The Top 7 Directors Who Could Replace Ben Affleck on 'The Batman'
by Dan Marcus
January 31, 2017
The trades were predicting it for a few weeks. Ben Affleck was even hinting at it for a while. Now it's official. Warner Bros and Ben Affleck announced together on Monday night that Ben Affleck will not be directing The Batman movie as previously planned. Affleck will remain on the project as a producer and star. With Affleck no longer directing the film, there's already a long list of possible candidates who could replace him. Variety reports that Warner Bros already has a shortlist, and there's going to be immense speculation as to who will be on that list. So we decided to put together our own dream list of directors who could replace Affleck on The Batman and make a kick ass, dark, yet different movie about the World's Greatest Detective.
Some of the top directors working today are going to be meeting with Warner Bros executives over the next couple weeks for the coveted gig. You can bet directing the next Batman film is going to be a hot commodity for many directors, no matter if they are industry veterans or newcomers to Hollywood with only a couple of indies on their belt. After all, Christopher Nolan had only directed a couple of films before Warner Bros hired him to direct Batman Begins back in 2003. So, with that in mind, let's take a look at some of our picks of the best candidates who could replace Affleck as director on The Batman. Here are the 7 we recommend:
#1 - Matt Reeves
War for the Planet of the Apes director Matt Reeves is the first person to be on that shortlist, which makes sense given Reeves' history of tackling tentpole films such as the Planet of the Apes remakes with style and artful sophistication. Reeves was also on the shortlist to direct Man of Steel before Zack Snyder was hired to helm the superhero origin story. Reeves got his start directing found footage movie Cloverfield for producer J.J. Abrams. He then honed his talent with the American remake of Let Me In in 2010. Reeves proved he could bring an enormous amount of nuance and subtlety to this story, directing a remake many thought was on par or even superior to the original. He has further honed his skills with the Planet of the Apes films, blending artistry and big budget spectacle with aplomb. Reeves would be an excellent choice to tackle the Dark Knight, bringing a certain level of gravitas that would more than elevate Geoff Johns' screenplay.
#2 - Mira Nair
This is a name you probably won't find on any other list of candidates for The Batman. Truth be told, most Warner Bros executives probably won't even be thinking of Mira Nair. However, she's a very capable and talented director who has been consistently making great films since the 70's. She's been gradually making a name for herself in the States with New York, I Love You, Vanity Fair and The Namesake. Nair has been branching out lately, having directed the suspense thriller The Reluctant Fundamentalist in 2012 starring Riz Ahmed and Kiefer Sutherland. Nair's most recent film, Queen of Katwe, received plenty of positive buzz last year. Nair is the kind of bold choice that would make a very interesting, compelling and different kind of Batman film. Warner Bros has prided themselves with being a filmmaker-driven studio, so by hiring Nair it would be embracing that by giving a filmmaker like Nair a chance to spread her creative wings. She may feel like an out-of-left-field choice, but at the time so were Christopher Nolan, Bryan Singer, Jon Favreau, etc.
#3 - David Fincher
The most obvious choice to helm a Batman movie will be David Fincher, who has made a name for himself directing stylish, gritty and dark crime thrillers such as Se7en, Fight Club and The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo. Fincher has been up for superhero movies before. For a while he was in consideration to direct The Amazing Spider-Man, but took himself out of consideration not before long. Fincher has gone on record saying he doesn't really like superhero movies, saying "I find [them] dull." However, the appeal of reuniting with Gone Girl co-star Ben Affleck might make directing The Batman a more appealing prospect for the notoriously picky director. Fincher would be an excellent choice, bringing his artistic precision and knack for impressive imagery to the Dark Knight with effortless skill. It would be up to Fincher himself if he truly wanted the gig or not. If he did, there would be no doubt he could deliver a truly outstanding Batman film.
#4 - Denis Villeneuve
Denis Villeneuve is also someone who is very likely already on WB's shortlist. Villeneuve had an amazing year in 2016 with the science-fiction film Arrival, garnering eight Academy Award nominations including Best Director for Villeneuve himself. The talented auteur has Blade Runner 2049 coming out later this year and has been attached to remake Dune for Legendary. The prospect of directing Dune may make Villeneuve unavailable to direct The Batman, but given his relationship with Warner Bros – which is distributing Blade Runner 2049 – you can bet he'll at least be considered. Villeneuve is another outstanding visualist, who would no doubt bring a sense of understated artistry to Batman. He has never done an outright action film before, so his style may not meld with a superhero film. However, if WB is looking to take a risk, hiring Villeneuve would be a surefire way to ensure this next Batman would be well-received by critics and fans.
#5 - Gavin O'Connor
Gavin O'Connor, who most recently directed Ben Affleck in The Accountant in 2016, will likely also be in consideration. He's experienced and he's done action films before, so he has shown he has the chops for the gig. The only snag is that O'Connor is currently attached to directing a Green Hornet reboot for Paramount. You can bet O'Connor would leave that project in a heartbeat if it meant tackling the Caped Crusader, however. O'Connor may not be the most inspired choice, but he has proven he can work well with Affleck, produce results and get the job done. His film Warrior, co-starring Batman alum Tom Hardy, was a riveting display of heartfelt bravado. O'Connor definitely has what it takes to make a sufficient Batman film. The real question will be if he'll be able to deliver the kind of Batman movie that WB, Affleck and fans will demand.
#6 - Duncan Jones
Another name who you can expect to be rumored a lot will be Duncan Jones. Jones has been up for a fair amount of blockbusters before. He was even in consideration to direct Man of Steel before Zack Snyder took the job. Jones' last movie, Warcraft, did incredible box office overseas despite not clicking with audiences here in the States. Regardless, Jones has some major geek cred having directed the indie darling Moon, so he'll be mentioned quite a few times until a director is officially announced. He'll probably reject it, though, as he did Man of Steel. Jones has said before he wants to make a name for himself doing smaller projects, such as his upcoming sci-fi film Mute. Then again, Jones did direct Warcraft, a huge blockbuster, so he might be more inclined to tackle the Caped Crusader with that experience under his belt. He proved with Moon he can handle heady themes and dramatic narratives with ease. Source Code proved he can handle an A-list star, a riveting story and stellar visual effects. Jones surely has the sensibilities to make a tremendous Batman movie. It boils down to whether or not he'll have the desire to jump into the blockbuster ring again.
#7 - Darren Aronofsky
Darren Aronofsky will also be a director that will be brought up a lot as well. Aronofsky has had a storied history with the Dark Knight, having been attached to helm an adaptation of Frank Miller's dark graphic novel Batman: Year One almost two decades ago. Aronofsky was at one point slated to direct The Wolverine starring Hugh Jackman, but bowed out to direct Noah. It's unsure if Aronofsky still has any desire to make a superhero movie, but Batman is a perfect fit for his darker, more psychological tendencies. Aronofsky has proven he can handle Batman's darker nature with such films as Requiem for a Dream and Black Swan, which is why he was under consideration all those years ago before Christopher Nolan was tapped to direct. He's also proven he can handle a blockbuster after Noah performed well overseas when it was released in 2014. Similar to Jones, it will depend entirely on if Aronofsky actually wants the job. He ended up leaving The Wolverine because he wanted to make Noah instead. Time will tell if Aronofsky still has any desire to bring his dark and gritty sensibilities to the Dark Knight. If he chooses to do so, however, you can bet he'll deliver a movie that could rival Christopher Nolan's trilogy when it comes down to psychological darkness.
No matter who directs, they'll be tackling a project that has been under a lot of media scrutiny. Ben Affleck was under an intense amount of pressure to deliver a Batman film that lived up to Nolan's previous trilogy. Affleck even stated: "I'm sure that's going to be the most pressure, the most stress I have ever experienced in my professional life." That was before he even started a single day of filming. While his performance in Batman v Superman: Dawn of Justice was praised by most fans and critics alike, his portrayal had a more divisive reaction from fans. Affleck's Batman was older, wearier – but also considerably more violent, killing people with little regard or consequence. The reactions to Suicide Squad weren't any better, so whoever ends up directing The Batman has big expectations to manage, including a divisive fanbase to keep at bay.
If DC's Wonder Woman and Justice League movies are big hits, then that will help things considerably. If both flop and/or under-perform – and early rumors have suggested both could be “disasters" – then it will make directing The Batman an even bigger challenge for whoever is chosen to direct. With that kind of pressure, it makes sense Affleck wanted to drop out. It also makes dropping out of starring in a Batman movie easier if WB doesn't have a good summer. The Batman is still currently slated to begin production by this summer, depending if someone gets hired soon enough to inherit the keys to the Batmobile and can keep the engine running. Whoever gets those keys will have to navigate an already bumpy road, and a possibly even bumpier road ahead. Fortunately the Dark Knight is accustomed to dealing with rough terrain.
Let's hope whoever Warner Bros chooses to lead the Dark Knight on his next epic adventure is equipped to handle some bumps in the road as well. We'll know soon. So who do you want to direct The Batman?
Reader Feedback - 25 Comments
I read some interviews from denis that he said he wont do superhero movies because thats not his world, and doesnt know how to approach it, but he very well knows the world of sifis like dune, and also he likes to have complete ownership of his movies like he had for Arrival, but warner bros havent give him the directors cut for blade runner 2049 yet... and he has probably seen what happened to BvS, so...I think he is not going to do that in this situation.
Arghavanf on Jan 31, 2017
Darren would be a huge get and pretty cool. I do not think he would do it, but damn that is an interesting pick.
DAVIDPD on Jan 31, 2017
Ben should just pull a Andrew Garfield and get the fuck out of this shit mess.
Ben Moore on Jan 31, 2017
Would be really interesting to see what Fincher could do.
Efterklang on Jan 31, 2017
Fincher is the man. I need to see a Fincher superhero movie.
tarek on Jan 31, 2017
I would love that also, but I don't think studios would give him the freedom with a huge budget he would want.
eris on Feb 3, 2017
Mira Nair...wtf?? Definitely not someone I would have ever considered for a blockbuster level movie. I have my doubts any of these big name directors will be drawn to the movie after Affleck's sudden departure from the director's chair. I just dont buy the story that Affleck all of a sudden had a hard time with juggling writer, producer, star and director when he's done it on other movies. To me it sounds like the studio has a vision that clashes with Affleck's ideas and he stepped out of the director's chair as to not be solely responsible for a poor product. I also expect his writing duties on the film to slowly fade away and at best he gets a writing credit.
desispeed on Jan 31, 2017
I think what happened was "Live By Night"...
kitano0 on Feb 1, 2017
agree on that too....that movie was damn forgettable...cant believe Affleck was invovled with it
desispeed on Feb 1, 2017
Maybe he was "overinvolved"...
kitano0 on Feb 1, 2017
Also his stipulation of there needing to be a good script before he was going to direct i am sure is an issue here. They care more for deadlines then they do for producing a good product.
eris on Feb 3, 2017
Really dumb choices.
Nielsen700 on Feb 1, 2017
I honestly don't really care too much who directs this....as long as the script is decent we should be okay. Affleck is still (allegedly) producing.... ...and Denis Villeneuve just singed on for the Dune remake, so we can take him off the list
TheOct8pus on Feb 1, 2017
Do we really need another Dune!?
Sky on Feb 1, 2017
I don't think so, but many would disagree....the David Lynch movie left a lot to be desired (not to mention its effects don't really stand up today) and I guess the TV miniseries - which was more faithful to the book - didn't have the budget necessary for an "epic" movie.... Besides, as long as someone owns the rights to a bestseller, they're going to milk it as long as they can...
TheOct8pus on Feb 1, 2017
Steven Lewis on Feb 1, 2017
Personally, I am ready for a real kick-ass Batman movie...more of the same type of action we saw in "BvsS" (you know the sequence I'm talking about,) i'm all for the broody, and the "Greatest Detective" angle...but let's have great fight scenes and action. My out of left-field pick is Peter Berg...
kitano0 on Feb 1, 2017
I agree with everything except your Peter Berg choice, although my favorite of his was Hancock.
RAW_D on Feb 2, 2017
Please let it be Fincher!
Cyberdine on Feb 1, 2017
I'm betting it won't be Fincher for the same reason it won't be Aronofsky. Too commercial. My guess (from this list) Matt Reeves, Duncan Jones or Denis Villeneuve. All three have tackled franchises and know what's at stake. My hope is that it would be Denis Villeneuve or Reeves.
RAW_D on Feb 2, 2017
New director won't fix the core issue of a shitty script and meddling studio execs. Best thing for any of these directors is to stay as far away from this shit show as possible.
Dan Hibiki on Feb 2, 2017
I was totally trying to reply but posted a new, your 100% right. Jeez. You guys would have em remake the Mona Lisa given the chance. No one I truly mean no one could provide a better trilogy story from conception to end with the darkness, actors, dedication, and mind bending reach that Nolan has. It's all about the money today which we all just address but its going to happen anyways so i digress and accept. To further insult this great hero we loose the core reason why we love him in 1 film. 1 film after Nolan and he's already lost the moral compass and values instilled since his inception. So because he got older and people now have abilities he's cool with almost anything.....This will be fun to play out but my wish list to direct would be for someone to take the job and then play Batman Begins for the premiere....Now that would be fun. In all seriousness Aronofsky has the mind for it but it's too big to tackle for him alone. Fincher would be the best off this list but it wouldn't come out for a decade because he's so meticulous which I love. The guy who amazes me is Ridley, he can conceptualize a film, set dates make decisions and for the most part there always good but he doesn't have what it takes either. I'd say Fincher or bust.....Either way it'll bust but we strive because hope is fickle.
ari on Feb 3, 2017
Jeez. You guys would have em remake the Mona Lisa given the chance. No one I truly mean no one could provide a better trilogy story from conception to end with the darkness, actors, dedication, and mind bending reach that Nolan has. It's all about the money today which we all just address but its going to happen anyways so i digress and accept. To further insult this great hero we loose the core reason why we love him in 1 film. 1 film after Nolan and he's already lost the moral compass and values instilled since his inception. So because he got older and people now have abilities he's cool with almost anything.....This will be fun to play out but my wish list to direct would be for someone to take the job and then play Batman Begins for the premiere....Now that would be fun. In all seriousness Aronofsky has the mind for it but it's too big to tackle for him alone. Fincher would be the best off this list but it wouldn't come out for a decade because he's so meticulous which I love. The guy who amazes me is Ridley, he can conceptualize a film, set dates make decisions and for the most part there always good but he doesn't have what it takes either. I'd say Fincher or bust.....Either way it'll bust but we strive because hope is fickle.
ari on Feb 3, 2017
Bring in the guy that did first Kickass movie.
Zack Smith on Feb 3, 2017
Sorry, no commenting is allowed at this time.