatic, proved he has what it takes to lead a movie with the aforementioned Sundance selected comedy, and already has some blockbuster experience.
Thomas Mann
The young star of party movie Project X and supporting star of Beautiful Creatures is coming off an astounding breakthrough performance in the Sundance 2015 award winning comedic drama Me and Earl and the Dying Girl, and if his turn in that indie doesn't prove that he has what it takes to be Spider-Man, then I don't know what will. Mann delivers a touching, genuine, funny and powerful leading performance, and this could be his chance at super stardom overnight.
Dylan O'Brien
Though he already has his own franchise with The Maze Runner, when something like Spider-Man comes along, especially being part of the Marvel cinematic universe, that's something else entirely. O'Brien has dabbled in action and comedy (The Internship), proving to be a solid talent in both arenas. He also has the right kind of natural attitude to be the smart-ass kid that we all know Spidey can be. Of course, considering how fast The Maze Runner sequels are coming together, he may not have room in his schedule.
Anton Yelchin
Here's another familiar face to fanboys as the young Chekov in the Star Trek franchise reboot from J.J. Abrams. But beyond that blockbuster work, Yelchin has taken on a variety of genre fare, both good and bad, including Terminator Salvation, Fright Night and Odd Thomas. But beyond that, Yelchin has shown tremendous dramatic work in films such as Like Crazy, Rudderless and The Beaver. The actor skews a little older for what I think would make the perfect new Spider-Man, but he still has the young looks and personality to pull it off.
Donald Glover
Hey, after he was buzzed about all over the internet when The Amazing Spider-Man was trying to find its leading man, why not reconsider the guy who got fans in a tizzy over potentially coming the first black Spider-Man on the big screen? It doesn't even matter whether this iteration of Spider will again be Peter Parker or Miles Morales, because I don't see any problem with Glover playing both. He's got everything we could ask for for a Spider-Man and his alter ego, and there's no doubt that even though Black Panther is one the way, the Marvel cinematic universe could still use some diversity.
Ansel Elgort
After making waves in The Fault in Our Stars, the charming actor followed Shailene Woodley over to The Divergent Series, though his role wasn't too meaty in the first film. It looks like he'll have a more pivotal part in the sequels, which might keep him out of the running, but Elgort certainly fits the bill to be Spider-Man. And it would be a little fortuitous for Elgort to shoot web around NYC considering Woodley was supposed to play the new Mary Jane in The Amazing Spider-Man franchise.
Iko Uwais
All right, this one is a little far out there since I have no idea how well the Indonesian actor from The Raid series speaks English in order to take on a major role in an American movie. But the thought of someone with the action skills, speed and ferocity of Iko Uwais putting on the Spider-Man suit gets me so excited. Uwais is the oldest out of this bunch (turns 32 this week), but he certainly looks young, and he's absolutely fit enough to take on a role like this. But again, because of his lack of experience in English-language films, I don't know if he can pull it off. But hey, we can at least let him do the stunt work as Spider-Man, right?
So those are my picks for who I would like to see get the role of the new Spider-Man. As for some actors that I really don't want to see get the role, Jaden Smith would be at the top of my list, and he's probably the only one that wouldn't make me happy. Logan Lerman seems like a pretty bland choice, but he wouldn't be terrible. Josh Hutcherson isn't a bad idea, but something just doesn't feel right about his casting in the role. Honestly, it's a shame that Andrew Garfield ended up on the raw end of this deal, because he was easily the best part of The Amazing Spider-Man franchise, right along with Emma Stone and their chemistry. Anyway, let's hear from you. Do you like my choices? Who do you want to see as Spider-Man?
98 Comments
1
Did up my own list of actors as well! http://moviepilot.com/posts/2015/02/10/confirmed-andrew-garfield-will-not-be-spider-man-in-marvel-s-cinematic-universe-here-are-5-actors-who-could-take-his-place-2678939?lt_source=external,manual Seems Dylan O'Brien is the current favorite among fan casted shortlists.
Tim Gonzales on Feb 10, 2015
2
Of this list, I think Dylan O'Brien is best suited for Peter Parker. As for Miles Morales, I think Glover is way too old now. But I'm sure there are a ton of young unknown Disney Channel actors I'm not aware of that could play Miles Morales.
CoosCoos on Feb 10, 2015
3
Please no Glover, not because he's black because I cant stand him. I like Anton though.
Jon Odishaw on Feb 10, 2015
4
u really had to throw in the "not because he's black"?
cg on Feb 10, 2015
5
Well yea Peter Parker isn't black to my knowledge
Jon Odishaw on Feb 10, 2015
6
mike morales is though...
mindie on Feb 11, 2015
7
MILES Morales.
R3last on Feb 17, 2015
8
It was a good point. Since there has been quite a shitstorms in messing with character ethnics. Not because racism, but just because its not true to original chararacter...
ProjectionistHP on Feb 10, 2015
9
Cancel Fantastic 4 and bring in Miles Teller.
Al Apone on Feb 10, 2015
10
I really hope you are joking.
Angry Lester on Feb 10, 2015
11
Pee Wee Herman all the way!
TheOct8pus on Feb 10, 2015
12
Anyone but Nick Robinson, he is just a pretty face who can't act. Thomas Mann has my vote.
Zack Snyder on Feb 10, 2015
13
You really think he Carnot act ur such an ass hole go watch Jurassic world shit head
Becky on Aug 9, 2015
14
Why?? It's not the acting that killed the last movie, it's the writing and directing!!
Angry Lester on Feb 10, 2015
15
I'm definitely thinking a younger Parker would be better for once.
OfficialJab on Feb 10, 2015
16
i am voting for harry shum here. i think it would be nice to switch it up on folks completely
thisguyhere on Feb 10, 2015
17
i think that'd be amazing because he honestly has amazing reflexes and could totally do it.
mindie on Feb 11, 2015
18
Uko speaks next to no English.....
Charles Oosterhouse on Feb 10, 2015
19
Iko from Asia, Spiderman from Western. Dylan O'Brien is good actor, he is funny and attractive
Prince on Feb 11, 2015
20
iko ,english is not very good but he was awesome in action movie from indonesian girl
Apriyanti on Sep 25, 2015
21
I'd love to see them have Spidey show up in-suit for the MCU film, only to remove his mask at the end of the film (or in an after credits scene) to reveal that he's Latino. Then have the new reboot pick up with a quick Miles Morales back-story/origin flashback so everyone who was confused by the reveal is up to speed, then continue on for the film with an actual story.
Jedi on Feb 10, 2015
22
Out of this list the only one I'd be remotely interested in seeing as Spiderman is Anton Yelchin but to be honest none of these jump out at me as being a decent choice. I don't want to see anything remotely close to an origins story for the new Spidey film so having a slightly older actor portray him in the MCU would be a better choice in my opinion.
izakkson on Feb 10, 2015
23
None of the above. Nothing against any of them, but for the sake of the fans just join Garfield's Spidey into the MCU. Can it really be that hard to do?!?
Steven on Feb 10, 2015
24
Iko uwais? That will be a bonecrushing spiderman!
ari smulders on Feb 10, 2015
25
Please don't do the origin story again. Please!
Nielsen700 on Feb 10, 2015
26
Sigh.. this is such bullshit. I liked Garfield as spiderman. Why did they decide to recast again? It wasn't his fault those movies sucked. Weren't they thinking of bringing back Tobey?
timnimbus on Feb 10, 2015
27
I think that Thomas Brodie-Sangster would be an awesome Peter Parker. He is right there with Dylan O'Brien though in the Maze Runner franchise. But if he had the opening in the schedule and a convincing enough american accent, he would be perfect.
Maxx on Feb 10, 2015
28
Andrew Garfield.
Xerxexx on Feb 10, 2015
29
Find a way to work it out with Garfield. He is a BEAST playing Spider-Man.
Buzz Killington on Feb 10, 2015
30
Donald Glover
mooreworthy on Feb 10, 2015
31
Excited for Spidey finally being a part of the MCU, but I'm not sure I'm ready for yet another origin re-telling.
jygsaw on Feb 10, 2015
32
I have to say that I too would have been more than happy with Garfield. Why can't they just through him in there?
ProjectionistHP on Feb 10, 2015
33
Lord....is this the best? Only way is down after Garfield. Perfect choice, bad films
Have Hope on Feb 10, 2015
34
Garfield is a way superior Spider-man than Maguire. Imagine if Garfield was in Raimi's Spiderman 2?
ragethorn on Feb 10, 2015
35
Andrew Garfield, John Gallagher Jr., Joseph Gordon-Levitt, or cast an unknown. THERE MARVEL I SOLVED YOUR MOVIE.
Giothegiant on Feb 10, 2015
36
yeah, they really should just keep Garfield. After watching ASM2 again and delving into the deleted scenes, he's pretty great as both Spider-Man and Pater Parker. That movie just was edited and conceived rather poorly. The deleted scenes add so much that seemed missing the first go round. #keepgarfield
daneforst on Feb 10, 2015
37
Thomas Mann
Lady Kaede on Feb 10, 2015
38
He'll be black I guarantee it. Marvel/DC has been all about political correctness as of late, and changing the race and sex of characters. Regardless of what the fans want they'll do what Sony's doing with Ghostbusters, and take a shit on the fans to push a message and or an agenda.
Billy Beefcaked on Feb 10, 2015
39
Choosing to change the race or sex of a character has nothing to do with political correctness. It's to take a story or storyline to different places that a white male storyline can only go so far with.
same on Feb 10, 2015
40
It's destroying the past and rewriting history, to appease the PC crowd.
Ray Rotello on Feb 20, 2015
41
except there is a black iteration of spiderman named mike morales and donald glover/any other black actor but mainly donald glover would be quite literally flawless. it has nothing to do with political correctness, and everything to do with the incredible likeness an actor has to a role. (for reference, however, captain america can be black, thor can be a woman and i can't remember what else they've changed)
mindie on Feb 11, 2015
42
I'd forgotten that being white was a vital part of Spiderman's character
Zak on Feb 12, 2015
43
I really love Garfield as Spidey, but I hear he told a bunch of executives at Sony to fuck off during filimg of ASM2 so I think he burned that bridge.
MattPeloquin on Feb 10, 2015
44
Yeah, for real, just keep Garfeild. He's good, he's really really good.
Jameson Cyr on Feb 10, 2015
45
no, thanks.
jonidimo on Feb 10, 2015
46
IKO Uwais best fighter,,, he is suited to plays a spiderman.. try you see in the movie the raid.
brandut on Feb 11, 2015
47
ANDREW GARFIELD. Or Glover or Yelchin.
si1ver on Feb 11, 2015
48
Just Keep, ANDREW GARFIELD. NO reboot!
HerCar on Feb 11, 2015
49
All of these choices are awful.
Brian Douglas Macleod on Feb 11, 2015
50
Adam Brody should be considered. His role in the OC was practically Peter Parker without the mask. Besides: http://24.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_lxybuuZzvn1r9mnljo1_r1_250.gif
Chrisscros on Feb 11, 2015
51
PETER PARKER IS FUNNY. HE ISNT COOL. HE ISNT HIP. HE'S FUNNY. HE'S A SMART ALICK. HES CHARMING. THATS HIS SCHTICK. TOBEY WAS NERDY. GARFIELD ALMOST HAD IT. BUT YOU NEED A FUNNY, CHARMING, YOUNG!! KID. SPIDER MAN IS A KID. NONE OF THESE SUFFICE. HE'S BACK WITH MARVEL NOW. THEY BETTER NOT FUCK THIS UP.
jonnyb61 on Feb 11, 2015
52
mr.bean,,, maybe 🙂
FAIZAL HARIZT on Feb 12, 2015
53
damn i love your comment. LOL
Aris Putra on Feb 12, 2015
54
please,, im not gay :p ,, vote rowan atkinson for Spidey
FAIZAL HARIZT on Feb 13, 2015
55
Dylan O'Brian!
Denny Saputra on Feb 11, 2015
56
great
Prince on Feb 11, 2015
57
Dylan O'Brien is the best actor. He is funny, energetic, cool and attractive.
Prince on Feb 11, 2015
58
I hope it is another unknown actor. I hope they are really young. Like 17 or 18. Let them age into the role for the next 10 years of his life.
DAVIDPD on Feb 12, 2015
59
I very happy when hear Iko include in the actors that consider for Marvel & Sony new Amazing Spiderman. I am so proud as Indonesian people. He's so strong, fast, and flexible. If he doesn't play as Spiderman at least he can be the stunt. He will be the next "Jackie Chan" from Indonesia
Govinda's NewDevide on Feb 12, 2015
60
what about The first Iko Uwais from Indonesia mate? he can be himself tho
wowdoge69 on Feb 12, 2015
61
Iko Uwais? really? i'm Indonesian but seriously he doesn't speak english very well....
Edgar Reza on Feb 12, 2015
62
This is absurd , Chuck Norris should be in there !
Andri Agam on Feb 12, 2015
63
iko uwais
raihan akbar F on Feb 12, 2015
64
Spideman, they rebooted it too much. just like bible. vote no for iko wais by the way
chimera28 on Feb 12, 2015
65
Jason Statham lol
wowdoge69 on Feb 12, 2015
67
i think IKO Uwais is suited to be a spiderman..
Aldi W on Feb 12, 2015
68
Iko Uwais should be the next Spiderman.
Ryan Adikara on Feb 12, 2015
69
iko Uwais the next spiderman !!!
robin ady setiawan on Feb 12, 2015
70
Not Jaden Smith for sure. He's already looks high without the suit.
Jonno on Feb 12, 2015
71
Iko uwais.. well even if i'm indonesian, but i don't think he's capable for it. His english is not fluent enough, and i don't think he's that good in acting. Plus, he's asian. It's no way he'll be the lead actor. My vote goes to Dylan O'Brien !!!
kirinstress on Feb 12, 2015
72
agree... maybe as stuntman or another villain.... it was sad to hear andrew'll not act as spiderman. He is better than tobey so far
Fachri Siddik on Feb 14, 2015
73
Yes it's cool enough if he able to became spidey's stuntman. At least, he can get a great chance to learn from hollywood a-list director 🙂 i'll pray for that. Btw, imo, tobey is still better than andrew to portray spiderman :p tobey's geeky look as peter parker is more believable, and more lovable too.
kirinstress on Feb 16, 2015
74
Iko Uwais should be the next VENOM..not Spiderman vote Dylan O'Brien 😀
Bayu Satrio Nugroho on Feb 12, 2015
75
Vote for Dylan, it just seems right to see him as Parker after Andrew departed, but Iko is more suited for suit actor than as Parker, so Dylan as Parker and Iko as Spider-Man suit actor, that would be nice!
Ivan Azzam on Feb 13, 2015
76
Dylan would need to start working out because Iko has bigger muscles than he does. It would just look weird if one has bigger arms than the other.
Gordon Mordecai Searles on Feb 20, 2015
77
Well, although Iko has the muscle, but i think he doesn't have the right feel to be Spidey, my ideal version is, the suit actor is Iko, and the face of Parker with Dylan, kinda like Japanese show (Kamen Rider/Ultraman), i agree though with your point, with Dylan working out and stuff
Ivan Azzam on Feb 24, 2015
78
iko uwais the really man
MWN Ngguf on Feb 13, 2015
79
Vote for Dylan.
Cynthia Cecilia on Feb 13, 2015
80
iko uwais
Rahmat Sam on Feb 14, 2015
81
Iko Uwais is best for the movie in the world. i like it
Rahmat Sam on Feb 14, 2015
82
Taron Egerton.
Dimius on Feb 14, 2015
83
Ein Durchbruch schaffte das "Iko Uwais", die grosse Abenteuer versprechen und ist ein spannendes Action Abenteuer.
Guest on Feb 15, 2015
84
Ein Durchbruch für "Iko Uwais", die grosse Abenteuer versprechen und ist ein spannendes Action Abenteuer. Ich mag es !!
yongky mr on Feb 15, 2015
85
It's going be the black guy, no need to vote
Johnnie Hudson on Feb 15, 2015
86
So PC it's sickening.
Ray Rotello on Feb 20, 2015
87
The only one I have seen in any thing is Glover and he is a worse choice for spiderman than Jordan was for the Human Torch and that is saying a lot
angry american on Feb 21, 2015
88
All of your choices are truly terrible but Glover is just a stupid dumbass choice
angry american on Feb 21, 2015
89
Jaden Smith... that would be pretty cool.
ZenaLundgren on Mar 4, 2015
90
how about none of these
Justin on Mar 5, 2015
91
The thing about Spiderman, is that the actor needs to play two characters. Peter Parker, the nerd who's life is changed by spidy powers, and Spiderman, the cocky, whimsical hero who is great at bantering with villains. So these guys could all make great a great Spiderman... but I have a really hard time believing any of them as Peter. That was the problem with The Amazing Spiderman. He simply was way too cool to be Peter, which ruined the fact that he was an absolutely terrific Spiderman. When he put's on the mask, he's no longer Peter. He convinces himself he isn't a geeky high-schooler. He isn't Peter, he's Spiderman now, the he hero everyone loves and adores. Also... Spiderman is in High School... half these guys are far too old.
Jaycen Zimbeck on Mar 6, 2015
92
Vote for dylan
Henny Tjandra on Mar 13, 2015
93
iko uwais.. iko , I think it would be able to do so . he has the agility in the fight. don't doubt Indonesian!
Al Fątih Ąrmštronģ on Mar 16, 2015
94
i think it could be dylan ,, but i hope he can face a rival or enemy such as iko that has great ability in fighting.....
Tommy Amin Santoso on Apr 11, 2015
95
Vote for Iko Uwais
latifah nuramadhani on Apr 11, 2015
96
i want Iko uwais is so cool
Aldoskateblackfast Ngablu on Jul 25, 2015
97
Iko uwais, Its Perfect to spidey ..
Rizki on Jul 27, 2015
98
He good for speak english language
Rizki on Jul 27, 2015
New comments are no longer allowed on this post.
FEATURED POSTS
FOLLOW FS HERE
Follow Alex's main account on Twitter:
Add our posts to your Feedly › click here
Get all the news sent on Telegram 
LATEST TO WATCH